“Maybe it is, I don't want to be unfair. But I'm sure you'd appreciate my music more if you'd had some grounding in the classical and really serious modern works. But that's my preference, I don't see why it should be yours, and obviously one of the big differences between us. As for films, I thought our tastes were pretty much the same.”
“They are. I forgot. Though for you it's mostly just entertainment while for me a lot of it is art. But I used to love when we were in a theater and I'd turn to you or you to me and we'd with just a look know we both didn't like the movie or stage show and get up and go before it was over. That kind of silent likemindedness happened so many times there and the pity's that it didn't in most other things we did.”
“Like reading.”
“I love writers you hate. And I know it's because they're writing about things closer to my age and past experience, and same with your writers to you. Some we both like, but they're masters or poets, so easy to like, or writing about eternal questions or the few things we both experienced or want to know more about.”
“We forgot food.” .
“What about it? I think we both like the same kinds, except for the meats I won't eat and you do, but that was never a problem. You're also a lot less into the junk thing than me, though you think it's cute that I am. Really, I was partly raised on it, while you grew up when there was almost no junk food and your mother, you even said, strained your vegetables with a hand strainer, which of course my mother, who's almost your age, never would.”
“But junk food's bad for you.”
“They taste good though. But that sort of represents another thing we disagree on. You're so much into health in your own way and I simply haven't come to that point except for my staying away from chemically filled carcasses and dead crap like that.”
“I'll give up all my meat for you.”
“I know you're joking. But there is some truth in it, isn't there? and that's that you'd give up things you like for your woman while I don't want to give up anything for any man yet. But another thing is your mother. Nice as she is to me, she seems like my grand or great-grandâ”
“Don't go overboard. âGrandparent' should suffice. Just âparent' would suffice also if you considered that some adults, like the possibility of myself, have children at a later age.”
“Your possibly becoming a parent I don't want to go into. But I do want my man's parent to be around the same age as mine, so she can get along better or whatever the reason. Though how can she be when the man I'm with is the same age as my father minus two years? And talking about that, people have sometimes looked strangely at us because of it. I know I shouldn't be bothered by such thingsâthat it's so bourgeois as you say for them to think that way. But I do get bothered by it sometimes, probably because I am young and as a result still unsure of myself in some ways, and I want to avoid those looks and talk.”
“Those looks you can get walking with any man. Though I can see how it could bother you if you're in no way in love with that person.”
“Listen, what it comes down to is I want to give myself more of a chance and time, okay? You seem more desperate to be mated now and from everything I said today, I'm not, agreed? And it's not only what I said but all the other things I didn't, all right? And I don't want to talk anymore about it, I just don't. It was nice, different, we had some terrific times, etcetera, and I know the break will be a lot more painful for you than me, but what can I say? You feel more deeply about me than I do you, that's all. And maybe I don't or couldn't because of the age differenceâwell of course that's one of the main reasons because that's what I've been saying all along, true? And I know I've contradicted myself a hundred times in almost everything I said, but in a discussion like this, who doesn't? Andâexcuse me but what was I saying before I started talking about contradicting myself?”
“I forgot,”
“Your memory's not too hot also, but I'm only kidding.”
“And yours? You're the one who forgot what you were saying after you got into that topic about deep and no feelings for me.”
“Oh yes. I was saying that the break, more painful than you, etcetera, and I know why. You think because of your age you'll have little chance of meeting someone new. But for all I know there are many women and even some my age and maybe even younger who might want to be with you because of your age. Sure there areâplenty. But to me your real obstacle in future relationships is that because you've had so many affairs and breakups, you've become cynical about them and women and so they'll never work out or almost.”
“Not so.”
“Believe me, it's so. And maybe you really don't want, no matter what you claim, a longtime relationshipâone ending in marriage and a baby.”
“How can you say that? I'd marry you today and conceive with you tonight if you wanted and we could.”
“You say you would but if I said yes, I'm sure you'd change your mind.”
“Say yes then. Go on, say it.”
“You know I won't. Not to you or any man, as I said, for six to eight years or more. Not that when I get married a man will have to ask me to. I can just as well ask also, right? Or that person and I will just naturally slide into marriage, but a happy slide, without either of us asking the other. But what was I saying again? Oh yes. I really believe that deep inside you want to live alone for the rest of your life. That's why you've lived alone all these years and all your relationships have failed, except for a couple of unsuccessful living arrangements with womenârelationships which eventually failed because of the very living alone reason I gave.”
