To no avail . . .
It was dawn when Tovi roused himself from his blankets. Beside him his wife groaned in her sleep. It was cold in the cabin and Tovi placed his own blanket over hers. The children were still asleep. Tovi moved to the fire, which had died down to a few smoldering ashes. With a stick he pushed the last few glowing embers together, then blew them into life, adding kindling until the flames licked up. Pulling on his boots and overshirt he tried to open the door of the cabin, but snow had piled up against the door in the night and Tovi had to squeeze through a narrow gap to emerge into the dawn light. Using his hands, he scooped the snow away from the door and then pushed it shut.
Grame was already awake when Tovi called at his small hut. The smith, wrapped in a long sheepskin coat and holding a long-handled felling axe, stepped out to join him. “The sky's clear,” said Grame, “and it feels milder.”
“The worst is yet to come,” said Tovi.
“I know that!” snapped Grame. “God, Tovi, must you stay so gloomy?”
Tovi reddened at the rebuke and glared at the white-bearded smith. “Give me one good reason to be optimistic and I shall. I will even dance a jig for you! We have nearly three thousand people living in squalor, and what are we waiting for? To face famine or slaughter in the spring. Am I wrong?”
“I do not know if you are wrong, Tovi. That's the truth of it. But you could be. Concentrate on that. We now have five hundred fighting men, hard men, fueled by anger and the need for revenge. By spring we could have thousands. Then we will see. Why do you need to show such despair? It does no good.”
“I am not skilled at hiding my feelings, Grame,” admitted Tovi. “I am getting old and I have no fire in my belly. They killed my son, destroyed my village. Now I feel as if I am waiting for the rest of my family to be put to the sword. I find it hard to stomach.”
Grame nodded. “You are not so old, Tovi. And as for your stomachâwell, you look better than you have in years. Felling trees and building cabins has been good for you. Come the spring, that claymore will have no more weight than a goose feather. Then you'll find the fire.”
Tovi forced a smile and scanned the camp. To the south the new community hall was almost half built, the ground leveled, the log walls already around five feet high. Eighty feet long and thirty wide, the structure when finished would allow many people of the encampment to gather together in the evenings. This, Tovi knew, would encourage a greater camaraderie and help lift morale. “How long now?” he asked, pointing at the structure.
“Five days. We'll be felling trees on the north slope today. If there's no fresh snow for a while we might finish in three.”
All around them people were emerging from the huts. Tovi saw the Outlander Obrin. The man was dressed now in borrowed leggings and a leather tunic; he strolled to a tree and urinated against the trunk. “I don't like the man,” said Tovi.
“Aye, he's iron hard,” Grame agreed.
“It is not that. There is an arrogance about him that slips under my skin like a barbed thorn. Look at the way he walks . . . as if he is a king and all around him are serfs and vassals.”
Grame chuckled. “You are seeing too much. Fell walks like that. Sigarni too.”
“Aye, but they're Highlanders.”
Grame's chuckle became a full-blooded laugh as he clapped his hand on Tovi's shoulder. “Listen to yourself! Is that not arrogance? Anyway, Obrin is a HighlanderâFell's son.”
“Pah! Put a wolf in a kilt and it is still a wolf!”
Grame shook his head. “You are not good company today, Hunt Lord,” he said. Tovi watched him stride away through the snow.
He's right, thought Tovi, with a stab of guilt. I am the Hunt Lord and I should be lifting the hearts of my people. He sighed and trudged off toward Obrin. The warrior had removed his shirt and was kneeling and rubbing snow over his upper body. As Tovi came closer he saw the web of scars on Obrin's chest and upper arms. The man looked up at him, his eyes cold.
“Good morning, Hunt Lord.”
“And to you, Obrin. How is the training progressing?”
Obrin rose and pulled on his shirt and tunic. “Six of the groups are proving adequate. No more than that. The others . . .” He shrugged. “If they don't want to learn, then I cannot force them.”
“You don't need to teach a Highlander to fight,” said Tovi. Obrin gave a rare smile but it did not soften his face. If anything, Tovi realized, it made him look more deadly.
