Authors: Elly Griffiths
âI don't think a pagan naming ceremony will be quite their thing somehow.'
âAre you sure? What about Shona?'
âShe'll come.' Shona loves a party almost as much as Cathbad does, and despite a Catholic upbringing she is definitely on the side of the pagans.
âYou'll have to invite Phil too,' says Ruth mischievously. âThey're together now.'
âIn that case I will invite him,' says Cathbad with dignity. âEven though I find him a rather negative spiritual presence.'
It's mutual, Ruth wants to tell him. But she doesn't. Despite everything, she quite likes the idea of a party for Kate. She gives in and sits in the visitor's chair. Good old Cathbad. He's been a real support to her over the first few months of Kate's life. He deserves to be a godparent.
Cathbad's next words, though, wipe the indulgent smile from Ruth's face.
âWe'll have to have Nelson.'
âWhy?' asks Ruth warily.
Cathbad looks at her blandly. One of the most irritating things about him is that you never quite know what he's thinking.
âI see Nelson as a sort of spiritual father to Kate.'
âDo you?' Ruth's heart is beating fast but she keeps her face still.
âHe can be a Guardian. Someone to watch over her.'
âNelson's a Catholic. He wouldn't come to a pagan ceremony.'
âHe's not hung up on ritual. He'd come. I'm sure of it.'
That's what Ruth's afraid of.
âWe must invite his wife too,' she says.
âI've only met her once,' says Cathbad, âbut she seems a beautiful soul.'
âShe's very pretty,' says Ruth drily.
âI meant spiritually beautiful,' says Cathbad. Ruth isn't convinced. For all his high-flown spirituality, Cathbad is susceptible to good-looking women.
âAll right,' says Ruth. âWe'll have a party and a bonfire. Invite all the beautiful people.'
Cathbad smiles and, long after he has left and Ruth is preparing for her tutorial, she still seems to see the smile lingering in the air, like the grin on the face of Lewis Carroll's famous cat.
A week later Ruth gets the results of the isotope analysis. She rings Nelson immediately but is told, importantly, that he is out âon police business'. His mobile phone is switched off so she leaves a message and waits impatiently, looking down at the data in front of her, tapping her phone against her teeth. When it rings, she jumps a mile.
âRuth?' It's Ted.
âHi, Ted. What's up?'
âWe've found something on the beach.'
âWhat?'
âSome barrels.'
âBarrels?'
âOld oil barrels. They might be linked to the bodies we found. Do you want to come and have a look?'
Ruth hesitates. Nelson could be hours and she doesn't feel ready to settle down to any other work. She has no tutorials this afternoon and doesn't have to collect Kate until five. And she's intrigued; how could some old oil barrels be linked to the six skeletons?
âOkay,' she says. âI'll come over.'
Ted is waiting for her by the cliff path. It's a beautiful afternoon; sunny but cold, with no wind. The tide is out and the shallow rock pools are a bright, unearthly blue. Ted is rubbing his hands together with what looks like glee but could just be an attempt to get the circulation back.
âThis way.'
He leads the way past the jutting headland and onto the next beach. To get there they have to climb over the remains of the old sea wall and Ruth is soon out of breath. Ted rushes on ahead, bounding over the slippery rocks like a goat. Is there such a thing as a sea goat? Ruth pauses on the highest part of the wall, getting her breath back and enjoying the view. In front of her is a perfect picture-postcard bay â white sand, blue sky, seagulls calling â a desert island courtesy of Radio 4. Ted's footprints in the wet sand are like Man Friday's. Ruth could almost believe that no-one has ever been on this beach before. Although it is only a few miles from resorts like Cromer, this coastline is remote and hard to reach. The cliffs are high and there are no paths or steps. And there's always the danger of being cut off by the tide. The cliffs are dangerous too, full of caves and fissures, overhanging precariously in places. The only creatures at home here are the birds â hundreds of them â nesting on the sheer rock face. Despite living near a bird sanctuary, Ruth is not fond of birds.
A tiny figure on the deserted beach, Craig is clearing away sand with a shovel. He looks like an illustration of an impossible task, one of the labours of Hercules or a punishment in the Underworld.
