Authors: Matt Gallagher
“Hotspur Six, do you copy?”
There was no one else in the room.
My mental bearings snapped into place. I was still alone. Captain Vrettos was still at Camp Independence. The voice was coming from the walkie-talkie clipped to my belt loop.
“Hotspur Six, this is Hotspur Six-Golf. You copy?” It was Dominguez.
I took a deep breath before answering. “This is Hotspur Six.”
“There you are. You're needed at the front gate. Got a local here requesting to speak to an officer. I think.”
With Captain Vrettos at Camp Independence, and the other platoon leaders on patrol, that left me. I folded the manila file in half and jammed it in a pocket.
“There in five. You copy, CP?”
“We copy, Hotspur Six.”
“Send a runner to wake Snoop.”
“Roger.”
I cleaned my mess hastily, throwing piles of folders and papers into the desk. I uttered a silent prayer to whichever deity protected office interlopers, slung my rifle, and poked my head into the hallway. It was empty. I secured the lock and walked downstairs, ignoring the urge to turn around and put faces to the watchers I felt behind me, real or imagined.
â¢âââ¢âââ¢
The Arabian night was cool and blue. I circled our sandstone citadel, navigating the razor wire and blast walls that surrounded it in layers. Pale blinking lights in the distance helped guide me to the front gate,
beacons courtesy of the few locals wealthy enough to purchase generators. The squat two-story buildings across the dirt road were about a hundred feet and a world away; the entire block was dark and abandoned, and had been since America made this place an edge of empire.
“It's the sir! Ain't it past your bedtime?”
“What's up, Hog.” It was my crew on shift again, mostly: Hog, Dominguez, Alphabet, and a husky private from third platoon named Batule. They stood in front of a Humvee, machine gun barrel pointing up at the muddy stars.
“Tool, why aren't you out with your platoon?” I asked.
“Part of your platoon now,” Batule said. “Swapped bunks this afternoon.”
“Who authorized that?”
“The platoon sergeants, I guess.”
Dominguez spoke, all monotony and undertone. “Platoon daddies talking trades. I'd expect more to come.”
Another power play by Chambers, I thought. Even though senior enlisted managed personnel, they were supposed to run these things by their officers. It was a matter of decorum. I sized up Batule. Thick, dense, and prone to smashing things. Chambers' ideal, no doubt.
“Where's this hajj?” I said, more harshly than intended. “And where is Snoop? I don't have all night.”
As if on cue, Haitham stumbled out of the black and into sight. The little man held a glass bottle and reeked of whiskey and filth. He wore an oversized soccer jersey, the green one of the Iraqi national team, and moved with a limp.
“The fuck you been?” I asked. “And what happened to your leg?”
“Molazim!”
He dropped his bottle, which met packed dirt with a thud, and grabbed my shoulders with both hands.
“Molazim!”
he said. “Karim! Ali baba!
Okht!
Karim . . . keeel!
Shaytan
keeel Karim! Karim okht! Ali baba!
Okht!
”
His rotting teeth and hell breath were too much, so I pushed him off.
Haitham's eyes bulged, and he collapsed to the ground, rocking himself back and forth, his head between his knees. I couldn't tell if he was talking to himself or crying.
“Mad sorry, yo!” Snoop ran out of the shadows wearing a do-rag and a fleece jacket, pulling up his basketball shorts as he made his way over. “They didn't tell me which gate.”
“Talk to him,” I said, pointing at Haitham. “Figure out what he wants. And say we're sorry we shot his nephew's goat.”
As Snoop kneeled down next to a still-rocking Haitham, I walked over to Dominguez, who was leaning against the near side of the Humvee.
“This place never ceases to amaze me,” I said, shaking my head.
Dominguez spat out a wad of dip. “Sir, can I tell you something?”
“Of course.”
“You didn't hear it from me.”
“
Está bien
. What is it?”
He scanned my face in the dark, and lowered his voice. “Staff Sergeant Chambers been pulling in the squad leaders, tweaking the rules of engagement.”
“ââTweaking'?”
“You know what I mean.”
“He can't do that. Captain Vrettos can't even do that. Those are set by the battalion commander.”
“Lots of gray in those rules.”
“Mmm.” I paused and hoped it made me sound thoughtful. “Why you telling me this, Sergeant?”
The dip in his mouth slurred his words and puffed out his chipmunk cheeks. He spoke with memory rather than from it. “In Afghanistan, we got hit bad. Forty percent casualty rate. So we got trigger-happy. One day, during a firefight in the mountains, a little girl got killed. Shot through the forehead, brains everywhere. Worst thing I ever seen. Screaming mama, raging papa, a total shitshow. She was still holding a fucking dinosaur coloring book we'd handed out a couple of days before. No one knew who had done it, but we all blamed ourselves. Could've
been a Taliban round, but we were sure it was us. That day destroyed the unit in a way no enemy could.” He spat out another wad of dip and started cleaning the remnants of snuff from his teeth. “Thought you should know.”
