Clifford Irving's Legal Novels - 02 - FINAL ARGUMENT - a Legal Thriller (25 page)

“I have to go,” I said.

“Your wife is expecting you?”

I had seen Connie as a beautiful older woman having an exciting affair, and not her first. I had seen myself as a man in thrall. Then, from what seemed one moment to the next, the net had lifted. The roles had reversed.

I couldn’t tell her that. She wanted to hear words of love and regret deeper than the earth. But I didn’t have such feelings. I felt sad —and I felt on the edge of an extraordinary freedom. I will soar. Then maybe crash. But survive.

“Goodbye, Connie.”

She clutched at me, and a harsh sound rose from her throat. She let go of me, turned, and toppled into the pool.

A white parachute floated on the disturbed surface of the water. There were bubbles, circles of foam. The parachute slowly sank. A woman’s body was attached to it. I heard sucking sounds, like soapy water swirling down an emptying bathtub drain. The bottoms of my trousers were drenched.

Rescue was definitely required, and I jumped in after her, the soles of my shoes striking soundlessly on the bottom of the pool. I was in about four feet of chlorinated water. I heard many dogs barking in excitement.

Connie was heaved out of the pool by her erstwhile hero—waterlogged, breathing like a half-drowned cat, but alive. A uniformed brown-skinned Latino maid about four and a half feet tall emerged from the house and waddled over, smiling cautiously. The expression on her face said: the Señora sure is a fun-lovin’ lady.

I explained that Mrs. Zide had fainted and fallen in the pool. The maid looked disbelieving, but she stayed calm.

“What is your name?” I asked.

“Martina.” Later, during the murder investigation, I learned that she was from the city of León on the high central plateau of Mexico.

Martina and I hauled Connie through the French doors into the living room and onto a twelve-foot-long sofa next to a marble backgammon table. The white Berber carpet and the sofa were quickly soaked.

Looking up, Connie said quietly, “I’m all right.”

Martina asked me if she should call a doctor.

“No. Take Mrs. Zide up to her bedroom. Bring bath towels and dry clothes. Is there other help around?”

“I will call the security guard,” Martina said.

“Yes. Do that. Goodbye, Connie.”

She coughed and spat water on the carpet. Then I backed out of the room, the house, and her life.

When I got home twenty minutes later, Toba stared and asked, “What the hell happened to you?”

“If I told you, you wouldn’t believe me.”

“Try me—you never know.”

“I had to go to someone’s house to talk to a witness in an extortion case. The woman fell backward into her pool. I jumped in and fished her out.”

“That sounds like something that could happen,” Toba said. “Why shouldn’t I believe it? Any man who would eat a whole banana would jump into a pool to save a woman who fell in backward.”

At the University of Florida, about the time we began the affair that would lead to marriage, I had discovered that Toba liked to eat parts of fruits and rarely the whole. In her fridge I often found half an apple, or a pear with a slice missing. When I reminded her of that, she always looked annoyed. Finally, one evening in my bachelor apartment, she said to me, “Can I have a third of one of your bananas?”

I rolled my eyes and looked at her as if she were demented.

“Stop that,” Toba said. “Do I make fun of you when you eat a whole one?”

Then I knew that I loved her and could make a life with her. She wasn’t simply being cute or lovable; in the season of my youthful ardor she was exhibiting to me a sophisticated sense of justice, promising balance and good cheer. Ten years later, in the kitchen of our home, holding her in my arms against my wet and wrinkled suit, free from whatever spell Connie Zide had woven around my heart, I vowed in my heart to be truly good to her.

I called Connie the next day to ask if she was all right. She thanked me for rescuing her from the pool. “I must have had too much sun.”

There was an awkward pause.

“Well, goodbye again,” I said.

“Yes. Goodbye again.”

I couldn’t believe it was that simple.

A week later, one morning when I was in court, Solly Zide called and left a message with my secretary. I returned the call later that afternoon. I imagined only the worst.

