‘He was probably desperate to be helped.’
‘Yes, I’m sure.’
Tom was feeling his way forward. ‘Do you think Mr Greene ended up drained?’
‘No.’ Very definite. ‘My husband is… well, devoted to the boys, as I’m sure you saw, but on the personal level he can be… quite impervious, as well.’
Tom found himself trying to translate that into terms that might have been used by somebody less admiring (presumably she
was
admiring) of Greene and his work, but the only phrases he could come up with were swingeing.
‘Bernard has a great gift. He can look at somebody and see the best person they could be, and somehow he manages to believe that person into existence. But the downside is that he’s actually rather naive about the way people are now. He’s not shrewd. In fact, I think he rather despises shrewdness, he thinks it’s cynicism.’
Tom was puzzled, and he took a moment to work out why. It was because he’d expected more resentment from this woman who was treated like a housemaid, expected to run and answer the door, sent off to make the tea, then dismissed, abruptly, although she’d taught Danny and might well have had something to contribute. But now, looking round the kitchen, he saw that this, not the study, was the power centre. Seen from this changed perspective, the study looked rather like a playpen.
‘And this suspension of disbelief worked with Danny?’
‘You tell me.’
Tom hesitated. ‘Well,’ he said. ‘They let him out.’
He saw her smile. Tom didn’t want to make the same mistake he’d made with Greene, closing down the conversation by focusing on a topic that produced a defensive reaction, so he asked the most open-ended question he could think of. ‘What was it like dealing with him?’
Silence: the silence of having too much to say. ‘I’m sure my husband told you he got no preferential treatment?’
‘He did, yes.’
‘The whole school was reorganized round him. Everybody thought he was bright, just talking to him, you could tell, but they did a battery of tests and realized he was very bright, so that meant an academic course. A lot of the time he was taught on his own, one to one. Most of the time here we’re coping with illiteracy.’
‘But that was inevitable, wasn’t it?’
She nodded. ‘Yes. And of course he was a child. People responded to him as a child. His housemother fell in love with him. I don’t think that’s putting it too strongly. No children of her own, and suddenly there’s this beautiful little boy. He
was
beautiful.’
‘But it didn’t stop there, did it? I think you’re… well, I think you’re implying Danny worked the system.’
‘Like otters swim. I think most of the time he was so good, nobody saw him doing it. In any relationship, but especially with an adult, he had to be in control. And – well, I think this is why he wasn’t spotted – it wasn’t control as a way of getting something, it was control for its own sake. Little things… it’s a rule the boys don’t call staff by their first names. Bernard’s a great believer in keeping a certain distance, he thinks it’s a mistake to start coming across as somebody’s best mate. Danny used everybody’s first name. And of course it didn’t matter. Except. Another rule: you’re not supposed to be alone with them. If you’re teaching one to one – and everybody who taught Danny did -the door’s supposed to be left open. Either that, or you do it in a corner of the library. With Danny the doors were closed. Not because anything… wrong was happening. It wasn’t. But he’d be telling them something, he’d be confiding in them, he didn’t want anybody else to hear, and they’d be flattered, they’d think: This is great, we’re making progress. I’m the one who’s broken through. And you see the reallydevilish thing? Danny wasn’t breaking the rules. They were. He was very, very good at getting people to step across that invisible border. Lambs to the slaughter.’
‘And one Aberdeen Angus bull.’
She looked surprised, but recovered quickly. ‘Yes.’
‘Did he do all this to women as well?’
‘He did it to everybody.’
‘Including Mr Greene?’
‘Yes. That’s when I first noticed him doing it. I don’t suppose you… no, you wouldn’t. My husband has a, well, a distinctive walk. Danny started imitating it. And there he was, bustling round the school like a miniature headmaster, it was… very funny to watch, and I think most people thought it was a good thing. Bit of hero-worship.’ She paused. ‘I didn’t like it.’
‘And where did Angus fit into all this?’
‘Oh, he came much later. Danny was fifteen.’
A short silence. ‘But the same thing?’
‘Plus.’
A long silence. Tom said, ‘Did he imitate Angus?’
‘The accent. Angus was very Scottish.’
‘And a good teacher?’
