Chasing Di'Maggio: a BWWM romance (9 page)

Nicolette woke up to Matty’s hand roaming everywhere on her body. She didn’t know whether to react to it or just let him continue; it wasn’t like she hated it. She felt ashamed because that turned her on, the way his hand was slowly rubbed her belly. She looked down and saw that Matty’s hand was going further down than her belly. She couldn’t stop him; she didn’t want to stop him. Why did she only wear underwear when she slept? It’s as if Matty knew where to go. Nicolette knew that Matty was still asleep. How the hell was he doing this? She just watched in amazement as Matty slipped his hand inside her panties. She gasped as his fingers went to work. She didn’t know whether to make him stop or what else to do. She just knew it felt good. No one had ever made her feel like this.
Well, maybe because no one has ever touched you,
Nico thought to herself. Matty really was going to make her feel way too good on their wedding day; she felt she was reaching cloud nine.

She felt Matty grow harder. He was so close to her, as though he was glued to her body. Nicolette ended up thinking of him in the bathroom naked and how the way he felt right now seemed like he was bigger than what he appeared to be. She couldn’t help it and ended up moaning. That woke Matty up and he realized what he was doing. Matty didn’t know whether to apologize or just continue to make Nicolette feel good. It’s as though his hand had a mind of its own, but he wasn’t regretting it. He was just upset that he was asleep through it all. Nicolette didn’t want Matty to stop, so as he was taking his hands out of her panties, she grabbed his wrist.

“Wait.”

“Nic?”

“Matty.”

“Nico, I’m so—”

“Don’t apologize. It’s okay. I want this.”

“Are you sure? I don’t want you to just say it.”

“I’m sure.”

Matty wanted this to be special. He practically jumped out of the bed, walking away from the bed.

“I can’t, Nico. I’m sorry. I got to go.”

“What? Why?”

“Nico, I’m not going to explain myself.”

“Wait. Is it because I’m a virgin?”

Matty was left speechless. It was a good thing he was standing away from Nico by then and not facing her because if she saw the look on his face… Oh man. Matty was pleasantly surprised that she was still a virgin. He didn’t know why he was so happy that no other man had her. Even though he knew he sounded like a caveman, he couldn’t help but smile at the thought of being her first.

“Matty, talk to me.”

He didn’t know why he turned around, but when he saw her face and how beautiful she looked, he didn’t know what came over him as he took his t-shirt off, returned to the bed and got on top of Nicolette. Nicolette didn’t think twice about anything as she initiated the kiss. Matty coaxed her into letting him in all the way. They were kissing as though they’d been deprived of each other for the longest time. Their tongues were so intertwined. Matty’s hands were exploring Nicolette’s body as he deepened the kiss. He couldn’t resist as he slipped his fingers back in her panties. This time he wanted to make sure that he remembered every part of her body and how she looked like when she was hot for him. Matty stopped kissing her and looked at Nico’s face; he’d never seen her face like that. She looked so sexy to him, which made him want her even more. He definitely wasn’t thinking with the same head anymore.

Nicolette had her eyes closed, registering everything in her mind, letting everything sink in as Matty’s fingers were going to work inside her. She didn’t know how to react, he was sending her over the edge again. She couldn’t hold on for long. Matty was going to send her off in a matter of minutes. It was amazing to her how he could just do this to her without being inside her. She knew she was close so she bit her lip, but Matty distracted her and kissed her closed eyelids, making her open them. She stared right into Matty’s eyes. She didn’t know what that look was, but she couldn’t control herself as he finally sent her over the edge. She was about to moan real loud, but Matty tugged at her bottom lip, sucking on it, making her feel like she was going to lose her mind. He started to kiss her whole body. Nico didn’t want to miss a second of this, so she looked down to where Matty was passing her belly button.

She attempted to get his attention. “Matty?”

But he ignored her obvious apprehension. “Do you know how beautiful you are?”

“Matty?”

“I’m going to show you how beautiful you are to me, baby.”

Nicolette was caught by surprise when Matty put his tongue to work. She thought that his fingers were magic, but his tongue did the trick. Nicolette thought she would have a heart attack even before she lost her virginity. How was it that he was this good? His hands were caressing her thighs at the same time as he was showing her how beautiful she was to him. Matty wasn’t even breaking a sweat, but Nicolette was sweating from all the heat she was feeling. She didn’t know it felt this good, and if she did know ahead of time, maybe she wouldn’t have waited this long. Matty was about to send her past cloud nine this time.

She didn’t know what to do, so she placed both her hands on Matty’s head. Her breathing started to quicken and she knew she was about to be sent over the edge again. God, what Matty was doing to her, now it was definite that she would never leave him. Where would she find someone who worked her in this way even before being inside her? It’s as if he didn’t need any air. When Matty sent her over the edge, he came back up and started to kiss her. She had a very confused expression on her face because she didn’t know how to react to kissing him after what he just did.

“Don’t like the way you taste, baby?”