Zide said, “I was going to ask you to lunch to discuss this, but now I’m tied up for the rest of this week and the next. Anyway, it’s not me you need to talk to.” He told me about the opening at Royal, Kelly, Green & Wellmet in Sarasota.

“If I were in your shoes,” he said flatly, “I would take advantage of the opportunity. Nothing better will ever happen to you.”

Was that a threat? Did he mean that
worse
things could happen? Did he mean leave Jacksonville or else? I wondered but never asked. Would never have the chance to ask, either. The next time I saw Solly Zide was two months later at the benefit black-tie musicale. The host, in his white dinner jacket, was surrounded by guests. We spoke a few words as we passed each other by the side of the pool, just a few feet from the spot where Connie had toppled in. Zide was crisp in his manner but not unfriendly. He had a lot on his mind, I assumed. There was no way of knowing what that was, although one day I was destined to find out. Seven hours later he was dead.

Chapter 19

BELDON SHUFFLED ACROSS his office to dump some wilting red roses into the only wastebasket that had space. Then he turned on me and said, “You’ve got some fucking nerve, Jaffe.”

He had never called me by my last name before. There was a warning there.

Next to his diplomas and police department citations for bravery hung the motto of the Justice Department, proclaiming that the government wins its point whenever justice is done. I waved at it and said, “If you believe that, you won’t stand in the way of my representing Darryl Morgan.”

“You can’t defend someone you once prosecuted!” Beldon snarled. “You
know
that!”

“No, I don’t. The State of Florida is an entity. How can it claim confidentiality and privilege?”

“Cops told you everything they knew. Prosecution witnesses talked freely to you. You can’t switch sides, damn it!”

“Elroy didn’t tell me then that he was lying. He told me twelve years later.”

“He’s your client now, isn’t he?”

“But now he’s agreed to testify that he lied about hearing Morgan confess.” I didn’t dare admit that I’d conned him into it by calling it part of the deal offered down in Sarasota. “Beldon, I told you the last time we discussed this—it was not a fair trial.”

“And I disagreed. And what have you told me to make me change my mind? Shit!”

“I think Floyd Nickerson perjured himself too.”

“Since when does ‘think’ count in a court of law?”

“I may have a witness.”

“Who?”

“I can’t tell you.”

“Oh? Now we’re being cute? Is this all a bluff? You bored down there in Sarasota?”

“Let me ask you a question,” I said. “Why are you scared of this thing being retried?”

“Wait a minute!” Beldon yelped. “Who’s talking about a
re
trial here? We’re talking about a motion, that’s all. Justice might—just
might
—require a hearing before the judge, if only to save this dude from the electric chair and put him in Raiford for life. But if it ever comes to a whole new trial, there is no way that justice requires your presence. CCR can do it. Two or three people over at Kenny’s office are capable of doing it. You are emphatically not the right man to do it. This is for a guy who likes to get off by himself and sniff dust and stick his nose in books.”

“Will you let me handle a motion and an appeal hearing?”

“You think I’m gonna say yes because we’re friends?”

“The bayou dog who gave me my first job took me to lunch at The Jury Room and said, ‘You’re not supposed to win any friends at this kind of job.’ “

“So what will you do if I say no? Pout and cry?”

I locked eyes with him. “I’ll fight you all the way. I’ll yell ‘cover- up.’ The Florida Bar will probably bring charges and try to kick me out. I’ll fight them too. There’ll be a big fuss in the newspapers and on TV. In the end I probably won’t be able to do the case, but someone else will, and you’ll look like an Uncle Tom who wanted to fry a black kid who shot a rich white entrepreneur. You’ll look like shit. Come next election, you may lose.”

Beldon guffawed. “You think I care if I look like shit and lose an election?”

“Probably not.”

“Well, you’re wrong,” he said. He pointed a finger at me, and somehow his mood had changed. “See, you don’t know everything, do you?”He was silent for a few moments, thinking things over. “Okay,” he said, “I’ll tell you. Horace Fleming’s finally retiring next January, when he’s eighty, and the governor wants to give me Horace’s court. Still be three and a half years left on the term.”

