Read The Philosopher's Pupil Online
Authors: Iris Murdoch
Tags: #Fiction, #Literary, #Biography & Autobiography, #Philosophers
They both rose, and kissed. Lips only touching, they hung together as if suspended in space. They remained so for a long moment.
âGoodbye, Alex. Soon, soon, you know. I'll take the rest of the sandwiches.'
âWhere are you going?'
âTo the cinema.'
However George did not go to the cinema. It was raining when he left Belmont, and he decided to go home to Druidsdale rather than walk to the Odeon in the High Street, which was farther away. George hated rain, he hated getting his hair wet, his feet wet, his clothes wet. He had no umbrella. He felt vaguely unwell and feverish. And he wanted to eat the rest of the sandwiches in peace. He wanted an
interval
in his existence, his life which had for some time been such intensely hard work. He felt, for the first time for months, that he might be able to
rest,
to do something which had seemed forever impossible, to lie down on his back and close his eyes and feel quiet and drowsy and unafraid and at peace. At the same time he felt excited and confused and odd. Something had snapped, had given way, and that was (was it not?) better. He did not want to examine the new state at all closely, he felt he would never want to examine anything closely again. He wanted to spend the rest of his life in
peace,
with people who did not examine things closely.
He reached Druidsdale and got the key into the lock. His hand trembled. He opened the door and entered the darkish hall. He stopped. There was something wrong. There was something there. Something
terrible.
He peered. Stella was sitting on the stairs.
âHello, George.'
âOh
God.
' George sat down on one of the chairs in the hall.
âI'm sorry to come suddenly.'
âWhy have you come at all? Why now, oh Christ, why
now?
'
âWell, it had to be sometime. I'm sorry it wasn't sooner.'
âYou cold - cold - beast.'
âI can't talk otherwise. You know how I talk. I can only say what's the case. I feel very upset, very emotional, not cold.'
âOther people have emotions. You say it's the case that you feel emotional.'
âI'm sorry I went away. I can't explain my conduct. Though there is an explanation. I just mean it would take some time, if you ever wanted to hear. Nothing dramatic, nothing interesting.'
âWhere have you been?'
âWith N, with Mrs Blackett.'
âN, that impotent voyeur, I thought so.'
âWhy?'
âI saw his sly old face in the street, he's always after me.'
âDon't be angry about that.'
âOh I'm not. Were you afraid to come back?'
âYes, I suppose so â '
âAfraid I'd kill you?'
âNo - just afraid of you - you're like a dog that bites - one is afraid. I don't like unpredictable things.'
âWhy have you come back then?'
âI had to decide whether I wanted to go on being married to you. That was another reason why I didn't come back. I felt it wouldn't be fair to you.'
âWhat wouldn't be fair?'
âTo come back and leave again.'
âAnd you decided â?'
âI decided I did want to go on being married to you.'
âWhy?'
âYou know why. Because I love you. Because I think - this between us is - absolute.'
âAbsolute, what a word. You always were an absolutist. You talk of love, you who have no tenderness, no gentleness, no forgiveness.'
âI have these things, but you just kill the expression of them, the way I would express them, you reject all my language, all my â '
âAlways my fault.'
âNo.'
âYou have never forgiven me anything. You remember every fault. You might as well be the recording angel. You are a sort of angel, a frightful one.'
âLet's not talk about forgiving, I think it's a weak idea, usually false â '
âYou're like Cordelia, the most overrated heroine in literature.'
âThe question is, do you want to go on being married to me?'
âWhat a charmingly blunt question. No.'
âAre you sure?'
George was silent for a moment. Then he said, âThat night - when the car went into the canal - can you remember it clearly?'
âYes.'
âWhat happened exactly?'
âWhat do you mean?'
âWas it an accident, or did I deliberately make it happen?'
âYou mean you don't remember?'
âNo.'
Stella paused. âIt was an accident.'
âIt was an accident?'
âYes, of course.' She added, âYou like to think of yourself as a fierce violent person, but you're harmless really. Just a bad-tempered dog.'
âAnd you claim to love this animal.'
âYes, I do.'