“That is true, Hunt Lord. They know how to fight, and they know how to die. What they don't comprehend is that war is not about fighting and dying. It is about winning. And no army can win without discipline. A general must know that when heâor in our case
she
âgives an order it will be obeyed without question. We don't have that here. What we have is five hundred arrogant warriors who, upon seeing the enemy, will brandish their claymores and rush down to die. Just like the Farlain.”
Tovi's first response was one of anger, but he swallowed it down. What would this Outlander understand of Highland pride, of the warrior's code? Fighting involved honor and courage. These Outlanders treated it as a trade. Even so, he knew that the man was speaking honestly. Worse, he was not wrong. “Try to understand, Obrin,” he said softly. “Here each man is an individual. Wars between clans always come down to man against man. There was never any question of tactics. Even when we fought . . . your people . . . we did not learn. We charged. We died. You are dealing with a people who have fought this way for generations. I don't even know whether the older warriors can absorb these new ideas. So be patient. Try to find some way to appeal to the younger men. Convince them.”
“I have already told them what is real,” said Obrin stubbornly. “And if that wasn't enough they have the example of the Farlain.”
“We are a proud people, Obrin. We can be led to the borders of Hell itself, but we cannot be driven. Can you understand that?”
“I'll think on it,” said the Outlander. “But I never was an officer, and I'm no leader. All I know is what I've learned through seventeen years of bloody war. But I'll think on it.”
A young woman approached them, a heavy woolen shawl wrapped around her slender shoulders. “By your leave, Hunt Lord,” she said with a curtsy. “My grandfather is sick and cannot rise from his bed. Can you come?”
“Aye, lass,” said Tovi wearily.
Obrin watched the Hunt Lord trudge off through the snow, saw the weariness in the man. He wears defeat like a cloak, thought the warrior. The former Outlander wandered away from the camp, climbing high onto the mountainside to the meeting cave. Three men were already present, and they had lit a fire. Their conversation faded away as Obrin entered. He walked slowly to the far side of the fire and sat, glancing down at the two bundles he had left there earlier; they were untouched. Obrin waited in silence until others arrived, some singly, some in pairs, others in small groups until twentyfive were assembled. Obrin rose and looked at their faces. Many of them were scarce more than children. They waited, sullen and wary.
“No work today,” said Obrin, breaking the silence. “Today we talk. Now I am not a great talkerâand even less of a teacher. But at this moment I am all that you have. So open your ears and listen.”
“Why should we listen?” asked a young man in the front row. He was no more, Obrin guessed, than around fourteen years of age. “You tell us to carry rocks, we carry rocks. You tell us to run and we run. I do not need to hear the words of an Outland traitor. Just give us your orders and we shall obey them.”
“Then I order you to listen,” said Obrin, without trace of anger. His eyes raked the group. “Your friendship means nothing to me,” he told them. “It is worth less than a sparrow's droppings. We are not here for friendship. What I am trying to do is give you a chanceâa tiny chanceâto defend your loved ones against a powerful enemy. Oh, I know you are prepared to die. The Farlain have shown us all how well a Highlander can give up his life. But you don't
win
by dying. You win by causing your enemy to die. Is that so hard to understand? The Hunt Lord says a Highlander cannot be driven. Is he incapable also of learning? If not, how did he acquire the skills to build homes, weave cloth, make bows and swords? What is so different about war? It is a game of skill and daring, of move and countermove. The Outlandersâas you call themâare masters of war.”
“Masters of slaughter more like!” came a voice from the middle rows.
“Aye, and slaughter,” agreed Obrin. “But in a battle they hold together. It is called discipline. It is nothing to do with honor, or glory. Yet all victories are based upon it.” Obrin walked to the first of the bundles and flipped back the blanket covering it. Stooping, he lifted a dozen sticks, each no thicker than his thumb and no longer than his forearm. Tossing them one by one to the nearest clansmen, he said, “Break them!”
The first man chuckled and glanced down at the thin length of wood. “Why?” he asked.
“Just do it.”
The sound of snapping wood echoed in the cave, followed by laughter as someone said, “The great warrior has certainly taught us to master stick splitting.”