Another, less classical, allusion comes into Ruth's head, inspired perhaps by Cathbad's championing of Lewis Carroll:
The Walrus and the Carpenter
Were walking close at hand.
They wept like anything to see
Such quantities of sand.
âIf only this were cleared away,'
They said, âit would be grand.'
Ruth climbs down from the wall and walks carefully over the rock pools towards the beach. As she gets closer, she sees that, in fact, Craig is clearing the sand away from a large object â several large objects â that lie half-buried at the foot of the cliff. Closer still, she sees that they are oil barrels, orange with rust and studded with limpets.
Craig is red in the face from his exertions. He greets Ruth and Ted with âJust the three of them, I think.'
âWhat are they doing here?' asks Ruth, bending close to examine the corroded metal. âIt's such an isolated place. Miles from anywhere.'
âI used to come birds-nesting here as a child,' says Craig. âWe actually used to climb up without ropes or anything. Madness really. The cliffs are eighty foot high in places.'
âI used to go in for extreme archaeology,' says Ted. âWent into these caves once in the cliffs on the Firth of Clyde. Thirty metres down and full of giant spiders.'
âFascinating,' says Ruth. She has no time for extreme archaeology, which seems to her to abandon the most sacred precepts of the subject â time, patience and care â in favour
of laddish thrill seeking. âWhy do you think they could be linked to the bodies?
âTake a look inside,' says Ted.
The nearest barrel has a hole in its side, leaving a wickedly jagged edge. Peering gingerly inside, Ruth smells a heady mix of petrol and the sea. She gags. The barrel is half-f of stones which have either fallen from the cliffs or been swept in by the tide, but the smell is still all-pervasive. The second barrel is also open to the elements and inside, under the stones and beach debris, Ruth can see something whitish. The third barrel, as Ted says, is still sealed.
She puts on protective gloves and reaches inside the second barrel. The stones are tightly packed, a mixture of chalk and flint, with a stray crab leg or two thrown in for good measure (probably dropped there by seagulls). Ruth reaches down as far as she can and manages to get a hold of the something white. She pulls.
âLet me help,' says Ted.
Together, they drag out a wad of cotton fibres, once white but now stained grey and yellow, smelling strongly of rotten eggs.
Ruth almost chokes again. She takes a deep breath. âIt looks likeâ'
âThe stuff we found buried with the bodies,' says Ted. âThat's what I thought.'
âThe barrel's full of it,' says Craig. âIt stinks to high heaven.'
âCould be something dead in the bottom of the barrel,' says Ruth. âA fish maybe?'
âNah,' says Ted sniffing knowledgeably. âThat's sulphur, that is.'
Sulphur. The word has an ominous sound. Sulphur and brimstone. The devil dancing in front of a yellow fire. Ruth shakes her head irritably. Her parents are big experts on the devil but she doesn't expect him to come invading her thoughts like this. Especially as he is something else she doesn't believe in.
The third barrel is still sealed. Ruth pushes at it experimentally; it doesn't budge but there is a faint sloshing sound.
âThink it's full of petrol,' says Ted.
âPetrol?'
âYeah, the beach stinks of petrol.'
Ruth realises that this is true. Petrol must have leaked copiously from the first barrel so that the whole area smells like a garage forecourt. Looking down she sees that the sand is black with oil.
âWell we'd better get the fire brigade to look at it,' says Ruth. âPut some hazard signs up. All we need is some idiot with a cigarette â¦'
âGoodnight Vienna,' agrees Craig. He starts to pack up his equipment. Ruth likes him; he's the only archaeologist who doesn't argue with her.
âWhat about the stuff we found in the barrel?' asks Ted.
âI'll take a sample to the lab.'
âRather you than me,' grins Ted.
*
Further inland, overlooking gently rolling hills and flat water meadows, Nelson and Judy are smelling a rather different smell. Antiseptic, lavender and cut flowers masking another, more elemental, odour.
âChrist, I hate these places,' says Nelson for the tenth time, shifting impatiently in his chintz armchair.
