Authors: Neil Gaiman
“ ‘Carasel is . . . no, was. That’s right, isn’t it?
Was.
He was always so involved. And so creative. But it was never enough for him. He always wanted to understand everything—to experience what he was working on. He was never content to just create it—to understand it intellectually. He wanted
all
of it.
“ ‘That wasn’t a problem before, when we were working on properties of matter. But when we began to design some of the Named emotions . . . he got too involved with his work.
“ ‘And our latest project was
Death.
It’s one of the hard ones—one of the big ones, too, I suspect. Possibly it may even become the attribute that’s going to define the Creation for the Created: If not for
Death,
they’d be content to simply exist, but with
Death,
well, their lives will have meaning—a boundary beyond which the living cannot cross . . .’
“ ‘So you think he killed himself?’
“ ‘I know he did,’ said Saraquael. I walked to the window and looked out. Far below, a
long
way, I could see a tiny white dot. That was Carasel’s body. I’d have to arrange for someone to take care of it. I wondered what we would do with it; but there would be someone who would know, whose function was the removal of unwanted things. It was not my function. I knew that.
“ ‘How?’
“He shrugged. ‘ I know. Recently he’d begun asking questions—questions about
Death.
How we could know whether or not it was right to make this thing, to set the rules, if we were not going to experience it ourselves. He kept talking about it.’
“ ‘Didn’t you wonder about this?’
“Saraquael turned, for the first time, to look at me. ‘No. That
is
our function—to discuss, to improvise, to aid the Creation and the Created. We sort it out now, so that when it all Begins, it’ll run like clockwork. Right now we’re working on
Death.
So obviously that’s what we look at. The physical aspect; the emotional aspect; the philosophical aspect . . .
“ ‘And the
patterns.
Carasel had the notion that what we do here in the Hall of Being creates patterns. That there are structures and shapes appropriate to beings and events that, once begun, must continue until they reach their end. For us, perhaps, as well as for them. Conceivably he felt this was one of his patterns.’
“ ‘Did you know Carasel well?’
“ ‘As well as any of us know each other. We saw each other here; we worked side by side. At certain times I would retire to my cell across the City. Sometimes he would do the same.’
“Tell me about Phanuel.’
“His mouth crooked into a smile. ‘He’s officious. Doesn’t do much—farms everything out and takes all the credit.’ He lowered his voice, although there was no other soul in the gallery. ‘To hear him talk, you’d think that
Love
was all his own work. But to his credit, he does make sure the work gets done. Zephkiel’s the real thinker of the two senior designers, but he doesn’t come here. He stays back in his cell in the City and contemplates; resolves problems from a distance. If you need to speak to Zephkiel, you go to Phanuel, and Phanuel relays your questions to Zephkiel . . . ’
“I cut him short. ‘How about Lucifer? Tell me about him.’
“ ‘Lucifer? The Captain of the Host? He doesn’t work here . . . He has visited the Hall a couple of times, though—inspecting the Creation. They say he reports directly to the Name. I have never spoken to him.’
“ ‘Did he know Carasel?’
“ ‘I doubt it. As I said, he has only been here twice. I have seen him on other occasions, though. Through here.” He flicked a wingtip, indicating the world outside the window. “In flight.’
“ ‘Where to?’
“Saraquael seemed to be about to say something, then he changed his mind. ‘ I don’t know.’
“I looked out of the window at the Darkness outside the Silver City.
“I may want to talk with you some more, later,’ I told Saraquael.
“ ‘Very good.” I turned to go. “ ‘Sir? Do you know if they will be assigning me another partner? For
Death?
’
“ ‘No,’ I told him. ‘I’m afraid I don’t.’
“In the center of the Silver City was a park—a place of recreation and rest. I found the Angel Lucifer there, beside a river. He was just standing, watching the water flow.
“ ‘Lucifer?’
“He inclined his head. ‘Raguel. Are you making progress?’
“ ‘I don’t know. Maybe. I need to ask you a few questions. Do you mind?’
“ ‘Not at all.’
“ ‘How did you come upon the body?’
“ ‘I didn’t. Not exactly. I saw Phanuel standing in the street. He looked distressed. I inquired whether there was something wrong, and he showed me the dead angel. And I fetched you.’
“ ‘I see.’
