Obit

Obit

A MYSTERY
ANNE EMERY

For Joan

We’ll always have “O’Malley’s.”

Prologue

Pater noster qui es in coelis sanctificetur nomen tuum
Adveniat regnum tuum
Fiat voluntas tua sicut in coelo et in terra.

Our Father who art in heaven, hallowed be Thy name,
Thy kingdom come,
Thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven.

March 3, 1991

The white-robed priest, murder charges now behind him, lifted his arms, and the building was filled with the music of the spheres. Candlelight illumined the small Gothic church of Saint Bernadette’s and flickered against the magnificent stained glass of its windows. My little daughter sat at my side, enthralled with the beauty and the sound. On my other side was my son and his beloved, herself a budding choir director; they too were enraptured. At the end of the row sat the mother of my children, the wife who no longer shared my home. Lost in the music. Lost to me.

We were transported back in time from the Renaissance to the medieval as we heard the famous Gregorian
Pater Noster,
the Our Father. It is said that Mozart, when asked which piece of music he would like to have composed, named this setting of the
Pater Noster.
At times like this, when the music seemed to shimmer between light and sound, between the earthly and the ineffable, I could almost understand how a priest could turn away from the pleasures of the
flesh and marry his spirit with the divine. This particular priest had stumbled the odd time, as I well knew. As everyone knew, after the trial. But he had picked himself up, brushed the dust from his robes and carried on. The glory of this night, the first student concert he had put on since coming to the Saint Bernadette’s Choir School as music director a year and half ago, would buoy him through the next two days until it was time to leave for New York, for a rendezvous with his former lover, and a probe into the enigmatic past of his redoubtable father. If we had been able to foretell the events of the coming weeks, perhaps we would have remained in the sanctuary, contemplating the infinite and ordering in.

Chapter 1

He, too, has been changed in his turn,
Transformed utterly:
A terrible beauty is born.

— William Butler Yeats, “Easter 1916”

March 4, 1991

“My old fellow aged ten years when he read this, Monty. See what you make of it.”

The choirmaster was in my Halifax law office when I arrived the Monday morning after the concert. In civilian clothes Brennan Burke had the appearance of a military man, one regularly chosen for clandestine, lethal operations. With his hooded black eyes, silver-threaded black hair and austere facial expression, he was a formidable presence. He spoke in a clipped voice reminiscent of Ireland, where he had lived until the age of ten. That is when his family had fled the old country for New York, for reasons that had never been explained. The priest had come to Halifax eighteen months ago, in the fall of 1989, to establish the choir school at Saint Bernadette’s. It had been quite a time. He and I had met when he was charged with two counts of first degree murder in the deaths of two young women. I am happy to say I successfully defended him against the charges, and found the real killer, who is now serving a life sentence in prison. All in a day’s work for Montague Collins, Barrister, Solicitor and sole
criminal lawyer in the corporate law firm of Stratton Sommers.

The priest pulled a piece of paper from the inside pocket of his black leather jacket and slapped it on my desk, and I directed my attention to whatever it was that had taken ten years off the life of Declan Burke. It was an obituary from the
New York Times
dated December 4, 1990. Three months ago.

“My brother Patrick sent it to me. He was visiting our parents. The old fellow was trying to fix something under the sink, and my mother was doing her customary scan of the death notices. ‘Declan!’ she calls out. ‘Do you know a Cathal Murphy? Came over here from Dublin around the same time we did.’

“My father comes in to the living room and takes a look at the obit. The way Patrick tells it, Declan turned white and grew old in the time it took to read it over. ‘Da, what is it?’ Patrick asks, and tries to get him into a chair. ‘Your face has gone the colour of your hair.’

“All Pat gets by way of an answer is: ‘I straightened up too fast. You’d be white too if you had your mug parked under a sink all afternoon, then had to stand to attention for another dead Murphy.’ And he stalks from the room.”

I put up my hand to silence Brennan so I could read the clipping.

CATHAL MURPHY
, 73, of Sunnyside, Queens, and formerly of Dublin, Republic of Ireland. He immigrated to the US in 1950 after working in Ireland as a Businessman. What is less well known is that he put in many long and arduous hours doing Volunteer work as well. Here in the US, Cathal quickly made a name for himself in the export business. His loyalty to his Uncle was never in question. He is survived by his devoted wife Maria, and his sons Tom, Brendan, Stanley and Armand. Predeceased by his brother Benedict and stepson Stephen. Those of us who had the privilege of knowing Cathal knew a man who enjoyed a good time, who was never shy about sharing a song or a drink. And if you said no, Cathal would share it with you anyway! He’ll be sorely missed. When the members of a generation pass away, the family is often left with little more than its
memories; the telling details are locked away in a trunk and never get out of the attic. A better way — Cathal’s way — was to celebrate and live the past as if it formed part of the present, as indeed it does. He was fond of saying “nothing ever goes away.” You’re right, Cathal. Your spirit lives on in our hearts. We’ll all be there to see you off, Cathal, dressed to the nines and raising a pint of Lameki Jocuzasem in your honor! Funeral arrangements will be announced when finalized.

Brennan resumed speaking the second my eyes looked up from the clipping. “How often would you say ‘Republic of’ in something like this?”

“Let me stop you for a second. What is it that has everyone upset? Is this someone your father knew? Someone he had a history with?”

Burke jabbed the paper with his forefinger. “What Patrick thinks, and I’m following him there myself, is that our father read this as —” he cleared his throat “— as an indictment of his own life. And an announcement of his death.”

“What?” I exclaimed.

“Volunteer,” he said then. “It’s capitalized.”

