Authors: Taylor Bell
We sat in silence.
“I just couldn't bring myself to snitch on anyone, even Colette. I didn't want to hurt the house, you know? I guess her priorities skewed a little differently.”
“How could she do this to you and live with herself?”
“I've asked myself that question over and over and over. And the answer is always the same. Colette won and I lost. She's a sociopathâtextbook narcissist, superficially charming, manipulative, cunning. I was supposed to go to Africa; I didn't make that up entirely. But the internship started in August and obviously I was institutionalized already at that point.”
“How did I not see all of this going on? How did Mom and Dad not let it slip?”
“You were a senior in high school last year. You were in your own world, where you should've been. And you were excited about graduating and about CDU. We all decided to just keep it hush-hush. We were trying to look out for you.”
I had to stop myself from crying. I was the youngest and they were looking out for me.
“All Colette thinks about is herself,” I said. “I mean, I knew I sensed a bitchy, conniving side to her. But Jesus. This? This is insane.”
“Honestly, she's probably terrified of you,” Kelly said, taking a sip of her beer. “Bottom line: Colette may be a liar who sold me down the river, but she's also a shark. She got off
on the business of it all. I think it made her feel powerful. It was weird; we were friends at first and I actually liked her because she was so direct and bossyâyou know how she is. But then when it got bigger, and our list of clients started to include some pretty big names on campus, the power went to her head.”
As if reading my mind, Kelly put her hand on my leg and continued, “You can't resign and you can't fight her. It will only make more of a mess.”
I paused.
“No fucking way,” I quietly said. “Of course I can't resign. If I quit now then Colette will totally get off scot-free . . . uggghhhhhhh!!”
“Whoa, whoa.”
“I could kill her. I knew something was weird. I totally knew something was, like, very, very weird with her.”
A tornado of thoughts raced around my head. I was mad and confused; I wondered what Colette knew, or what she thought of me. Why had she let them dirty rush me at all? Did she only draw me in so that she could watch my every move? And who else knew?
“Does she know that I know?” I asked.
“CDU made us sign confidentiality agreements. So I'm guessing she doesn't think you know. And besides, she knows what lengths I've gone to in order to protect Beta Zeta. Telling you the truth would have put all of that at risk.”
“I guess . . .”
“Also, Colette is insanely good at reading people. I'm sure she'd be able to tell if you had dirt on her.”
“I don't know, Kelly, I think she dirty rushed me because she wanted to keep her enemies close.”
“I think
you were dirty rushed because Meg and the girls genuinely like you and wanted you to pledge. Of course, the fact that you're a legacy is what made them pursue you in the first place. But it would not have happened without Colette's blessing, and she definitely wanted to keep a close eye on youâof that I'm positive. But there's no way she'd just assume that you know.”
“This is so much to deal with . . . Oh my God, does Jack know?” My palms were sweating.
“Alright, slow down. I don't think he knew about it and he was definitely not a client. He's not the kind of kid we were dealing with.”
“Are you sure?”
“Yes. Don't worry about that.”
“How can I not worry about that?!”
“Jesus! I knew you'd react or whatever, but you are on ten right now when really you should be on seven, maybe eight. It's kind of amaze, though. But, Tay?”
“What?”
“I'm serious about you leaving all of this alone. You need to take this information and just swallow it. Clearly the sisterhood of Beta Zeta and the code of silence among pill poppers have been successful in keeping the scandalâand my involvement in itâa secret. You're making friends and doing your thing and you'll have your own experience at BZ. You can't let this shit from the past ruin anything for you and you cannot get involved. It's not your mess to clean up, and frankly, it's over. Water under the
bridge. I fucked up, I served my time and that's it. I can't control Colette and her bullshit. Just don't get involved. You're better than this.”
I sensed an awkward smile creeping onto my face. Kelly also smiled. I felt a rush of adrenaline and then boom! It felt like I hit a wall going a hundred miles an hour.
“It's gonna be fine,” I said, putting my hand on her shoulder. “I'm gonna go back there and everything's gonna be super fine. Jack, the girls, school. I'll make it work. This will have a happy ending. I won't get involved. It's okay.”
“Really?”
“I know you're probably thinking,
let's talk this out, let's make sure Taylor's all good and not gonna freak out later
, but trust me. I'm fine.”
“I mean, if you don't want to talk about it anymore, I will not argue with that.”
“You fucking bitch!” I said, pushing her back into the sofa by her shoulders. We were laughing like kids.
But it wasn't really fine. I was freaking out inside and I wanted to scream. Most of all I wanted to scream at Colette for putting me in this position and for what she'd done to my sister. Sure, they'd both fucked up royally, but Colette took it to a whole other level of shadiness.
I wanted her to pay . . . but the truth was I'd probably be on the floor of my bedroom later, curled up and not even crying, just thinking really fucking hard.
“A
re you fucking kidding me?!”
I was letting Jonah have his freakout moment.
“Are you fucking KID-DING-ME-with-this-shit-right-now?” He was really angry.
“I know. I know.”
“Knew that bitch wasn't normal from the moment I met her at that party at Jack's house.”
“Duh, no normal person eats soup for dinner every night of the week.”
I was starting to feel more sane. Jonah got me, he knows me, he understands how I react to the world. I'd had more than a week to live with the new info about Colette and Kelly, but I'd
waited until Jonah and I were in his car alone, headed back to school for the Snow Bash (which was supposed to be the most epic Greek party of the year), to drop the bomb. He'd been running around having what he refers to as “forced family fun” during Christmas week and I knew how stressful that kind of stuff was for him, so I'd made the decision to hold off on telling him my interesting news. Also . . . I think I just needed time to try and personally process everything. Not that I was very successful at that.
“The thing that's so fucked up is that this little tidbit of info, like, basically affects every aspect of your life, you know?”