Nicolette didn’t know what to say, the way that Matty kept calling her baby just made her want to melt again. Everything Matty did turned her on.

“I don’t know. Am I supposed to?”

“Nico, you don’t like it?”

“I love anything you do right about now, Matty.”

“I love it when you say my name.”

Nicolette didn’t know how this was happening, but she was happy that it was. Matty got off the bed and took his sweats off. Nicolette was so nervous but she couldn’t help but stare at Matty as he took everything off. Nicolette thought that Matty’s body was the best thing she had ever seen. He was so tall, broad shoulders, the six-pack, and the v-cut that she just wanted to lick. Nicolette knew that Matty just kept on turning her on more and more. When Matty took off his boxers, Nicolette’s eyes were about to pop out of her socket. Nicolette had no idea that Matty was that thick and long. She knew he wasn’t going to fit and her heart started to race. Matty got back on the bed, which sank down at his weight. Matty saw the fear in Nicolette’s eyes and he tried to assure her that it was going to be okay. The kisses that Nicolette was receiving from Matty were the sweetest, softest kisses she had ever received in her life. Nicolette started relaxing when Matty deepened the kiss as Matty was getting ready to enter her but Nicolette’s body started to tense up again.

“Matty.”

“Shh. Shh, baby. Relax, breathe.”

“Matty, I don’t think I can.”

“Shh baby, let me in.”

Nicolette started to relax as Matty was kissing her everywhere. Nicolette had no idea how his kisses made her relax so much. She felt each inch of him as he slowly entered. Nicolette shut her eyes as Matty made her forget everything else. She couldn’t help but concentrate on his kisses on her lips, her neck, and her ears. When he started nibbling on her ear, she couldn’t help but giggle.

“Why the hell are you giggling?”

“My ear, Matty… My ear.”

Matty took the opportunity to slide all the way in, and Nicolette gasped.

“You okay, baby?” But she was too caught up to respond. “Nico, talk to me, babe.”

“I’m good,” she forced out.

“You sure? I’ll give it a second to adjust. Look at me, Nic. Relax.” And as she did as she was told, he coaxed her, “Yes, baby, just like that.”

Matty was more than surprised that this was happening. He didn’t want to hurt Nicolette, so he didn’t go too far with her this time. When Nicolette relaxed, Matty started to move slowly, making sure that Nicolette was with him. The way she wrapped her legs around his waist, pulling him closer, made him even harder. He felt as though he was going to go crazy.

Nicolette didn’t realize that she fell asleep, all she knew was that Matty made her feel like she was on clouds. Matty made sure she experienced what she had been missing out on but he held back because he didn’t want to hurt her.

They had no clue what just changed, but they knew something had. As they laid there sleeping on the bed, Matty couldn’t wish for this to be any different. Nicolette and Matty were so comfortable sleeping next to each other they had no clue as to how their positions in bed switched. He woke up to Nicolette laying her head on his chest. He was looking at how innocent she looked; the way she was smiling even in her dreams, the way her hair was a big mess all over her face. She looked way too gorgeous for him and he couldn’t resist but kiss her senseless again. Even with just a kiss, Matty couldn’t help but get hard again and want to go at it again, but it was time to get ready for the wedding.

There was a knock on the door that woke Nicolette up. Matty was already awake.

“Guys, it’s time for us to get ready. People are downstairs to get the bride ready and Matt, bro, you have to come with us and get ready,” Gabriel said.

Matty and Nicolette completely forgot about their wedding. They both started laughing at the irony of having sex the morning of their wedding instead of their wedding night.

“Guys? Hello! Wake up!”

“Ugh, Mike, we’re awake....Nico, I’ll see you at the wedding.”

“Okay.”

Watching Matty put his clothes back on, Nico realized that this would be even harder for her if ever they had to separate and that made her heart ache. As Matty left the room, Nico plopped her head back on the pillow smiling, then she remembered that her and Matty didn’t use a condom. She started to panic, but then reality kicked in that she took birth control to regulate her horrible monthly issues. Shaking her head as to how stupid that was, Nicolette promised herself that she couldn’t let the same thing happen again. Nicolette looked at the time and realized that it was already noon. Weddings really do stress people out, but lucky for her she was now stress-free. She decided to shower and go downstairs before her mother came and cursed her out into next week.

As Nicolette went downstairs, her mother Natalia, Matty’s mom, Katerina, and Grandma Antonia were all looking at her suspiciously. Nicolette wondered if they could detect that she just slept with Matty. She hoped to God that they couldn’t or else she was screwed.

“Hi, mom.”

“Nicolette. Hi, honey. Are you ready to go?”

“Go where?”

“Did you honestly think you’d look like that for your wedding? We have to go to get your hair done, makeup done, then get your dress on.”

“Oh... Hi, Grandma Antonia. I missed you.”

“Oh,
amore mia
, I’ve missed you so much and congratulations on the wedding. So Matty, huh? I knew it!”

