Triple Threat (14 page)

He looked a bit reluctant. “I’m not so sure about this. What are you gonna do?”

I got up off the bed and went to him. He was up against a wall with nowhere to go. I stood in front of him. “You told all my friends you’re my boyfriend. So, are we gonna have that type of relationship or not?”

“But I…”

I put one hand over his mouth. “No more of that.” Then I opened his towel with the other hand. It fell to the floor and I looked at him. I bit my lip. “Where do you hide that?” His cock was about an inch longer than Chad’s, just not as thick.

“I don’t advertise it,” he said. When I took it in my hand, he tensed all over. “No, don’t touch me.”

I looked up at him as I stroked his erection slowly. “Why not? It’s very nice.”

“Please, you’ll make it worse.”

I let his stiff dick go and pulled him to the bed. When he was on his back, I looked him over again. His body was perfect. Wow. At that moment, I couldn’t wait to feel that huge cock inside of me. I hoped he was as good as Chad. Then I took a hold of his shaft again.

“Please tell me what you’re gonna do,” he plead.

“You’ll see. Just relax and close your eyes.”

As soon as I felt him calm a bit, I put my mouth over him and took as much of that awesome cock in that I could. He let out a moan right away. I started with what Chad liked best, moving my tongue around the tip.

“God, that feels good!”

I looked up at him. “No one ever did this to you before?”

“No. I wouldn’t let them.” He was already out of breath. When I ran my tongue up and down his entire shaft, he yelled, “Holy shit!”

I smiled and took him in again, sucking hard. He moaned loudly. All the noise he was making was driving me crazy. I started to move my tongue around his shaft while it was in my mouth. He liked that too.

Then: “Stop, stop, please!”

I did and looked up at him, unsure of what the problem was. “Did I hurt you?” Then suddenly, I was drenched with cum. I didn’t expect that. I had no idea he meant that fast. It even got in my hair.

“I’m so sorry. I tried to tell you.” He looked humiliated.

I then realized my mouth was still open in surprise. I must have looked shocked. “It’s OK. Don’t worry about it.” I slowly got up off the bed and took another shower.

When I got back into the bedroom, Noah was under the blanket. “That felt real good. I’m sorry, really.”

I lay down with him and put my arms around him. “It’s OK.” Then I kissed his lips. “Does it happen that fast during sex too?”

“Not if I’m drinking. But sober, yeah. Condoms help me hold off a little.” Then he turned away from me, obviously still embarrassed.

I held him from behind and assured him, “We’ll figure something out. We have to.”

Noah and I had just gotten back to my apartment. “Did you have fun today?” he asked as we took our shoes off.

“Yeah. The water was cold, though.”

He laughed. “What did you expect? It’s the middle of November. It might be nice outside, but the ocean don’t know that.” He poked me in the side. “You’re lucky I didn’t throw you in the water.”

“No, you are.” I would have pulled him in with me.

He would never do that. He was too much of a gentleman to act that way. He just tried to be a little like Chad sometimes. It never worked.

“The sunset was amazing,” I added.

“Yeah, and the movie was better than I expected.”

We had gone to see a romantic comedy. Something Chad would never do, but Giovanni went with me to one once. I sighed, thinking about the last few weeks with Noah.

We had not had sex yet, but he seemed to enjoy pleasing me and was very good at it. Normally, he would eat me out first. Then use his hands to make me cum at least four times. He had let me give him another blowjob or two, but seemed too nervous about actual sex. It was a bit frustrating, but Chad was still making up for that.

I shook my head and watched Noah look around the living room. He seemed to be anxious about something. He moved around a lot, not able to stay still.

“What’s wrong?” I asked, concerned.

“Nothing,” he replied.

Then he took a shower. When he was out in a towel, I kissed him and jumped in myself.

By the time Noah and I were in bed, I knew something was freaking him out. I worried that either Chad or Giovanni left something in my apartment he had seen. But then I realized he would have been angry about that, not nervous.

It all came together, when Noah moved closer to me on the bed and started kissing me. I hoped he finally wanted to do it. He caressed my breasts as our tongues twisted and swirled with each other. He was turning me on fast.

I ran my hand over his backside, trying to entice him into going further. I was shocked when he climbed on top of me. He had never done that before while naked. I opened my legs and let him press his hard cock against my aching wet pussy while we continued to kiss.