“Like, can I trust anyone at this point? My parents lied to me, my sister lied to me, and my sorority used to run a drug ring.” I sighed. “So that's what I've been dealing with for the past ten days.”
“I'm sorry, babe. That sucks in a major way.”
“Thanks.” I stared out the window and realized I'd done nothing but talk about myself.
“Shit, I'm horrible. How was your Christmas and everything?”
“It was fine. My dad's a dick, my mom's a drunk, my brother's an assholeâand his video game obsession scares me. But other than those minor details, it could have been worse.”
“Sounds festive.”
“It was a festive mess.”
“Families are a mess.”
“Truth,” Jonah agreed with a nod. “I never, ever thought I would say this, but I wish classes started tomorrow. I mean, I'm glad we get to go back to campus, but after the Snow Bash, I have to go back to my parents' dysfunctional home for another
week of misery. I could honestly fucking murder you for the fact that you're just gonna stay at school till classes start. My parents would never let me skip out on a week of torture with them.”
“Well, after this whole thing happened with Kelly on Christmas Eve, I was pretty much calling the shots in that house. They all felt like shitheads for lying to me.”
“Every cloud . . .”
“I guess.” I wanted to talk about something else. Anything else. “Will Ryan be in town at least?” Ryan was a guy from our hometown whom Jonah had kind of dated on and off the summer before we left for CDU.
“Maybs,” Jonah replied, semi-blushing.
“Well, that should keep you occupied. Maybe you guys could go for a swim together.”
“Haha. There's definitely been heavy texting.”
“Love that.”
“We shall see.”
Jonah rolled up his window.
“P.S. I can't believe your preppy-ass sister was a drug dealer.”
“No. I honestly can't with that whole aspect of it. Can we move on to a different subjectâ”
“I'm all for being proactive as a fund-raiser for a cause you believe in, but this is ridiculous.”
I guess we had no choice but to keep talking about it.
“Doesn't surprise me one bit that Colette was involved, though,” I added.
“Oh, me neith. Nothing would surprise me about that girl. Speaking of little miss drug lord . . . What are you going to say to her when you see her?”
“I don't know. Kelly
said not to get involved. And she spent six fucking months in rehab to keep the chapter's secret . . . What do you think I should do? Do I come right out and tell her I know what's up?”
“Fuck yeah, you do. In front of all those bitches. She deserves a public stoning.”
“She most definitely does, but it's the other girls I worry about. This whole scandal is going to crush them. They all look up to Colette like some sort of holy benefactor. I don't think they can handle it.”
“You're not considering just keeping quiet on this, are you?”
“No . . . I mean, I don't think so.”
Jonah pulled off the road and onto the shoulder, slamming on the brakes.
“Taylor Natalie Bell, I'm sorry, but you are honestly brainwashed if you just let this one slide. You and Kelly may not have been that close, but she's your sister, like, your real sister, and Colette fucked with her whole future! I don't know what those girls did to you to make you this way, but trust me it's not a good look.”
“Jesus. Okay! I'm gonna do something. Obviously. Retribution will be dealt. But I just need to figure out what my move is.”
“It's pretty simple, Tayâ”
“It's not as simple as you might think. This scandal is not public knowledge in the house. Some girls might know bits and pieces, but no one knows what really went down. These girls are all innocent.”
“So?”
“So . . . they have been really nice to me.”
“Who cares?
Colette lied to them all. All the more reason to humiliate her and get her out of there.”
“If I expose her publicly, it'll create so much tension in the house. And the way these girls gossip, I'm sure it would get out that Beta Zeta was involved in a scandal, which could end up getting our chapter shut down.”
“Are you listening to yourself? You're protecting these rando girls above the dignity of yourself and Kelly?”
“Yes, Jonah, I am. Think about the lengths Kelly already went to. She was in rehab for six months, and she doesn't even do drugs. If I go in there now and freak out and scream at Colette, what good will that do? Kelly's commitment to all of them will be wasted.”
Jonah just sat there in silence, looking at the road ahead.
“I get it.”
“You do?”
“Yeah. I get it.”
Jonah zoomed back out onto the highway.
“You have your reasons and I support you,” he continued. “But please tell me you are at least working on a plan to privately yet savagely destroy her.”
“I might be,” I confessed.
“I can help you come up with something good.”
“I know you can.”
“You have to let her know that you know. That needs to happen stat.”
“Really? Why?”
“Because for maximum effect, you need Colette to be squirming every time she's around you, constantly wondering if you're about to blow up her whole spot.”
“I like
the sound of that. But how do I do that, you know?”
“Just tell her how you got home and finally got to catch up with Kelly. If you say it like you mean it, she'll get it right away. Colette's not a fucking dummy.”
“True. But she kind of is. She's like smart-stupid.”
“Very, very true.”
“I'm just trying to focus on the positive parts of my life. You, Jack, my grades, and my magnificent breasts.”
There was no one I'd rather have been with at that moment than Jonah. The rest of the drive we geeked out and listened to the soundtrack of
Wicked.
We sang/screamed our faces off. It was the release I needed after the vacation I'd had (if you can even call it that).
I never, in a million years, would've expected to be thrilled to get back to my dorm room. It was empty and boring and peacefully devoid of anything that made me think of the mess that was my life. I plopped onto the bed and let out a huge scream into my pillow, which was only semi-relieving.
I couldn't stop wondering when I'd see Colette next and how it would go down. I remembered her saying that she was going away on vacation over break, but I didn't know if she was coming back to school early for Snow Bash or not. Until my phone blew up with a group-text string that clued me in:
M
eg 3:17PM
How the fuck is everyone's break? I'm bored.
Stephanie 3:18PM
Same. I'm over being on break. All I've been doing is eating mini muffins