This, I thought, this is why I need to get rid of Chambers.
I cleared my throat. “Maybe it's time to bring the guys together, do a refresher course on what we can and can't do. Wouldn't hurt anyone.”
“Good idea, sir.”
“Thanks. And, well. Thanks.”
Rather than respond, Dominguez nodded to Snoop and Haitham, who were still behind us. I turned around.
“Haitham drank too much whiskey,” Snoop said. “Talking like a crazy man. About ghosts and phantoms, the bad days in Ashuriyah.”
“Before you came down, he was ranting about ali baba,” I said. “And he mentioned
karim
. What's a
karim
?”
Haitham still had his face between his knees. The terp had to lean in to hear what the drunk said, but a few seconds later he had it.
“Karim is a person.” Snoop's voice dropped to a strong whisper. “Karim was al-Qaeda. Dead now.”
I felt an anger rising in my chest, red and hot like a fire poker. The looks of confusion on Alphabet's and Batule's faces didn't help. “Just find out why he's here, Snoop. Tell him if he doesn't get to the point, we're going to drop him off in the Shi'a part of town.”
After a minute or so of rapid-fire Arabic, this: “Haitham wishes to go to Camp Bucca. He say jail is safer than Ashuriyah now.”
“Snoopâ”
The little man cut me off and pointed north, toward the ancient mosque.
“He say he will tell you everything, he swears by the shrine. But you must promise him Camp Bucca.”
I'd heard enough. I wanted to read the sworn statements in my pocket and get to bed. “Tell him to come back tomorrow, sober. We'll sit down and talk then.”
I started walking toward the outpost. Then came a low, singing pop, howling with consequence.
I dropped to the ground and waited for more fire. None came. I counted to three with my eyes shut tight. Some combination of angel and instinct induced me toward the Humvee for cover.
“Contact to the front!” Dominguez shouted. He'd dropped to one knee and held his rifle at the low ready. He swung his night vision goggles down from his helmet. “Anyone get eyes on?”
“Negative, Sergeant!” Hog said. He'd somehow made it up the Humvee's turret to the machine gun.
“Scan the rooftops and windows across the road, Hogâfucking sniper.”
“Roger, Sergeant.”
“Tool, report.”
“Got nothing.” He was somewhere in front of the vehicle, in the vicinity of the gate.
I was racking my brain for what the manuals said the platoon leader needed to do in situations like this. I drew a blank. “Snoop?” I asked into the air. “You okay?”
“Yeah, LT,” he said from somewhere on the other side of the vehicle. “Haitham, tooâhe's with me.”
That was when Alphabet started gurgling. He sounded like a broken sprinkler back home. But it wasn't anything that technical or complex. Just blood spilling out of a throat.
Dominguez shined a white light onto Alphabet. He'd been shot three feet in front of me and his legs were bucking, one at a time. Left, right. Left, right. Left, right.
“CP!” I shouted into my walkie-talkie. “This is Hotspur Six. Casualty at the front gate, a friendly! Request medevac immediately!”
The voice that came back was incredulous. “A casualty?”
“Yes, did I fucking stutter?”
A blur of barking orders rushed past me.
“Tool. Third platoon is on their way down. Take point and clear the buildings across the road. Fire at anything that fucking moves.”
“Roger, Sergeant.”
It was Chambers. He slung his rifle and grabbed Alphabet by a body armor strap, dragging him toward the blast walls.
“Hog, stay up there and provide cover. Fire at anything that fucking moves.”
“Roger, Sergeant!”
“Dominguez. You and the terp help me with this. Sir, get a medic down here. Lieutenant Porter, that means you.”
I still held the walkie-talkie in my hand, but my mind was stew, so it took me a second to process what I needed to do. Then I did it.
Chambers got Alphabet's body behind the barriers before anyone could catch up to them. A group of twenty hustling bodies and jangling gear emerged from the outpost. Third platoon. They followed Batule, bounding and covering into the black night. The mechanical swerving of Hog in the turret sounded like a garbage truck eating trash, and it reminded me that there was still a sniper out there. I ran behind the blast walls to check on my soldier.
Doc Cork was there. He'd managed to stop the bleeding with some gauze pads and adhesive tape. Both Snoop and Dominguez were on their knees, holding Alphabet's shoulders with one hand and his palms with the other. I asked Doc Cork if I could help, but he shook me off and stuck an IV into Alphabet's arm. I wasn't sure what to do with my hands, so I leaned down and stroked Alphabet's left calf.
You joined to be a part of something, I thought. I joined to believe in something. Not that different. Not the same, but not that different. I wish I'd told you that.