“Please, Noah. Don’t make me beg you.” It had become too much for me.

Then he pulled away from me. He reached down next to the bed and grabbed his pants. I thought he wanted to stop, but he took a condom out of his pocket. I could feel he was tense and edgy. I ran my hands down his body, trying to help.

He looked at me. “You’re really OK with this?”

I bit my lip and told him, “I want it as much as you do. Please.”

He smiled and put the condom on. Then after I opened my legs wider for him, he got on top of me again. I could even feel how nervous he was. I glided my fingertips down his back, slowly which made him sigh and relax a bit.

When I felt the head of his cock touch my pussy, I grabbed his arms, unsure of what it would be like. I always got nervous being with someone for the first time and that was no exception. He pushed into me slowly and felt somewhat like Chad, but only because of his similar size. Unlike with Chad, I didn’t feel pleasure immediately.

“Am I hurting you? That happens sometimes.”

“I’m OK,” I admitted, knowing it was because of Chad that I wasn’t wincing in pain.

He seemed to like it a lot. He moaned as he drove deeper into me. Then he pushed in a bit faster.

“Ouch!” I gasped as he went in too far.

He leaned down and kissed my lips. “I’m sorry. Am I too big for you?”

“It’s OK. I was just nervous,” I assured him.

He pulled out and thrust all the way in, quickly.

“Ow!” I whimpered as he hit into my cervix again.

He kissed me. “You can’t take it all. I’m sorry. I’ll be more careful. You’re so tiny.”

Noah kept his weight on me, so I couldn’t do much. Then he took my hands in his and held them against the bed. At first that scared me, because I was basically pinned under him.

“God, you feel so good,” he whispered as his hips moved slowly.

After a minute or two, I got used to the hand thing and it felt nice. But his pace was too slow and I wasn’t getting anything out of it. I looked up at him and could see he was enjoying it that way.

“Why did I wait so long? Your pussy is amazing.”

I wished I could show him what I liked. I was disappointed. I tried not to relay that. He would be upset by it. I tried to just concentrate on his cock coming in and out. I liked the way it felt going in, but he didn’t come out far enough for me.

“Let me move my legs, Noah.”

He lifted up enough that I could move and I hooked my feet around him. I felt him carefully thrust in a bit further. I relaxed so it wouldn’t hurt.

“Oh, damn, that’s good.”

Then I felt him grip my hands tighter. His hips started moving faster. Finally, he was making me feel good. I clutched his hands tighter also.

“You like that?” he softly asked.

I closed my eyes. I was glad I felt something. “Yeah, much better.”

He began driving into me harder and that forced my body to really respond. I started to moan as it got better with each stroke. I was so close to getting there. I felt it coming. I gripped him harder, knowing I would scream soon.

Then suddenly, Noah stopped. “Shit!” he shouted. His body tensed then I felt his cock swelling.

No!
I yelled in my head as he came. I just let my body relax as much as I could.
That sucked!

I tried to hide my frustration from him. He had told me it would happen. I was just hoping it wouldn’t be that fast.

“I’m sorry,” he whispered in my ear. “I can’t help it.” Then he got up off me. “Don’t move.” He left the room to throw away the condom.

When he was back, he got up on the bed again. He quickly lay down and put his hand between my legs. I closed my eyes, wishing Chad were in my bed instead.

Then I felt his fingers inside of me. He knew how to use them very well, most likely because of his problem. It took him merely a minute to make me cum, but it wasn’t the same.

Afterwards, we held each other. I didn’t say anything at all. I worried I would make him feel worse with anything that could come out of my mouth.

The next day, I still felt unsatisfied, but I kept it to myself. Noah came with me to Chad’s. Rosario and Giovanni talked with Noah while I went inside to use the bathroom. Chad was in his room, looking for a hair tie.

When I came out of his bathroom, he knew something was off about me. “Baby, you OK?”

“It’s complicated,” I replied.

He came closer to me. “Is Noah treating you right?”

“Yeah,” I knew he hoped the answer was no because he wanted me to leave him.

He touched my face. “Then why do you have that look on your face.”

“Well…” I sighed. “Will you promise not to say anything to Noah?”

“You know I won’t.”