“Okay, say what you said is true. All of it, right from since we started talking. But now I want to stop that pattern for good.”
“Then do, but with someone else, not me. It will in fact have to never be me. Because when I get to that age where I only might want to get married, you'll be forty-eight or fifty-two or whatever then and so still way too old for me. So you see, it can never change. There's no reason in the world for you to think it can change. At forty-five I might not find a man sixty-six or so that unappealing, but that's so ridiculously far away and I also, if I was going to have a baby, would have had one long before that age. So from this point on the relationship and everything we have to talk about it has to end, okay?”
“Not even as friends?”
“You know that's not all you'd want, and besides, I really have more friends than I can deal with now, but thanks.”
“All right then, goodnight.”
“Goodbye.”
“Right. Goodbye, goodnight and the rest of the goods. I'll see you.”
“Okay,” and hangs up.
I hang up, tell myself to stay calm, it's happened before, though it hasn't happened and hurt so much with someone in a couple of years, pick up the receiver to call her back, put it on my lap and think what am I going on about, because she's right, I am too old for her though her reasoning against my age is mostly bull and my arguments against her reasons are just as full of it, when the phone starts making its off-the-cradle noise and I put the receiver back on.
I dreamt of her. That's nothing unusual. Dreamt of her plenty of times before. About every four months or so since I last saw her three years ago. Since I walked out on her after she asked me to. “Walk out. I want you to,” she said. “Walk. Really. It's no good. For too long it hasn't been good. It'll never be good.” Other things she said. I walked, got another apartment that day, a cheap enough place, hotel I still live in, residential hotel, so I didn't have to bring or buy any furniture. Called her the next day and said I'd like to pick up all my things and she said she'll send them to me with a friend, where am I? I told her. She sent them. Some things I wanted weren't in the cartons and valises. I never called back and asked her for them. That phone call was our last communication. I've thought of her many times since. Haven't pined for her though. I don't mourn for her and never did. I was glad it was over. I loved her when I left her but knew we were never going to work out too. But tonight I dreamt of her. It was a good dream. She was very nice to me in it. She was nude too. Right from the beginning of the dream. Had a darker suntan than she ever got when I knew her. The white marks of a brief bathing suit's top and bottom showed. It must've been summer. The windows were wide open. It was very bright in the room. We were high up, overlooked a river, in a bedroom I didn't and still don't recognize. She smiled, we talked, I forget about what. Something about how you doing, how are you doing, I'm doing fine, I'm doing fine too, “Why don't you take your clothes off?” she then said and when I said “Well, I really don't know,” wondering if the pleasure I'd probably get would be worth the problems I might have to go through later because of it, she took them off for me, or started to. I let her. I wanted to make love very much. Her body was smoother and stronger than when I knew her, though when I knew her her body was very good. Her body in the dream was exceptional. Smaller waist, larger breasts, firmer buttocks, longer slimmer legs. She used to sayâsaid it several times, usually when we were naked on top of the bed coversâ”If I'd been stretched on a rack when I was fourteen, which was when I stopped developing, I'd have a perfect body, one, not that I'd want to be there, good enough for a centerfold.” I never had any complaints. In the dream we made love twice. I was very satisfied in the dream. She seemed to be too. I woke up with an erection, played with myself, lost it. How many times have I had an orgasm in a dream?âforget two, which was how many I had in this one. Maybe once. A few years ago. I vaguely remember it. I forget who it was with but I don't think it. was her.
I do some exercises, dress, make breakfast and leave for work. On my lunch hour I see her. It was sunny and warm when I left the office building and I took off my sweater and jacket and carried them. I took a sandwich and coffee I bought at a sandwich shop to one of the midtown pocketparks. All the tables and chairs were filled. I sat on one of the long concrete benches that run the entire lengths of the park. I'd finished half my egg salad sandwich and was wiping my mouth with the napkin when I saw her. She's with a woman. They're looking for available chairs it seems. I want to shout her name but then think wait awhile. If they start to leave, go after her and invite them to sit with you along the wall. That is, if they don't find two chairs or don't after they don't find two chairs decide to sit against the wall. If they decide to sit against the wall, wave to her as they approach, if it's this wall, and if it's the other wall, go over to them without your sweater and jacket, and food if you haven't finished by then, and ask if she'd mind you joining them. If she does mind, say sorry and leave. If she doesn't mind, go back to where you were sitting, get your things and sit with them. If they find chairs, go over to them. If she sees you before they find chairs or head for one of the walls or start to leave, wave to her as if you just saw her and get up and start over to her. I wrap the second half of the sandwich in the paper it came in, just in case they want something to eat, though there is a small food shop in the turret at the park's entrance, or if they don't have food in their handbags.