“Judge Ruth?”

“How about that? You know, I never knew I wanted it until Horace hinted and Tallahassee made me the offer. I guess I’m tired of working a ten-hour day, and I’m tired of the phone ringing on Sundays and just about every time I sit down to dinner with Laurette. I asked Horace, ‘What do you do on weekends?’ He said, ‘Fish, go squirrel hunting, sleep a lot, mess with my great-grandkids.’ Sure sounded good to me.”

“And who wants a judge starting out with shit on his face?” I asked.

“Right. So I’ll make a deal with you. You handle your motion for Morgan, assuming you’re rich enough and crazy enough to waste all that time. The state attorney’s office won’t object. If you win— meaning if Horace grants a new trial for Morgan—you step down. Let another lawyer do it. Get the hell back to Sarasota where you belong. For your sake, believe me, not mine. Is that a deal?”

One step at a time. I shook the offered hand and said, “Toba and my law partners will certainly be grateful to you, Judge.”

But at the door, Beldon put his other hand on my arm. I felt a slight trembling in the fingers.

“You’re not telling me everything,” he said.

“About what?” He couldn’t mean my con job on Elroy; he had no way of even guessing at that.

“Your private life’s your own business, asshole. I’m talking about this case. Something else is happening here. Else why would you be so anxious to do it?”

I didn’t answer.

“It’s not evidence,” Beldon said. “You’d tell me if you had more evidence, wouldn’t you?”

“No, it’s not evidence,” I said.

“But it’s a little more than a hunch.”

“A little more.”

“You gonna keep me guessing like a fool?”

“I have to, Beldon. We’re not partners in this one.” That was as diplomatic a way as I could phrase it.

I was smiling woodenly and trying to get out, but he still touched my arm. There was a message in the touch, and it held me.

“I know something too,” he said. He let the words hang there, like drifting tendrils of smoke.

Wary, I said, “About the case?”

“It’s not exculpatory. I wouldn’t fuck with you like that.”

I believed him.

He said, “It’s just something that makes me feel you shouldn’t be involved, not even at this level. So what I’m saying is, be judicious. Do what you think you have to do, but don’t go too far.”

“What is it you know?”

Beldon’s eyes were quiet with warning. “You can figure it out.”

He knew about Connie. It had to be that.

“Think about it,” he said. “Don’t be stubborn and get yourself hurt.” He lifted his fingers from my arm. It was as if a weight had been withdrawn.

Beldon had said, “ … if Horace grants a new trial.” That was because Judge Bill Eglin had retired from the bench and gone into politics. He was a state senator now, bringing all his enlightenment to bear on moral and legal issues in Tallahassee. Horace Fleming had inherited all his cases. The mandatory age for a Florida judge to retire was seventy. Horace Fleming was the only one I knew who had fought against that and won.

I asked Kenny Buckram if his presence on the bench was good or bad for me.

“It would have been good five years ago,” Kenny said. “Maybe even two or three. But Horace is an old man. He forgets things, he makes mistakes. It’s a weird courtroom. I’ll tell you one thing, though—it’s always interesting.”

The next day I drove the four hours to Tallahassee and spoke to the people at CCR. They were happy to have me take the case; they were always hunting for pro bono volunteers. I worked most of that evening in my room at the Ramada Inn and the next morning returned to Jacksonville.

Kenny made available to me the facilities of the public defender’s office, including its law library, newspaper files, and computerized case histories.

“I need a desk and a telephone extension.”

“We’ll also provide a chair and a sharp pencil. You can use our Xerox machine. Fifteen cents a page to everyone else. For rich lawyers like you, a dollar.”

That evening I took Muriel Suarez to dinner at my favorite seafood joint at the beach. Muriel dropped into a red plastic booth and said, “I’m bushed, so would you do me a favor? I’d like a vodka gibson with a twist straight up—that’s to revive me—and maybe some wine with dinner, but otherwise, you do the ordering. I eat everything that swims except jellyfish.”