“Easy, was it not?” said Obrin amiably. “No trouble. A child could do it. And that, my fine clansmen, is how the Outlanders will deal with you. It is not a question of bravery, or honor. You fight as individuals, single sticks. Now, this is how the Outlanders fight.” Taking up the second bundle, which was also composed of a dozen sticks, but tightly bound with twine, he tossed it to the jester. “Come then,” said Obrin, “show me how you have mastered stick splitting. Break them!”
The man stood and held the bundle at both ends. Suddenly he bent his knee and brought the sticks down hard across his thigh. Several sticks gave, but the bundle remained intact. Angrily he hurled the sticks on the fire. “What does it prove?” he snarled. “But give me a claymore and I'll show you what I can do!”
“Sit down, lad,” said Obrin. “I do not doubt your courage. The lesson is a simple one to absorb. What you saw was two bundles. Each bundle had twelve sticks. One could be broken, the other could not. It is the same with armies. When the clans fought at Colden Moor they fought in the only way they knew, shoulder to shoulder, claymores swinging. They were brought down by archers and slingers, lancers and pike-men, heavy cavalry and armored swordsmen. They were beaten decisively, but not routed. They stood their ground and died like men. By God, what a waste of courage! Did any here see the Farlain dead?”
Several men spoke up. Obrin nodded and waved them to silence. “What you saw was easy to read. The Outlanders were in the valley. The Farlain attacked from the high ground, sweeping down on them, their claymores bright in the morning sun. The Outlanders formed a tight shield wall, their spears extending. The Farlain ran upon the spears, trying to beat a path through. Then the cavalry came from the right, from their hiding places in a wood. Archers appeared on the left sending volley after volley into the Highland ranks. How long did the battle last? Not an hour. Not even half that. According to Fell it was probably over in a few short minutes. The Outlanders carried their dead away in a single wagonâten . . . fifteen . . . twenty bodies at the most. The Farlain lost hundreds. Are the clans too stupid to learn from their errors?” They were listening now, intently, their eyes locked to Obrin's face. “We all know the animals of the forest, and their ways. When faced with wolves, a stag will run. The wolves lope after him, slowly robbing him of strength. At last he turns at bay, and they come at him from all sides. If he is strong his horns will kill some, then he dies. You are like the stag. The Outlanders are the wolves; only they are worse than wolves. They have the horns of the stag, the stamina and cunning of the wolf pack, the claws of the bear, and the fangs of the lion. To defeat them, we must emulate them.”
“How do we do this?” asked the boy who made the earlier jest.
“Your question is a good beginning,” Obrin told him. “Understanding is the first key. All war is based on deception. When you are weak, you make the enemy think you are strong; when you are strong, make him think you are weak. When you are far away, make him believe you are near, and when you are near, lead him to think you are far away. The Outlanders did this to the Farlain. Their scouts must have told them the clansmen were near, so they hid their cavalry and archers. The Farlain saw the infantry occupying a weak position and attacked. In doing so, they walked into the iron jaws of the monster. We will not follow their example. We will fight on our own terms, choosing our own ground. If necessary, we will fight and run. We will make them the stag, and we shall be the wolves.
“To fight like this takes great discipline and enormous strength of heart, but it is the only way to win. Go now and talk among yourselves. Choose a unit leader from among you; he will be your officer. Pass the word to the other twenty-five groups. Tell them to appoint one man to represent them. Then I want all officers to report to me here at dawn tomorrow.”
As the men stood to leave Obrin lifted his hand. “One more point, my lads. I am from a Highland people far to the south. We are called the Arekki. I am the only man of my clan within three hundred miles. I am Obrin, and I do not lie, cheat, or steal. Not once in my life have I betrayed a friend or comrade, nor have I ever fled from an enemy. The next man to call me a traitor to my face will die on my sword. Go now!”
Sleeting hail beat against the windows as Asmidir sat at his desk with quill pen in hand, poring over maps of the Highlands. Two lanterns were glowing close by, casting gentle light on the sheets of paper littering the desktop. Asmidir stared hard at the lines on the ancient parchment, trying to picture the pass of Duane. Sheer to the east, mildly sloping to the west, it opened out into two box canyons and a long, narrow plain. Dipping his pen into the ink jar he sketched the pass, adding notations concerning distance and height.