Look at her. This morning I'm making love to her in a dream, five hours later I see her in this little park off Fifth. How do you really feel about her? She looks good. That's not answering the question. She points to a table a couple are getting up from and she and the woman start for it. She hasn't seen me yet. I don't know the woman she's with. Aline's blouse is the one I remember from her closet when we lived together and which she never wore during those four years. I once asked her why she never wore it. “My husband gave it to me,” she said. “I don't know why I kept it. I got rid of everything else he gave me except some of the books he didn't inscribe. Besides, it's not me.” They sit and both open their handbags and pull out brown paper bags. Containers come out of the paper bags first. The woman points to the waterfall at the far end of the park and they start talking about it it seems as they pull off the container tops. I look at the fall. It makes a nice sound, drowning out the surrounding traffic and construction noises. They take out wrapped sandwiches and halfâor quarterâpound containers and plastic forks from the paper bags. Cole slaw, potato or noodle salad, something like that inside these containers. They unwrap the sandwiches and pull off the container tops. They eat, drink and talk. Her companion faces me. Aline has her back to me and I can only see a little of her profile now and then. She seems the same. Suppose she saw you, came over to you and said “Hey, let's cab to my apartment and make love for a halfhourâa quickie like we used to do when we were in a rush,” what would you do? She wouldn't do that. It's absurd to think about. Though just thinking about itâwell, that says something. Though we often weren't compatible, our sex till the last month was usually very good. I don't see a woman now, haven't been serious with one since Aline, though I've gone with several women since. One for six months, another for three. I went to Europe with one for a month, spent two weeks with another on a Virginia beach. Suppose she said “Call me,” what would you do? I'd say I don't know. I don't think I want to be with her again. But she wouldn't say that. Or maybe she would, just so we could later talk. “Let's have dinner one night,” she could say, “or lunch, just to catch up on what we've been doing the last three years.” I've no idea what she's been doing. I don't see anyone we both knew from that time. I did for a year. Then the man we both knew moved to Utah and the woman we both knew died. I went to the funeral, Aline didn't. In that first year after we split up, Aline had a lover both those people said. She might still have him. She might be married to him or to someone else and have a child. I'd like to know. I should go over to her. I wanted to marry her and have a child but she kept putting it off. Strange that I dreamt of her this morning and see her now. Stranger that I made love to her in the dream. Stranger still that we made love so much in the dream and I was so satisfied. If I speak to her should I tell her I dreamt of her this morning? Would she even believe me? She used to say I exaggerate too much, that it was one of my problems. Tell her, why not? It's interesting. Somewhat, not very. It's coincidental. It'd also be interesting to see her reaction. I wouldn't volunteer that we made love in the dream. If she asked what were we doing and where were we in the dreamâshe liked to ask that after I said I dreamt of usâI think I'd be cagey. That I'd rather not go into it, or would I say I forgot? No, I'd tell her. What's to lose? I'd say something like “Strangely enough, we were making love. That's the absolute truth. I'm not saying it for effect or making it up. I've nothing to gain or lose by saying it. I know you used to say I exaggerated a lot, but I don't anymore. I've other problems, but not that. So that's why I mentioned the dream. Because it was only hours ago and first one about you in months and here we are now.” If she asked me to go further into it, I'd say we had orgasmsâat least I did: two. “Never in my life have I had two in a dreamânot even in any number of dreams in a month.” If she wanted to know what she said in the dream and what her sex was like, I'd mention her wanting me to take my clothes off and that her last words in the dream after our lovemaking was over were “That was very good for me, I'm sure it was for you.” That's what she said. I remember it now. But I wouldn't go that far in describing the dream. If I said we made love in the dream, she wouldn't ask me anything further about it and I wouldn't volunteer. I think I know enough about her to know what she wouldn't ask. Though it's been three years, I've changed somewhat, so I don't see why I should be that sure about her.