Authors: Natalie Dias Lorenzi
I feel like an imposter wearing a Cardinals uniform, even if it is seven years old. I hold up my baseball glove like that explains everything. “It belongs to Jalaal.”
She peers at the trick-or-treat bag threaded through my bat. “Yeah, but the cricket uniform is different. You're the only one who has one.”
“Exactly.” Why does she look so disappointed? Why does she even care what my costume is?
Hira tugs at my shirt. “Come on, Bilal!”
I step down off the porch. “I will see you tomorrow.”
Jordan nods. “See you.” And she shuts the door.
I didn't do anything wrong. So why do I feel so guilty?
 Sixteen
T
he end of the fall baseball season is here, and Baba is not. He missed the whole thing. Or maybe he didn't miss anything at all, since I didn't play in a single game.
Today is our team end-of-season party at the Slice of Heaven Pizzeria, with all the Cardinals and the Phoenixes. When Ammi and I walk in, the smell of the pizza brings me back to cricket team pizza parties in Karachi, which makes me miss Baba even more. Lots of other teams are here, including a soccer team with one girl I recognize from school.
Akash waves. “Bilal! Over here!”
Ammi fiddles with her
dupatta
, weaving the ends of the scarf through her fingers. She smiles. “Go on, Bilal. Join your friends.”
It hits me that this is the first time Ammi has been anywhere in America without Auntie or Uncle. Ammi is learning English, but she doesn't speak it very often.
Henry waves me over to where he stands with Akash and some other kids.
“Hey, Bilal.” Akash leans in, lowering his voice. “We're talking about who's gonna get MVP.”
“MVP?”
“Most valuable player,” they say in unison, then look around to see if anyone heard them.
I tune out of their conversation when I look over at Ammi, standing alone and still fingering the ends of her scarf. She moves toward the end of the table and pats a folded napkin, with a fork and knife nested inside, like it's the most interesting object in the world.
Behind Ammi, Jordan walks into the room with her mom. Jordan sees me, then looks away. I don't think she'll come over as long as I'm standing with the guys, so maybe I should go and say hello. I wonder if I could slip away without the guys noticing.
Before I can decide what to do, Coach Matt raises a hand. “Okay, folks!”
We all quiet down.
“First of all, welcome to our end-of-season gathering.”
Coach Pablo nods toward the parents. “Please have a seat.” He waves his hand to the left end of the table and says, “Parents at this end of the table.” Then he waves his hand to the right. “And players at this end.”
All the guys scramble to take a seat, but I am torn. Akash waves me over to a chair next to him, but I keep glancing over at Ammi. She stands back as parents fill in the seats at their half of the table, chatting and laughing with one another. Ammi chooses a chair at the end of the parents' section near the middle of the table. She exchanges a smile with the lady across from her, but then the lady continues her conversation with someone else. Ammi leans her arm on the back of the empty chair next to her. She looks so alone. I am not the only one who wishes Baba were here.
“Bilalâcome on.” Henry jabs his finger at the open seat across from him, the spot next to Akash. I take two steps in that direction, then stop.
“Hold on,” I say. “I need to ask my mom something.”
I slip into the seat next to Ammi, and she looks surprised.
“Bilal, is everything okay?” Ammi frowns and puts her hand over mine. I slip my hand out from under hers, hoping none of the guys saw that.
“I'm fine, Ammi. I just thought I'd sit over here.”
Ammi's face softens. “Bilal, go sit with your friends. Have fun!” She smoothes her paper placemat.
Henry slides into the seat next to me and waves Akash over, just as Jordan and her mom come to stand behind the seats across from us. “Are these taken?” Jordan's mom asks.
“Please.” Ammi nods and points an open hand at the chairs. “For you.”
Jordan's mom smiles and tucks a strip of blonde hair behind her ear. “Thank you.”
Henry doesn't look happy to see Jordan sitting across from us, but he doesn't say anything.
“See?” I whisper to Ammi in Urdu. “Now I am sitting with friends.”
This seems to satisfy Ammi. She smiles and, thankfully, does not try to pat my hand again.
“Pizza!” someone calls.
“Carefulâthey're hot!” a waitress says, placing a raised tray of pizza between Jordan and me. “We've got eight pizzas here to start, with more coming out.” She points at the first pizza at the adults' end of the table. “The first pizza is cheese, then pepperoni, next one's Hawaiian, then sausage.” Now she points to the other far end of the table. “Same lineup hereâwe've got cheese first”âher hand follows the pizza path toward the middle of the tableâ“then pepperoni, Hawaiian, and sausage.”
I was hoping one would be a
mirch masala
pizza, the kind I always used to get. Henry loads up his plate with pepperoni pizza slices, and Akash gets two slices of Hawaiian. Akash takes a bite of the pineapple-and-ham pizza and closes his eyes. “Bilal, you've gotta taste this.”
I scan all the pizzas. “I can't have any with meat. Cheese pizza is fine for me.”
Henry stops, mid-chew. “Why can't you have meat?”
I've never had to explain
halal
to anyone before. Ammi pauses, setting her fork on the edge of her plate. “Go on,” she whispers in Urdu. “I'll help you explain if you need me to.”
Now everyone is watching and waiting for my answer.
“Muslims only eat meat that is
halal
.” I can tell by their faces that my words have not explained anything. “
Halal
means what we are allowed to eat. We can only eat meat from animals that are killed in a very quick way so the animals suffer not so much.”
One mother puts down her slice of pepperoni pizza and looks at it like she's not hungry anymore.
Shortstop Ben says, “Sounds kind of like
kosher
.”
Akash adds, “We don't eat beef at our house.”
Jordan shakes her head. “I make it a point to always avoid eggplant.”