“He… well, we…” I closed my eyes. I couldn’t look at him and tell him. “Last night we kinda… did it… and he… he… came before I did.”

Chad let out a little laugh then bit his lip. “Did he make it up to you at least?” He laughed again. I knew he was glad about it. “I’m sorry. I just never did that before, especially not to you.”

“It’s not funny.” I told him. “He wasn’t very good until the end and then… ugh!”

Chad backed me up into the wall. “Do you want me to give you what he couldn’t, baby?” He kissed my lips a few times.

“I can’t.” I pushed him away. “He’s in the garage.”

Chad smiled. “Even better, I can think about how good I am compared to him.” Then he started kissing my neck. “Come on, baby. It’ll be exciting. He’ll never catch us. I’ll hold your mouth shut.”

I moaned just thinking of him inside of me. “Maybe later, after he goes home.” I pulled away from him, feeling guilty.

“I’m ready when you are, baby.” Then he put his hair up and we walked to the garage together.

I heard Giovanni say, “It does suck.”

“What sucks?” I asked.

Rosario looked at me. “I got laid off.”

“That does suck. Now what?”

Giovanni looked at me. “We gotta hit clubs further away, Crystal. Can we start tomorrow night?”

I walked to Noah. “Do you mind?”

“I guess not.” Noah looked at Chad. “What took so long inside?”

“We were talking,” Chad replied. “You know she’s my best friend right? I tell her everything.” He was annoyed that Noah would question us.

Noah put his arm around my shoulders and whispered, “Please don’t tell him about last night. It’s too embarrassing.”

I didn’t answer. I just pulled away from him, so we could get started. Noah watched me with a smile. I knew he was starting to have stronger feelings towards me, but I didn’t feel the same.

We broke for dinner in the living room. Chad had gotten sandwiches and we all sat around the room eating together. He took his shirt off after I helped him get everything set up.

I saw Noah watching Chad closer than normal. Soon, he turned to me and quietly asked, “You and Chad have the same tattoo? I thought you guys were never together.”

“We weren’t,” I explained.

He kept looking from Chad to me. “But normally, only married couples do something like that. Are you in love with him?”

“No. He’s my best friend. That’s why we got them.”

“He acts like he feels much more for you. I hate when he touches your hair. He looks at you like he wants you.”

I sighed. I had to tell him. “He’s in love with me, but I don’t feel that way and he knows that.” Then the subject was dropped.

After a while, Rosario and Giovanni started horsing around. Well, technically, Rosario was shoving his younger, but stronger brother. Giovanni hardly ever pushed him back too hard. He knew he could hurt him.

But Rosario wouldn’t stop, so Gio yelled, “Cut it out, asshole!” Then he shoved him without looking.

Rosario fell back over the coffee table. I would normally have laughed, but he fell onto me and the soda in my hand drenched me as I screamed.

Giovanni quickly came to me. “You OK?”

“Do you want me to go to your place and get you a change of clothes?” Rosario asked as he helped me up.

“I’m fine. I have clothes here. I’ll go change.” Then I stood up.

Noah grabbed my hand. “What do you mean you have clothes here? I thought you were only friends!”

“I… uh…” I didn’t know how to explain it without telling the truth. “Sometimes, I stay here.”

He looked furious. “You fuck him?” he yelled.

Everyone turned towards us. I looked at Chad, pleading with him to help me. He came to us. “Noah, relax. I got three bedrooms. She only stays here when we hang out too late. I won’t let her go home alone.”

Noah seemed to calm down. “So, it’s just a friend thing, really?”

“Yes,” I lied, so as to protect his feelings. “I’ll go change and you just sit tight. Even my underwear is wet. This feels nasty.”

Chad stood up. “I moved your stuff. I’ll show you where I put it.”

He walked with me to his room and locked the door behind us. I took off all of my clothes and threw them in his hamper. My skin felt nasty too, so I took a shower.

When I came out, Chad was naked with a condom on. He pulled off my towel, grabbed me and bent me over his bed. “I’m not letting you leave without giving you what he can’t.”

He thrust into me quickly and put a hand over my mouth. I felt incredible immediately. He drove in and out of me with perfect knowledge of my body. He kept pulling out almost all the way then shoving back in hard, the way I loved him to.