“He leaned down, let one hand enter the cold water of the river. The water splashed and rolled around it. ‘Is that all?’
“ ‘Not quite. What were you doing in that part of the city?’
“ ‘I don’t see what business that is of yours.’
“ ‘It is my business, Lucifer. What were you doing there?’
“ ‘I was . . . walking. I do that sometimes. Just walk and think. And try to understand.’ He shrugged.
“ ‘You walk on the edge of the City?’
“A beat, then ‘Yes.’
“ ‘That’s all I want to know. For now.’
“ ‘Who else have you talked to?”
“ ‘Carasel’s boss and his partner. They both feel that he killed himself—ended his own life.’
“ ‘Who else are you going to talk to?’
“I looked up. The spires of the City of the Angels towered above us. ‘Maybe everyone.’
“ ‘All of them?’
“ ‘If I need to. It’s my function. I cannot rest until I understand what happened, and until the Vengeance of the Name has been taken on whosoever was responsible. But I’ll tell you something I
do
know.’
“ ‘What would that be?’ Drops of water fell like diamonds from the Angel Lucifer’s perfect fingers.
“ ‘Carasel did not kill himself.’
“ ‘How do you know that?”
“ ‘I am Vengeance. If Carasel had died by his own hand,’ I explained to the Captain of the Heavenly Host, ‘there would have been no call for me. Would there?’
“He did not reply.
“I flew upward into the light of the eternal morning.
“You got another cigarette on you?”
I fumbled out the red and white packet, handed him a cigarette.
“Obliged.
“Zephkiel’s cell was larger than mine.
“It wasn’t a place for waiting. It was a place to live, and work, and
be.
It was lined with books, and scrolls, and papers, and there were images and representations on the walls: pictures. I’d never seen a picture before.
“In the center of the room was a large chair, and Zephkiel sat there, his eyes closed, his head back.
“As I approached him, he opened his eyes.
“They burned no brighter than the eyes of any of the other angels I had seen, but somehow they seemed to have seen more. It was something about the way he looked. I’m not sure I can explain it. And he had no wings.
“ ‘Welcome, Raguel,’ he said. He sounded tired.
“ ‘You are Zephkiel?’ I don’t know why I asked him that. I mean, I knew who people were. It’s part of my function, I guess. Recognition. I know who
you
are.
“ ‘Indeed. You are staring, Raguel. I have no wings, it is true, but then my function does not call for me to leave this cell. I remain here, and I ponder. Phanuel reports back to me, brings me the new things, for my opinion. He brings me the problems, and I think about them, and occasionally I make myself useful by making some small suggestions. That is my function. As yours is vengeance.’
“ ‘Yes.’
“ ‘You are here about the death of the Angel Carasel?’
“ ‘Yes.’
“ ‘I did not kill him.’
“ ‘When he said it, I knew it was true.
“ ‘Do you know who did?’
“ ‘That is
your
function, is it not? To discover who killed the poor thing and to take the Vengeance of the Name upon him.’
“ ‘Yes.’
“He nodded.
“ ‘What do you want to know?’
“I paused, reflecting on what I had heard that day. ‘Do you know what Lucifer was doing in that part of the City before the body was found?’
“The old angel stared at me. ‘I can hazard a guess.’
“ ‘Yes?’
“ ‘He was walking in the Dark.’
“I nodded. I had a shape in my mind now. Something I could almost grasp. I asked the last question:
“ ‘What can you tell me about
Love
?’
“And he told me. And I thought I had it all.
“I returned to the place where Carasel’s body had been. The remains had been removed, the blood had been cleaned away, the stray feathers collected and disposed of. There was nothing on the silver sidewalk to indicate it had ever been there. But I knew where it had been.
“I ascended on my wings, flew upward until I neared the top of the spire of the Hall of Being. There was a window there, and I entered.
“Saraquael was working there, putting a wingless mannikin into a small box. On one side of the box was a representation of a small brown creature with eight legs. On the other was a representation of a white blossom.
“ ‘Saraquael?’
“ ‘Hm? Oh, it’s you. Hello. Look at this. If you were to die and to be, let us say, put into the earth in a box, which would you want laid on top of you—a spider, here, or a lily, here?’
“ ‘The lily, I suppose.’