“So’s ‘Businessman.’ You should see what gets capitalized here in the office. Lawyer, Adjuster, Report . . .”

He ignored me. “The Irish Volunteers.
Óglaigh na hÉireann
, the
IRA
. That much is clear. All the more so when the word ‘Uncle’ is added. My father’s father and his uncles were known to have played a role in the 1916 uprising. ‘He is survived by his devoted wife Maria.’ Maria, a name that could be Spanish like my mother’s name, Teresa. As you know, she had a Spanish father, Irish mother. A possibility. We’re told he was also survived by his sons Tom, Brendan, Stanley and Armand.” He looked at me. “Those four names. Does anything strike you about them?”

“No. Aside from the fact they are all men’s names, and one of them sounds like yours — but isn’t — I don’t see a pattern. They’re not even all Irish.”

“Right, but Tommy, Bren —” He paused. I waited. “Guns, Collins.”

“Brennan, for Christ’s sake! This just doesn’t sound like you. I can imagine your reaction if someone else came up with this, this —”

“Fantasy, you’re thinking. I know, but Patrick and I both think there’s something here and he’s not a fey kind of man either. And we weren’t stocious drunk when we spoke about this on the phone. So bear with me. Tommy gun, Bren gun, Sten gun, Armalite rifle.”

“Brennan,” I began and put up my hand to fend off an interruption. “Surely it has occurred to you that you may be reading something into this, something that is not really there.”

“It has occurred to me. I’ve dismissed that notion. It’s here, I know it.” He paused to take out a pack of cigarettes from his jacket pocket. I had given up telling him that Stratton Sommers was a smoke-free office; he found the ashtray I kept for him, lit up a smoke, and returned to his train of thought. “Predeceased by his brother Benedict and by his stepson Stephen. Now, disregard those two names for a moment. I admit they throw me off, because my father did not have a brother who died, and he certainly does not have a stepson.”

I shook my head, moved the paper closer with my finger and skimmed the obituary again. “I’m more interested in the pint of ‘Lameki Jocuzasem.’ What in the hell is that?”

“No idea. Doesn’t sound like a local brew, does it? Let’s stop by the Midtown Tavern and ask one of the waiters.”

“Let’s not. I’d like to be able to show my face in there again some day. And the day after that.”

What I did not say was that I would like to enjoy the upcoming New York trip my family and I had planned with Brennan Burke. He had been asked to officiate at the wedding of his niece, Katie, and he decided to extend his visit for a few weeks. I hoped his distraction over the death notice would be short-lived. Brennan certainly needed a break, after the year he’d just had. And I could use a rest as well. My holiday was to start the very next day. I had leapt at the chance of a month in New York when a complicated products liability suit had been settled on the courthouse steps, affording me the gift of several weeks with no obligations. I was determined to take advantage of the free time. My wife, Professor Maura MacNeil, had strong-armed someone into taking over her classes at Dalhousie Law School for
three weeks, so we could give our kids a trip to New York City.

I mentioned my wife; I should have said “estranged wife.” But I’m not one to give up easily. I saw the vacation as an opportunity to put an end to years of squabbling and living in separate houses. After all, if I could oversee the settlement of years of squabbling and costly litigation between the consumers, suppliers and manufacturers of defective concrete, which had caused the foundations of two hundred new houses to sink and crumble, how difficult would it be to charm my own wife back into my loving embrace?

Chapter 2

Going to take a sentimental journey,
going to set my heart at ease.
Going to take a sentimental journey
to renew old memories.

— Bud Green/Les Brown/Ben Homer, “Sentimental Journey”

March 5, 1991

I called Brennan the next morning, the day of our departure, to confirm the plans we had made for our first evening in New York. I was catching a later flight with my family but we would be there in plenty of time to meet him in the lobby of the Metropolitan Opera House, where we would be seeing a new production of
Norma
. Our teenage son, Tommy Douglas, and his little sister, Normie, were not at all displeased that they would have the hotel room, with its pay-per-view movies and room service, to themselves while we were at the opera.

“You’re bringing the family to the wedding,” Brennan said. It was a statement, not a question. “It’s at seven o’clock Friday evening.”

“Did you inform your brother that four strangers will be showing up at his daughter’s wedding and reception?”

“Everyone knows you’re coming and, if they didn’t, who’d notice you in a crowd of three hundred other people?”

I took that as the gracious invitation it was no doubt meant to be.

“So, Brennan,” I asked, “have you issued an invitation to Sandra to join you at the wedding?”

“Hardly.”

“Why ‘hardly’? She’s an old friend of the family, through you, and you gave me to understand you’d be looking her up whenever we made a trip to New York. You’re going to see her, right?”

He made a kind of noncommittal noise. He might or he might not; it was of no importance.

He had not seen Sandra Worthington, formerly the love of his life, in the quarter century that had passed since his ordination as a celibate priest. But I had met her; I interviewed her at her posh Manhattan apartment while conducting research for Brennan’s trial. Then, after he was exonerated, Sandra showed up unexpectedly at a concert in which he was guest conductor. She had been overseeing repairs at her family’s old summer home in Chester, and had driven to Halifax for the concert. Her arrival had rendered Brennan speechless. But once he recovered himself, he, Sandra, Maura and I had spent a couple of hours at the post-concert party, drinking, talking, reminiscing, bickering . . . just like old times for all of us. Sandra had departed early, leaving Brennan to do his best not to look bereft. Now, it seemed, we were back to “Sandra who?”

Well, not quite, as it turned out. “You’ll be seeing her tonight.”

“I’ll be seeing her, Brennan, or you will?”