Then I told him that.
His body armor had been stripped and his breathing was low and labored and his legs weren't bucking anymore. Chambers ran up holding a litter, and he and Dominguez prepped Alphabet for movement to the landing zone while Doc Cork held the IV bag high.
I grabbed a litter handle to help carry it. It was lighter than I'd expected. The bird had a hard time landing in the field behind the outpost; it was whipping up too much dust. Chambers produced a
pair of ChemLights from a cargo pocket and guided the pilot down. After the helicopter landed, collected Alphabet, and took off for Camp Independence, Chambers remained in the field. I walked over to him, kicked-up dust falling down on us in a dry rain. He was in his undershirt, tapping his arm tattoos with the ChemLights as if he wanted to inject neon into his bloodstream. The black skulls on his arm throbbed in the dark, little halos of fluorescent green.
“Smart thinking,” I said, pointing to the sticks. “You might've saved him.”
He looked back and smiled, his eyes dilating in the neon light.
“No,” he said. “But I'm not going to lose another one like this. You know what the best way out of something is, Lieutenant?”
“What's that?”
“Through. The best way out is always through.”
I shivered in the desert, alone.
SWORN STATEMENT
File number: 4z08
Place:
CAMP INDEPENDENCE, IRAQ
Date:
April 30, 2006
I, First Lieutenant Tyler L. Grant, make the following free and voluntary sworn statement to
Major Edward P. Price
, whom I know to be the Investigating Officer for the Command Investigation into the circumstances of the death of Saladin Jalal al-Badri on April 12, 2006. I make this statement of my own free will and without any threats made to me or promises extended.
I am currently assigned as the platoon leader to 2nd Platoon, Charlie Company, 2-48 Infantry Battalion, 1st Cavalry Division. I have been the platoon leader since September 7, 2005.
Our unit deployed to Iraq on July 1, 2005.
On the morning of April 12, my platoon was given the “kill or capture” mission of Saladin Jalal al-Badri, aka the “9 of Clubs” of our unit's target deck. Saladin was an alleged member of al-Qaeda in Iraq in the town of Ashuriyah. This mission was part of Operation Fumble Recovery, the search for my platoon's missing squad leader, Staff Sergeant Elijah Rios.
On April 12, at approximately 0100, our command post in Ashuriyah received a tip on Saladin's bed-down location. Captain Tisdale, the
commander, assigned the mission to my platoon. We didn't have time for a full rehearsal, so as the soldiers prepped the Humvees, my squad leaders and I planned to have second squad raid the house while first and third squads formed an outside perimeter in case of runners.
I don't remember exactly when the platoon arrived at the target house, but I believe it to be around 0135. I ordered the platoon to have all weapons on “Red” status, aka locked and loaded, since battalion intel considered Saladin “armed and dangerous.”
First and third squads formed the perimeter and second squad stacked against the house. No lights were on and there was only one door, in the front. I gave the order to raid the house.
There were two shots, and then a pause, followed by two more shots. I found out later that Corporal Daniel Chambers, a fireteam leader in second squad, fired both sets of “controlled pairs.”
I don't know what the standard practice is for placement of fireteam leaders in room-clearing stacks. I don't micromanage, and leave decisions like that to my noncoms.
By the time I entered the house, all the rooms had been cleared. One military-age male lay in the center room, two shots in his chest and two in his forehead. The platoon medic declared him dead, and using the photo we had from our target deck, I identified him as Saladin, aka the “9 of Clubs.” A loaded AK-47 rifle lay next to his body. I was informed that he raised it as my men entered the house, prompting Corporal Chambers to fire.
I don't remember which side of the body the AK-47 was on. I updated the outpost and oversaw intel collection. I had the soldiers take photos of the body and rifle, for evidence.
No other persons were found on the premises, and papers and computer equipment were collected for analysis.
I am not aware of the use of “drop weapons” and would have stopped their use immediately had such a thing been occurring in my platoon. Nor have I seen any convincing evidence of their use in my platoon, during the Saladin mission or before. I cannot explain why the AK-47 was first photographed without a clip and then photographed with a clip inserted into it, though it seems likely one of the men felt it important to clear the weapon for safety. I regularly brief my platoon on the rules of engagement and believe every soldier in my platoon understands and abides by them.
I never saw any of my soldiers with an AK-47 in their possession before or during this mission. The AK-47 recovered during the raid was turned over to battalion, along with the other evidence.
I never heard of any drop weapon allegation until the CID interview.
I have an open door policy. I don't think my soldiers are afraid to tell me what's going on in the platoon at their level. I don't think they would hesitate to come to me if things were going wrong. I visit their rooms at least once a day, sometimes twice. We have a good relationship.
NOTHING FOLLOWS
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT:
TG