‘Yes, that’s what I think, too. But
why?
I wish . . .” He raised a hand to his chin, stared down at the two models, put first one on top of the box, then the other, experimentally. ‘There’s so much to do, Raguel. So much to get right. And we only get one chance at it, you know. There’ll just be one universe—we can’t keep trying until we get it right. I wish I understood why all this was so important to Him . . .’
“ ‘Do you know where Zephkiel’s cell is?’ I asked him.
“ ‘Yes. I mean, I’ve never been there. But I know where it is.’
‘Good. Go there. He’ll be expecting you. I will meet you there.’
“He shook his head. ‘ I have work to do. I can’t just . . .’
“I felt my function come upon me. I looked down at him, and I said, ‘You will be there. Go now.’
“He said nothing. He backed away from me toward the window, staring at me; then he turned and flapped his wings, and I was alone.
“I walked to the central well of the Hall and let myself fall, tumbling down through the model of the universe: it glittered around me, unfamiliar colors and shapes seething and writhing without meaning.
“As I approached the bottom, I beat my wings, slowing my descent, and stepped lightly onto the silver floor. Phanuel stood between two angels who were both trying to claim his attention.
“ ‘I don’t care how aesthetically pleasing it would be,’ he was explaining to one of them. ‘We simply cannot put it in the center. Background radiation would prevent any possible life-forms from even getting a foothold; and anyway, it’s too unstable.’
“He turned to the other. ‘Okay, let’s see it. Hmm. So that’s
Green,
is it? It’s not exactly how I’d imagined it, but. Mm. Leave it with me. I’ll get back to you.’ He took a paper from the angel, folded it over decisively.
“He turned to me. His manner was brusque, and dismissive.
‘Yes?’
“ ‘I need to talk to you.’
“ ‘Mm? Well, make it quick. I have much to do. If this is about Carasel’s death, I have told you all I know.’
“ ‘It is about Carasel’s death. But I will not speak to you now. Not here. Go to Zephkiel’s cell: he is expecting you. I will meet you there.’
“He seemed about to say something, but he only nodded, walked toward the door.
“I turned to go when something occurred to me. I stopped the angel who had the
Green.
‘Tell me something.’
“ ‘If I can, sir.’
“ ‘That thing.’ I pointed to the universe. ‘What’s it going to be
for
?’
“ ‘For? Why, it is the universe.’
“ ‘I know what it’s called. But what purpose will it serve?’
“He frowned. ‘It is part of the plan. The Name wishes it; He requires
such and such,
to
these
dimensions and having
such and such
properties and ingredients. It is our function to bring it into existence, according to His wishes. I am sure
He
knows its function, but He has not revealed it to me.’ His tone was one of gentle rebuke.
“I nodded, and left that place.
“High above the City a phalanx of angels wheeled and circled and dove. Each held a flaming sword that trailed a streak of burning brightness behind it, dazzling the eye. They moved in unison through the salmon pink sky. They were very beautiful. It was—you know on summer evenings when you get whole flocks of birds performing their dances in the sky? Weaving and circling and clustering and breaking apart again, so just as you think you understand the pattern, you realize you don’t, and you never will? It was like that, only better.
“Above me was the sky. Below me, the shining City. My home. And outside the City, the Dark.
“Lucifer hovered a little below the Host, watching their maneuvers.
“ ‘Lucifer?’
“ ‘Yes, Raguel? Have you discovered your malefactor?’
“ ‘I think so. Will you accompany me to Zephkiel’s cell? There are others waiting for us there, and I will explain everything.’
“He paused. Then, ‘Certainly.’
“He raised his perfect face to the angels, now performing a slow revolution in the sky, each moving through the air keeping perfect pace with the next, none of them ever touching. ‘Azazel!’
“An angel broke from the circle; the others adjusted almost imperceptibly to his disappearance, filling the space, so you could no longer see where he had been.
“ ‘I have to leave. You are in command, Azazel. Keep them drilling. They still have much to perfect.’
“ ‘Yes, sir.’
“Azazel hovered where Lucifer had been, staring up at the flock of angels, and Lucifer and I descended toward the City.
“ ‘He’s my second-in-command,’ said Lucifer. ‘Bright. Enthusiastic. Azazel would follow you anywhere.’
“ ‘What are you training them for?’