‘Very. Though whether he was suited to this sort of work…’ She seemed to come to a decision. ‘Danny started mimicking him, anyway that’s what Angus thought, and he cracked down on Danny pretty hard. He’d no experience with disturbed kids, he treated them as a normal class. Little sprog plays up. Crack down. But you can’t do that here. To any of them,but especially not Danny. You see, all the other kids were on a points system. The.more points for good behaviour, the sooner they got out. But not Danny.’
‘Danny wasn’t going anywhere.’
‘That’s right. Life. He didn’t know how long life was going to be, but he knew it was going to be a helluva long time, and he knew being a good boy in English lessons wasn’t going to get him out of anything. So when Angus cracked down, Danny freaked out. Bounced himself off the walls, tried to break the windows, threw things, generally went berserk. And suddenly it wasn’t a normal class.’
‘What did Angus do?’
‘Saw him afterwards. Alone.’
‘With the door closed.’
‘I shouldn’t be at all surprised.’
‘And then he got Danny writing about his childhood?’
‘Yes. I don’t think he was trying to get at the murder, though I don’t know where else he thought it was leading.’
‘You obviously think it was a bad idea.’
‘Well, from Angus’s point of view, yes. You do know Danny accused him of sexual abuse? He had to leave.’
‘No, I didn’t know,’
Tom was almost too surprised to speak, and the more he thought about it, the more baffled he became. Danny’s silence might be explicable, but what abouGreene’s? What about Martha’s? There was no way this wouldn’t be on the file. Unless… ‘Was there an inquiry?’
‘No. Angus was on a one-year contract. It all blew up towards the end of the summer term. He left a bit early.’
‘With references?’
‘That I can’t tell you.’
‘And the stabbing? Mr Greene said –’
‘Attempted
stabbing.’ She shrugged. ‘Incidents like that happen here all the time.’
‘What caused it?’
‘The other boy said, “Everybody knows you’re MacDonald’s bum boy.” ‘
‘So it was about Angus?’
‘Yes.’
‘Do you believe there was a sexual assault?’
She pursed her lips. ‘There may have been a
relationship.
Not that I’m justifying it for a minute, but… Angus wasn’t the only person to leave over Danny. I can think of another four.’
‘Who had relationships?’
‘No, no, just got over-involved. You’d be amazed how many people didn’t believe Danny had killed that woman. When he tried to stab the boy in the woodwork class, the teacher who was taking the class was absolutely shattered. Not by the incident – by what he saw in Danny, because he was one of the ones who couldn’t believe he was guilty. Danny didn’tpick fights, you see. So it was easy for people to slip into thinking he wasn’t violent. And this teacher said he thought, My God, there it is.’
The tea was cold. ‘Would you like another?’
‘I’m taking up a lot of your time.’
‘Nothing’s spoiling. I’ll put the kettle on.’
She got up and began moving around. Tom watched her thinking that he still had no real idea what she felt about Danny. ‘I’m interested in what you were saying about Danny’s mimicry. If that’s the right word.’
‘No, it was more than that. He…’ She groped for the right word. ‘Borrowed other people’s lives. He… it was almost as if he had no shape of his own, so he wrapped himself round other people. And what you got was a… a sort of composite person. He observed people, he knew a lot about them, and at the same time he didn’t know anything because he was always looking at this mirror image. And of course everybody let him down, because you couldn’t
not
let Danny down. Being a separate person was a betrayal. And then you got absolute rage. Angus had no idea what he was tangling with.’
‘You really didn’t like him, did you?’
A short laugh. ‘I thought he was one of the most dangerous boys we’ve ever had through the school. Bernard thinks we transformed him. I don’t think we even scratched the surface. Or, if anybody did, it was Angus, and look what happened to him.
’
‘Do you know what did happen to him?’
‘Angus? He runs some sort of writers’ centre. So he stayed in teaching, that’s one good thing.’
‘Do you think I could have the address?’
‘Yeah, hang on a sec, I’ll get it.’
He went to the patio doors and stood looking over the garden, while she turned over papers in a drawer. Green lawns, rose bushes, blue shadows creeping over the grass. Beyond the trees, the smooth, windowless walls of the secure unit, as disturbing, in the fading light, as a face without eyes.
‘We used to live in there,’ she said, coming back. ‘Can you imagine? Bernard said it did the boys good to have a normal family living with them. I’m afraid I had to put my foot down, and point out that the normal family wasn’t going to stay normal if we didn’t get a bit of privacy.’