Nicolette couldn’t help but smile at Antonia, although her heart broke when she saw how weak she looked in her wheelchair and how she was using every last breath and bit of strength to attend the wedding. It made Nicolette want to cry.

“I will have to answer that later, Grandma Antonia,” she giggled. “Mrs. Di’Maggio, hi. How are you?”

“Oh, I’m wonderful and happy—now come on, let’s go get this show on the road.”

“Wait, don’t I need my purse or anything?”

“Nope. Just you. You have your cell, right?”

“Yes, ma’am.”

“Then let’s go, my future daughter-in-law. Thank you, Nico. Seriously, thank you.”

“Oh, Mrs. Di’Maggio, no problem. Anything for Grandma Antonia.”

Nicolette was trying not to fall asleep as everyone was getting ready for the wedding. She hadn’t had much sleep at all. Her mom and Matty’s mom were rushing around making sure everything was in place. She couldn’t help but laugh because that was usually her job, and now everyone else was feeling the pressure she usually felt during event planning. The makeup artist was really too up close and personal for her liking, but her mom made sure that she couldn’t complain about the makeup artist being in her personal bubble. She hadn’t seen any of the guys in so long and she wondered if they were going through the same stress as everyone on her end.

“All done with your makeup. You look stunning. Want to take a look?”

Nicolette looked in the mirror. She’d never looked so captivating in her life. It dawned on her that this was really happening. She couldn’t even recognize herself.

“Oh, my baby... You look so beautiful.”

“Thank you, Mommy.” Nicolette was looking at her mother through the mirror and her mom was almost in tears. She didn’t think that this would be overwhelming, but her mom just made it worse for her.

“Time to get your dress on, love.”

“Okay, Mrs. Di’Maggio. You’re saving me from mom’s waterworks here. She’s trying to mess up my makeup.”

Mrs. Di’Maggio smiled. “Oh my dear, I almost cried too. You’re stunning. I’m thinking Matty might fall more in love with you than he already has.”

Nicolette just stared at Matty’s mom. What did she mean by that? She didn’t know what to say and she had no time to elaborate since Katerina was making her get that wedding dress on.

Meanwhile, Matty was nervous as everyone was getting ready for the wedding ceremony to begin. The thought of being married to Nicolette was making him smile, and the memories of that morning kept a grin on his face.

All the men were getting ready in Matty’s room and they were all in a great mood, cracking jokes and sipping drinks.

“Bro? Why the hell are you so happy? Stop grinning. Are you that happy?”

“Shut up, Gabe… and nothing. It’s just a beautiful afternoon and I’m getting married.”

“Hmm yeah bro, just a beautiful afternoon, huh? Did something happen that I don’t know about?”

“No. Why would you think that?” Gabriel walked over and sat down next to Matty as he put his shoes on

“Oh my God, big bro, I can see it on your face.”

“Well hmm.” Then Matty smiled and winked at Gabriel.

“I am glad to be your best man. I know you’re going to have a great night tonight. Right, Gabriel?” Mitch asked.

“Yes, Mitch. Plus I snuck a peek at Nico when I went upstairs and she looks stunning.”

“Can both of you guys shut up?” Matty was already nervous and he didn’t need them making him even more nervous and curious about what Nicolette looked like.

Both Mitch and Gabe couldn’t help but chuckle at Matty. They knew that he was happy but didn’t want to admit it.

It was now time for the ceremony to start, so the men raced to the backyard. Matty couldn’t help but be nervous. His family decided to have the wedding at Matty’s villa, where there was beautiful greenery in the backyard. On his way up the aisle, Matty saw his family and some of Nicolette’s friends and coworkers there; he was happy that people came to support her.

His heart started to race after the last bridesmaid came in and the flower girl, Matty’s little cousin, came down the aisle. Everything was happening in slow motion for Matty. He just wanted to see his bride-to-be and how gorgeous Gabriel said she was.

Everyone stood up, acknowledging that the bride was approaching. Matty took deep breaths to calm down. He closed his eyes and when he opened them, he saw the most stunning bride ever. She was even more gorgeous than before. He felt like he was falling in love with her even more. Was it the sun shining on her that made her glow? In her wedding dress, Nic looked like a beautiful princess. She wore the dress she’d wanted since she was a child: a ball gown-style wedding dress. He loved that it was strapless and princess cut. To him, it held her breasts just right and looked even more appealing to him. With the veil on, she looked like the best gift he could ever receive. He knew that she was nervous; Nicolette didn’t keep eye contact with him. He knew that he wasn’t alone with all the attention on him or her. Nicolette looked happy with her dad walking her down the aisle. Matty saw how she looked at everyone but him. She looked at Roxy and her other three friends who were bridesmaids, plus Mitch, Gabe, Mike, and Tommy. Nicolette finally reached the minister with her dad, who kissed her on both her cheeks and gave her hand to Matty.

Nicolette knew that this was for show but it felt real for her. She wondered if it felt real for Matty, but suddenly she couldn’t help but savor the moment. She was about to be Mrs. Matthew Di’Maggio!