Second baseman Carlos grabs another piece of pizza. “And I don't eat any green vegetables.”
Carlos's mother wags a fork in her son's direction. “I heard that, Carlos Riccardo Vasquez de la Fuente,” she says, and we all laugh.
Everyone goes back to eating, and Ammi gives me a smile. “Well done, Bilal.”
I look at the guys and Jordan. All of us are actually talking and laughing our way through the rest of our pizza, without worrying about baseball. For the first time, it feels like maybe all of us could be friends.
“Ladies and gentlemen!” Coach Pablo stands near a small table filled with trophies and two medals.
Coach Matt joins him. “Hope you all enjoyed the pizza!”
Everyone cheers, including the parents. Even Ammi smiles and calls out, “Very good!”
Coach Pablo puts on tiny reading glasses that I have never seen him wear and unfolds a piece of paper. He clears his throat. “It has been our distinct honor to work with your sons, and daughter”âhe smiles at Jordanâ“this season.”
Scattered laughter ripples through the room, and Jordan's cheeks turn a pepperoni color.
Coach Matt nods. “Every one of you has worked your tail off this season, and it shows. The Cardinals had the winningest record this fall since I've been coaching, and the developmental teamâour Phoenixesâcame a long, long way.”
Coach Pablo picks up a trophy. “Okay, players, when I call your name, come on up and claim your well-earned trophy.”
When they get to my name, Ammi's eyes shine and she claps the loudest. Once everyone has a trophy, two medals remain.
Coach Matt holds up a thick blue ribbon, a medal dangling from the end that glints as it catches the light. “This is the award for the most improved player of the season.”
Murmurs race around the table. For a second I wonder if it could be me, but I don't think I have improved all that much. Henry has gotten a lot better, and he's hoping the coaches will move him up to the Cardinals for the spring season. Everyone has improved, though, so I'm not sure who it will be.
Coach Matt waves everyone down to quiet. “I don't think this will be a big surprise for anyone.” He nods. “This award is going to a player who, before July, had never even touched a baseball or a bat in his life.”
Everyone swivels around and grins at me. My heart fills all the way to the top as I take a shaky breath. Coach Matt gives me a thumbs-up and I give him one back. “This player continues to show up at every practice, at every scrimmage, and gives his best. If he keeps going at this rate, he'll be unstoppable. Let's hear it for our very own southpaw . . . Bilal!”
The room erupts into applause, and my legs feel wobbly as I make my way to the awards table. Coach Matt shakes my hand, and I bow my head as he puts the medal around my neck.
Coach Pablo motions for everyone to quiet down. With his hand on my shoulder, he says one more thing. “We'd like to invite Bilal to play with the Cardinals in the spring.”
I am a Cardinal?
I am a Cardinal!
Everyone is on their feet, clapping and hollering just for me. I think of how loudly Daddo would cheer if she were here. Ammi's eyes brim with tears. I look away from the pride on her face because I know she is thinking what I am thinking, that the only thing that would make this day better is to have Baba here.
As I make my way back to my seat, everyone's hands are out for high fives, and I slap each one until I reach Ammi, who pulls me into a hug.
Jordan offers her high five over the table. “Way to go, Bilal!” Her grin is contagious, and my cheeks hurt from smiling.
It's a good thing that other lefty, Sebastian, picked some Maryland team over the Cardinals, or I might still be a Phoenix.
Coach Pablo picks up the next medal, and everyone quiets down. “This next one is for our MVPâmost valuable player.”
The guys all lean forward in their chairs a centimeter or two. The Cardinals did so well this fall, and there are lots of players who could get this one.
Coach Pablo holds up the medal. “Although this award is called the Most Valuable Player, we want you to know we value each and every one of you.”
Coach Matt nods.
“That said, there is one player who stands out.” Coach Pablo takes a breath. “This player consistently performs well, consistently works hard, and consistently makes a difference on the scoreboard in each and every game.” He smiles. “Please join me in congratulating . . . Jordan!”
Jordan gasps. But instead of looking overjoyed, the color has drained from her face. Everyone claps and some even cheer, but the celebration is nothing compared to mine. No one stands.
Jordan's mom throws her arms around her. “Oh, honey. I'm so proud. Your dad will be so proud!”
Jordan makes her way to the awards table. The clapping continues, and when she turns, her mom stands. I stand, too, and so do the parents. The rest of the team stands, one by one, but there is no whooping or hollering this time.
When she gets back to the table, I high-five Jordan, but Henry and the other guys don't.
Coach Matt calls, “Who's up for dessert?”
Waiters bring out bowls of vanilla ice cream and smaller bowls with sprinkles and toppings. I think about taking my medal off so I won't spill ice cream on the ribbon, but I decide to leave it on and just be very, very careful. I can't wait to tell Baba about winning, and maybe I'll even bring my medal to ESL class to show Mr. Jacobs. I wish I could tell Mudassar.
I bet Jordan's dad will be proud that she won MVP. When I open my mouth to ask when she'll get to talk to him next, she slips her medal from around her neck. She wraps the ribbon around it and stuffs the whole thing in her pocket.
Henry leans over and whispers to me: “Even Jordan knows she doesn't deserve MVP.”
When Henry was a guest player for one of the Cardinals' games, his dad spent most of the time yelling at the umpire, asking if he was blind. I should ask Henry the same thing. I should ask him if he's ever seen Jordan pitch, because she definitely deserves that medal.
But I don't.
Henry goes back to his ice cream and to whatever he was talking about before with the guys.
I try to catch Jordan's eye to figure out if she heard Henry's words, but she doesn't look up. She stirs her ice cream until the sprinkles disappear.
 Seventeen