‘It must get quite claustrophobic’
‘It certainly does.’ She held out a piece of paper. ‘Here you are. North Yorkshire. Somehow I always thought he’d go back to Scotland.’
He thanked her and shortly afterwards left. She stood at the door, watching him go, and then, as he started to reverse the car, came out into the drive.
‘Be careful, won’t you?’ she said. And he knew she wasn’t referring to the fading light and the long drive.
FOURTEEN
Towards evening it came on to rain. The river was a confusion of overlapping rings and bubbles, too turbulent to reflect the blackening sky. Tom looked back into the room. ‘I’ve been to Long Garth.’
‘Did you see Mr Greene?’
‘Yes.’
Danny smiled. ‘I won’t ask what you thought of him.’
‘More to the point, what did
you
think of him?’
‘Idealistic. Naїve.’ A slight pause. ‘Vain.’
‘No, I meant when you arrived. When you were eleven.’
‘I admired him, I think. He was like my father. In some ways. Very upright, clean, organized. There was absolute clarity at that school, and it came from him. You knew what the rules were, what the rewards were, what the punishments were, and it was always the same, and it was the same for everybody. You felt safe. I know a lot of people would say the regime there was pretty inadequate. But… you’ve got to start with the basics. You can’t do anything in a place like that unless people feel safe. And we did. We were supervised round the clock. You couldn’t go to the lavatory on your own, you couldn’t close your door, you weren’t allowed to be alone with anybody, you couldn’t go out… It was absolutely bloody terrible, I hated it, but it worked.’
‘And you met Angus?’
Danny looked surprised. ‘Did Greene talk about him?’
‘His wife did.’
‘Oh yes. Elspeth. She didn’t like me very much.’
‘Why do you think she didn’t like you?’
‘Not partial to murderers?’
Tom let the silence deepen round the attempted flippancy of that remark. Then, ‘Tell me a bit more about Angus.’
‘I don’t know that there’s much to tell.’ He was staring at Tom, perhaps trying to work out how much he already knew. ‘He was a brilliant teacher.’
‘Tell me about his teaching methods, then. What did he ask you to write about?’
‘Usual stuff. A Storm at Sea. Masses of purple prose. And then one day he said, “Write about your granddad,” and I wrote about the day my grandfather died.’ Danny was reaching for another cigarette. ‘I hadn’t thought about it for years. He came into the kitchen talking about rabbits, thousands of them, he said, all over the top field, and there were drops of sweat on top of his bald head, grey, like dirty rain. And by midnight he was dead.’
‘Of?’
‘Pneumonia. Old man’s friend.’
Danny seemed to have ground to a halt. Tom said, ‘What else did you write about?’
A smile. ‘ “My Pet”.’
‘Duke.’
‘Yes. He was a bull mastiff, and he was kept chained up in the paddock by the side of the house. He used to watch the geese walk past on their way to the pond. One year he got one, just before Christmas. My grandmother said he’d watched them getting fatter. Quite old, smelly, ropes of saliva hanging from his jaws.’
‘Did you love him?’
A blank look. ‘I don’t know.’
‘Why was he kept chained?’
‘Because Dad liked the idea of a powerful dog, but he didn’t want the grind of training it. Like a lot of things about Dad, it was all show. And when he left home he left the dog behind.’ He laughed. ‘I think I was more shocked by that than his leaving me behind. Anyway, the dog was too big for my mother to cope with. My grandmother felt sorry for him and took him for a walk, and he dragged her through a bed of nettles. So he was given to a man who ran a scrap-metal yard. I used to go and see him in the school lunch hour, and there were notices all over the place. “Beware of the Dog.” There was a little kennel, too small for him to get into, and a bowl with no water in it. I told the other kids it was my dog and they didn’t believe me. I went up and put my arms round him, and he stank. He was hot, he was slobbery, he was a horrible dog. I started to cry.’
‘And that’s what you wrote about?’
‘Yes, and then the battery hens, and the pigs on the next farm. And in the end Angus said, “But I can’t see the people.” And of course he was right. No bloody way was I doing the people.’
‘So how did he get you on to that?’