âYou humiliate me in order to love me. That's not love. It's like torturing your pet. The sort of thing that interests N.'
They sat silently in the darkish hallway, Stella on the stairs, George sitting near the door on a chair against the wall, not facing Stella but facing an old ornate Victorian hallstand which they had bought in an auction sale when they were engaged.
Stella said, âSee, I brought the netsuke back.'
George saw on the hallstand the little array of pale ivory figures. He said, âYes, I went looking for them one day.'
âI thought you would.'
âIsn't it rather sentimental of you to bring them back? The sort of thing a real woman might do. Am I supposed to be touched and softened?'
Stella was silent. She began to fumble in her handbag.
George said, âOh you aren't
crying
are you? Can you cry now? Congratulations. You never used to.' He added, âI've got a cold.'
âWant an aspirin?'
âNo. To answer your earlier question, yes, I am sure I don't want to go on being married to you.'
âWhy?'
âBecause I'm going to go and live in Spain with Diane Sedleigh.'
Stella was silent again. She blew her nose. She said, âAll right.'
âWhat. No scene?'
âYou know me.'
âYes I do. Diane is a woman. I like women. I get on with her. She makes me feel happy and calm. Which you have
never done.
'
âI'm sorry.'
âI admired you. That was the trouble. A rotten basis for marriage.'
âI daresay.'
âMaybe you shouldn't have gone away, I mean if you really wanted it to go on. I had time to see the point.'
âI wanted you to have time. And I needed a holiday from you too.'
âWell, the holiday can continue. What will you do with it?'
âI don't know. I'll travel. I'll go to Tokyo to see my father, go to California to see Rozanov.'
âYou'll -
what?
'
âWell, I might. I'd like to see him. I only kept away because of you. Or is he still here?'
George leapt to his feet.'
You'll talk to him about meâ¦
'
âIt might be difficult to avoid mentioning your name, but I won't discuss you. You know how fastidious I am in such matters.'
âFastidious, that's one of your words. How I loathe your vocabulary! It's power, power, contempt, contempt, everything about you. Oh God, why did you have to come back
now,
you
devil,
just when I was feeling better, you don't know what you've done, you've spoilt everything, you've destroyed it all, you did it on purpose, you heard I was with Diane at the funeral. Didn't you, didn't you?'
âYes. But that's not the reason.'
âIt is - it's common mean spite and jealousy - you can lie too, you foul vixen - I could kill you for spoiling things so - you want to destroy me - and you killed Rufus, you killed Rufus, you killed Rufusâ¦'
Father Bernard was sitting in his study in the St Paul's Clergy House meditating to the sound of Scott Joplin's
Sugar Cane.
He sat as usual, four-square, relaxed, his hands on his knees. He used to kneel once, but found the posture uncomfortable and fraught with irrelevant emotion. The unlined curtains put up by his predecessor were drawn and displayed, penetrated by the lurid rainy light of Saturday evening, a design of huge chrysanthemums. The room was filled with a subdued yellowish glow. In a corner of the room a dim electric lamp illumined a calm radiant icon of the baptism of Jesus. (Father Bernard did not care for the more tormented images.) Opposite to him, Father Bernard's Gandhara Buddha (a reproduction) meditated with drooped eyelids and delicate slightly pursed lips. His exquisitely beautiful austere face combined the calm of the East with a thoughtful Hellenic sadness. Father Bernard loved him because he was and was not a judge. He paid no attention to the priest and did not require to be addressed as âthou'. But Father Bernard, who did not always meditate with lowered eyelids, paid a great deal of attention to him.
Some teachers of meditation exhort us to empty our minds. Others permit the quiet circling of random thoughts, increasingly to be set at a distance and sensed as unreal. Father Bernard followed both rules, but more usually the latter which was easier because more ambiguous. He let his worldly thoughts accompany him sometimes to the extent that a detached observer of them (God, for instance) might have found little difference between the priest's holy reverie and the unregenerate day-dreaming of one of his flock.