âI can't imagine anyone likes them much,' says Judy. She is finding her boss rather trying. It's not her favourite way to spend an afternoon â interviewing some gaga old bloke in an old people's home â but it's her job and she has to get on with it. She thinks that Nelson just resents the fact that Whitcliffe has insisted that he attend this rather routine interview. His attitude, as he shifts in the too-low chair, seems to suggest that, if it wasn't for this intrusion, he would be out catching criminals and righting wrongs. As it is, he'd probably only be in another of Whitcliffe's meetings.
As for her, she'd be catching up with paperwork and trying not to think about her hen night in two weeks' time. There's a notice on the staff room wall for people to sign on and she saw, to her horror, that there were at least thirty names on it. Surely there aren't thirty women at the station? âOh, people are bringing friends,' said Tanya, a friend and fellow WPC. âThe more the merrier.'
Judy is sure that it'll be very merry. They are starting off in a wine bar, then out for a meal then on to a club. She has asked for no fancy dress but she's sure there'll be an element of comedy headgear and novelty suspenders. Oh yes, everyone will have a whale of a time. Everyone except the bride herself, that is.
âWould you like to come this way?' a uniformed figure is smiling down at them. She is probably not a nurse but her manner â a crisp mix of kindness and professionalism â certainly suggests a hospital ward. But this isn't a hospital, Whitcliffe stressed that. âAbsolutely super place. Granddad
loves it. They play bowls and do gardening. There's even an archery team. Real home from home.'
Greenfields Care Home, as they walk through its cream-painted corridors, is certainly clean and well-organised, but homely? Judy can't imagine anyone wanting to decorate their homes with prints of Norfolk Through the Ages or hand-sanitisers or stairlifts or notices on fire safety. And it doesn't seem terribly like home to have a room with a number, even if it does have your name on it, in cheerful lower case letters.
âArchie? Visitors for you.'
Archie Whitcliffe, who greets them at the door of his tiny room as if he were Jack Hastings himself, looks disconcertingly like his grandson. Superintendent Gerald Whitcliffe is tall and dark, vain about his hair and his suits. Archie Whitcliffe is also tall, though slightly stooped, with immaculate silver hair. He isn't wearing a suit but his cardigan and trousers are freshly pressed and he is wearing a tie, regimental by the look of it.
He shakes hands briskly. âSo you work for Gerald?'
That isn't quite how Nelson likes to look at it, but he nods. âYes. I'm Detective Chief Inspector Harry Nelson and this is Detective Sergeant Judy Johnson.'
Archie positively twinkles at Judy. âWhat a mouthful. Do you mind if I call you Judy?'
Judy smiles back. âNot at all.' There's no reason to antagonise the old boy, after all.
The room contains only a single bed, a desk with a television on it, an armchair and a bookcase. As well as the ubiquitous Norfolk print, there are several framed family
portraits. Judy cranes her head to catch a glimpse of a teenage Whitcliffe.
âHere,' says Archie obligingly. âGerald at his passing out parade.'
Judy looks at the newly qualified policeman, saluting, his neck vulnerable under the new cap. He looks about twelve.
âHe's done so well,' she says. âYou must be proud of him.'
âCourse I am. Proud of all my grandchildren.'
âHow many do you have?'
âTen. Gerald's the oldest.'
Jesus wept, thinks Nelson. The Whitcliffes are breeding like rabbits. There truly is no help for Norfolk.
Archie sits on the desk chair, gesturing Nelson to the armchair. Judy perches on the bed.
âMr Whitcliffe,' Nelson begins. âSuperintendent Whitcliffe, Gerald, may have told you about the skeletons found buried at Broughton Sea's End â¦'
âHe has.'
I bet he has, thinks Nelson. Despite the matter being strictly police business.
âWe believe these skeletons are of a group of men who may have died anywhere from forty to seventy years ago. This obviously includes the war years. I wondered if, as a member of the Home Guard, you remember any sort of incident at Broughton Sea's End.'
Archie is silent for a long time. Along the corridor someone is playing the piano accompanied by some rather weedy singing. âIf You Were the Only Girl in the World'.
âYou were in the Home Guard,' prompts Nelson.
âYes.' Archie seems visibly to straighten in his chair. âThe
Local Defence Volunteers we were called at first. I was too young to join up at the start of the war. Did later, of course. Tank Corps.' He gestures to the tie.