The Night Garden (39 page)

The Red Garden
by Alice Hoffman—One of my favorite books in recent years, this short story collection traces the life of a Massachusetts town from its frontier settlement days to the present. It’s chocked full of folklore with hints of
magic—and to me, these stories feel quintessentially American. I swear, reading it fills your nose with the smells of forest soil and freshly sawn wood. This is on my keeper shelf to read again and again.

Thanks for reading
The Night Garden.
I would love to hear from you by email on my website (
www.WriterLisaVanAllen.com
) or on my Facebook page. And if your book group reads this story, please be in touch! I may be able to Skype or call in.

Good things,
Lisa Van Allen

Questions and Topics for Discussion

1.
Olivia Pennywort has a unique condition that causes anyone she touches to develop a rash. What would you do if you had Olivia’s condition? How would you cope if you knew there was no way to get rid of it?

2.
Olivia keeps her condition a secret at the risk of being perceived as a monster and driving everyone she knows away. What do you think would happen if Olivia was more open about her condition? Is she right to fear the public’s reaction?

3.
Because of her condition, Olivia believes she “would be wrong to expect more of her life than what she had” (
this page
). Even though she has everything she needs to survive, do you think this is an acceptable attitude? In what ways can expectations shape how you live your life?

4.
At the start, Sam’s condition has stripped him of the ability to feel. If you had this condition, which sensations do you think would be the most jarring to lose?

5.
When she was younger, Olivia chose not to be with Sam because she was hurting him, even though she still loved him. Did she make the right decision to break up with him? Should she have told him the truth? What would you have done?

6.
Sam comes from a family of rescuers and feels pressure to be a rescuer as well. In what ways can a positive family legacy be both a blessing and a curse? To what extent should a person attempt to live up to a family legacy? What happens if this legacy comes at the expense of carving an individual path?

7.
A central theme in the novel is temptation, or the idea of desperately wanting what we know may be bad for us or for others. Is there a right way to deal with temptation? In what scenarios would it be okay to give in?

8.
Another core theme is the importance of touch. How important is touch and feeling for a happy life? Is it possible to find happiness without it? Do you think you could?

9.
Olivia is appalled that her father knew she was becoming poisonous and did not try to stop it. What makes Arthur’s act so reprehensible? Do you think it’s possible to atone for such a destructive act? How would you go about making things right?

10.
When Sam comes to rescue her out of the poisonous garden maze, Olivia realizes that “when a person could find happiness, she should seize it without question, without a single thought for the future, and with a steady resolve never
to become bitter once it was lost” (
this page
). Does her reasoning make sense? Is this the best way to live your life?

11.
When the boarders ask Olivia what they will do without the maze, Olivia replies, “The only thing that stands in the way of your inner wisdom is your fear of it” (
this page
). Do you agree with Olivia? Why do you think it’s so hard to figure out what we really want?

12.
If you had a magical maze that could help you figure out what to do, what would you want it to help you with?

13.
Why do you think Gloria continually tries to change the Pennywort farm? What do you think her actions suggest about how we respond to what we don’t understand?

By Lisa Van Allen

The Wishing Thread

About the Author

Lisa Van Allen’s writing has been published in many literary journals and has been nominated for the Pushcart Prize. She currently lives in northern New Jersey with her husband.

* D P G R O U P . O R G *

Chat.
Comment.
Connect.

Visit our online book club community at
Facebook.com/RHReadersCircle

Chat

Meet fellow book lovers and discuss what you’re reading.

Comment

Post reviews of books, ask—and answer—thought-provoking questions, or give and receive book club ideas.

Connect

Find an author on tour, visit our author blog, or invite one of our 150 available authors to chat with your group on the phone.

Explore

Also visit our site for discussion questions, excerpts, author interviews, videos, free books, news on the latest releases, and more.