‘He said, “Does your father use an electric razor?” And I said, “No,” and he said, “Tell me about your father shaving.” Well, that was always a time of enormous tension, because he didn’t shave in the mornings if he was going to be on the farm all day, he shaved in the evenings before he went out. I’d be sitting with my mother in the living room on this leather sofa we had. If you were in short trousers the backs of your legs stuck to the seat, and when you stood up you really yelped. And my mother would be sitting in the armchair, pleating her skirt. On and on, making pleats, smoothing them out, making them again, and… not saying anything. And there’d be this bluthering and spluthering from the kitchen. He always got ready at the kitchen sink, almost as if he was trying to start a row. Because, you know, because he was going to the pub, and he was going to be spending money we didn’t have, buying rounds for people who laughed at him behind his back. And there’d be this… tension.’
‘Did they fight? I mean, did he hit her?’
‘No, he hit me. He hit me to get at her.’
‘So Angus was pressing on some raw spots.’
‘Oh, it was dynamite. I mean, I’d totally blocked off the past. I didn’t have any explanation for why I was in the secure unit. I was just there. I wasn’t there because I’d done anything wrong. I believed my own story.’
‘So why did you go on writing about the past? You could’ve stopped.’
Danny shifted in his chair. ‘I think…’ A sigh. ‘I think I got addicted to the… intensity of it.’
‘Did you feel it was dangerous?’
‘God,
yes.
What the fuck did he think he was doing? Because you look at what he did, he took somebody with hypothermia, and put them next to a blazing hot fire. As soon as the feeling starts to come back, they scream their bloody heads off.’
‘Yeah, I can see that. But then, the other thing you don’t do with hypothermia is to leave people in the Snow.’
‘No, I know. No, I know it had to be done. And then he fell in love with me, and that didn’t help.’
‘When did you realize he was in love with you?’
‘Quite late. I’m not sure I knew at-all till after I’d left. If you mean when did I realize he wanted to fuck me, about five minutes after we met.’
‘And he made love to you?’
‘Yes.’
‘How on earth did you manage that? You were supervised every minute of the day, locked in at night…
‘Well, he was doing the supervising, wasn’t he?’
‘And how long did this go on?’
‘Two months? Not long.’
‘Do you remember how it started?’
‘I was walking past the window of his room, the room where he taught, and I tapped on the glass. He was sitting at the desk, marking books, and he waved to me to come in. And we talked. And that was all we did. But we were alone, and it was an absolute rule that we shouldn’t be, and we both knew that. So there was this casual conversation going on, totally innocent, and at the same time… And then he had to go to a meeting, and that was that. Except he knew I’d tap on the window again, and I knew that when I did he’d wave to me to come in.’ Danny smiled. ‘It was all so bloody repressed you wouldn’t believe. Talk about Jane Austen. And it went on like that for quite a long time. And then one day I brushed against him, deliberately of course…’ He shrugged.
‘But then the headmaster found out?’
Danny looked surprised, almost as if he’d forgotten how the affair ended. ‘Yes, that’s right.’
‘And Angus lost his job.’
‘Yes.’
‘Did you tell the headmaster?’
‘No, I told another teacher. She told him.’
‘And there was no inquiry?’
‘Nobody wanted one. Angus certainly didn’t.’
‘And that meant no more digging into the past?’
‘Yes. Till now.’
Tom took the hint. ‘All right,’ he said. ‘Your father had just left home and you were searching for the present you thought he must’ve left for you, and you found his binoculars.’
‘And more or less went to bed with them for the next three months.’
‘You also said you looked at your mother through the wrong end and she was tiny like a beetle and you didn’t have to feel sorry for her. Did you feel sorry? It implies there was a problem.’
‘Well, yes. It would’ve been a hard life for a woman, at the best of times, but she’d had a mastectomy. She’d lost her hair. She’d lost her husband. For Christ’s sake. That Christmas she got one of the neighbours to kill the geese, and she sat in the shed till midnight plucking them. I went in, and the draught from the door made all the feathers rise up, and they take ages to settle. And when you looked at them every one of them had a little plug of blood at the end of the spine. I tried pulling some of them out, but of course I got bored, and she says, “It’s all right, son. You go to bed.” It was freezing in the shed. And the skin was this horrible dingy yellow, pimply, cold.’ He pulled a face. ‘I hated her because I couldn’t help her.’
The word ‘hate’ seemed to liberate him. 1 hated her because she couldn’t keep him. I hated her for being ill and miserable and bald and ugly and old. I hated the way her nose went red when she cried. And at the same time I was frightened she was going to die. Only even that was mixed because at the back of my mind there was a fantasy: if she dies he’ll have to come and get me.’
‘And it was just the two of you?’