On this Saturday evening Father Bernard's thoughts, somewhat tidied up for purposes of communication, might be rendered as follows. John Robert, what a monster, how attractive that frightful face is, I want so much to see him again, I'm quite in love with him, dear me. If only my life could change completely, be utterly renewed and changed. Lord, let me amend my life. If I could only reach a place beyond personal vanity, sometimes it seems so close, an inch away. Miss Dunbury said she saw Christ waiting on the other side, could she be right? Lord have mercy upon me, Christ have mercy upon me, Lord have mercy upon me. How moving simple faith is, Lord let me have a simple faith if it be thy will.
Quaerens me sedisti lassus.
I ought to go and see Hattie, I must see her before I see Rozanov, I was supposed to see her last Saturday, oh my God, last Saturday. Hattie, that milky-white flesh, like angel cake, no. What a nasty anonymous letter I had this morning about kissing prostitutes in church, there are spies everywhere. And on that bench with Bobbie, oh dear me. I like that bit in the music, it's such melancholy music, mechanical and yet jaunty, like life. Tom McCaffrey, his tumbling hair.
Dans l'onde toi devenue ta jubilation nue.
Yes, I spend my life wanting the impossible. But I never reach out my hand for what I want. Isn't that religion, not reaching out? O Lord Buddha, have mercy upon me, a sinner. George McCaffrey, may he be protected from evil and may he do no harm to anyone. Will he come to me?
Non ragioniam di lor, ma guarda e passa.
What a dreadful thing to say, how cruel Dante was and yet he was granted a vision of paradise. Pretty boring place, actually. But oh the desire for God, the desire, the desire.
Agnus dei, qui tollis peccata mundi, miserere nobis.
If I had walked across the bridge when George was miming the accident he would have killed me, exciting, what nonsense. Dear little Diane squatting down behind the elder tree. I'll have to go one day, the bishop's letter will come, Mount Athos, I'll live in retreat at last. John Robert said I was false, a false priest, broken my vows. I suppose so. Not that anybody cares what a priest believes these days, but I do. Have to come to it at last. At last. I wonder if Diane would come with me to Greece, she wouldn't mind what I did, what a crazy idea. Bobbie's coming tonight, I hope he's got rid of that cold, thank God I don't seem to have caught it, a pity he's so unattractive. Have a nice talk, wine, oh blast I forgot to buy that cheap Valpolicella. I shall lie in the earth. Every year I pass the anniversary of my death. Where will I lie? In Greece? In America? Perhaps I shall follow Rozanov, I suppose he'll go back there. An impossible man. How sad the yellow light is in this room, and a fly on the window. How beautiful he is, the Lord Buddha, so austere, so stern, so sad. George and Rozanov. Oh God, help them, help us all, help the planet. The lonely circling planet moving into night. God rest all souls. I am tense, I must relax, forgive. Not think about Rozanov, Tom, Mount Athos. Oh the desire. Oh God, if only I could be at peace. Lord, I prostrate myself, I ask for forgiveness, for guidance, for faith. My Lord and my God. Tomorrow's Sunday, damn.
The front door bell rang. The priest sighed. He rose and turned off Scott Joplin. He bowed reverently and kissed the stern Buddha on the brow and the lips. Then with slow majestic tread, smoothing his hair, he went to the door. George McCaffrey was outside.
âCome in,' said Father Bernard. And after a glance at George he thought, this is it.
George followed the priest into the study. Father Bernard did not draw back the curtains. He switched on a lamp.
âSit down, George. There, on that sofa.'
George sat down, then got up again and walked to the bookcase, facing it but not looking at the books. There was something dreadful in the position, as if he were expecting to be shot in the back. Then he turned and leaned against the bookcase, facing the priest who was also standing. Love for George flooded Father Bernard's heart.
âWhat is it, my son?'
George was silent for a while, looking rather wildly about the room as if searching for something. Then he said, âStella's come back.'
âOh - good.'
âNot good. I don't want her. I
detest
her.'
âPerhaps that means you love her.'
âI suppose you have to say something stupid like that.'
âI'm glad you've come, George. I thought you'd come, at last.'
âDid you? I didn't. Anyway it doesn't mean anything, not what you think.'
âWould you like a drink?'