‘Yes, till the cancer came back and she had to have another mastectomy. And then my grandparents came and lived with us. I don’t know how she’d have managed otherwise.’
‘And then your grandfather died.’
‘Yeah, babbling on about rabbits, poor old sod. Gran went back home. She couldn’t do anything — she was ill herself. I think — I’m not sure — I think there was a bit of a breach. I think she blamed my mother for Granddad dying like that. He was doing too much, trying to help, and he couldn’t, his heart was too bad.’
‘It sounds as if there was a lot of blaming going on.’
‘Oh, a tremendous amount.’
‘How did you react to all this?’
‘Went off the rails. Let me see, what was I doing? Starting fires. Once in my bedroom, I think that was the worst time.’
‘How did it feel?’
‘Marvellous. Fantastic. My mother said when she came into the room I was staring at the fire, not doing anything, not trying to put it out. And that was awful for her, because then she felt she couldn’t leave me, and she had to leave me. She’d got a job cleaning, by this time. The farm was up for sale, but it wasn’t selling. She sold all the stock and lived on social security, Dad never sent a penny. And she got this little job, cash in hand, and she used to run all the way there and all the way back, and every time she turned the corner she fully expected to see the place on fire. Then I burnt the barn down. And there was one other little fire in the shed. The rest of it was all outside. But that was with other kids. We lit a fire once that took four fire engines hours to put out.’
‘Did you watch?’
‘Yes.’
‘How did you feel?’
‘Powerful’
‘The opposite of being hung up on a peg.’
A sour smile. ‘Yeah.’
‘And what did you do the rest of the time?’
‘Moped about. Nicked off school. Stole.’
‘On your own?’
‘No, there was a gang of us. Except I think… I don’t know.’
‘No, go on.’
‘I think they were more normal than me. I mean, we used to play at being the S AS behind enemy lines, and we’d be completely lost in it, the way kids are, but then the game would stop for them, and they’d go and do something else. I was inside the game all the time. And then I’d go to call for somebody and he’d come to the door, and say, “I can’t play out today. Me nanna’s coming to tea.” And I’m like, What does he mean his nanna’s coming to tea? We’re the fucking SAS. I was inside the game all the time. I’d be lying in bed at night listening to Mum and Gran downstairs and they were enemy civilians.’
‘And the fire-setting and the stealing?’
‘Part of the game. Setting fire to enemy buildings. Living off the land.’
Any moment now he was going to claim that Lizzie’s death was collateral damage. ‘Who did you steal from?’
‘My mother. Shops. Eventually houses.’
‘With the gang?’
‘Sometimes. Everybody nicked sweets from shops.’
‘And stealing from houses?’
He hesitated. ‘No, that was just me. It wasn’t about money, though I did need it. I don’t know… I liked being in the houses. Being there, breathing the air, leaving all these invisible traces all over the carpet. I liked the idea that when they came back they wouldn’t know.’ He shrugged. ‘It’s hard to explain. Nothing in the house could do anything.’
‘The house was helpless?’
‘Yeah – something like that.’
‘Did your mother know?’
‘She knew about the shops, because I got caught. The newsagent caught me. She had to go to the police station. And then the headmistress wanted to see her, I was playing truant, and then social services got involved. And that was worse than the police. She wasn’t used to anything like that. And she did what somebody like her would do. She talked to the vicar, and he got me into the church choir. Oh yes,’ he added, noticing Tom’s expression. ‘In the middle of all this, I became a choir boy. Only I stole from the boys in the choir, and the vicar came to the house, and said he couldn’t have me in the choir any more. Not fair to the other boys. And that was it, she cracked.’ He was stubbing a cigarette out as he spoke, grinding it flat. ‘After the vicar had gone,’ he said, at last, deliberately, crumbling fibres of tobacco between his fingers, ‘she took the belt to me. The other thing he left behind. I thought, You can’t do this. She lashed out, shouting, screaming, she looked so ugly, and I suddenly thought,
No.
And I caught the end of the belt, and wrapped it round my wrist. And then again. I swung her round and round, and then I let go and she crashed into the wall and slid down it. Her wig was all lopsided. She looked at me and I looked at her, and…’ A deep breath. ‘I ran out of the house. I didn’t go back till nearly midnight.’
‘What were you feeling?’
‘Exhilarated.’
‘Where did you go?’
‘Nowhere. Just walked.’