Authors: Mariah Stewart
“Neither do I, but I agree there’s something there, and there are a whole lot of pieces to this puzzle.” He opened his car door and started to get out. Over his shoulder, he added, “I’m hoping sooner or later we’ll be able to put them all together and see the whole picture.”
“Wow, those white columns really stand out against those redbrick walls, don’t they.” Dorsey rolled down the window to get a better look at the home of Aubrey Randall, the self-styled Southern version of Martha Stewart.
It wasn’t a question.
“She certainly does seem to like that antebellum look.” Andrew parked in front of a tidy boxwood hedge. “I could swear I heard the theme from
Gone With the Wind
while we were driving up that long drive from the road.”
“You too? I thought it was just me. Eleanor Taylor’s got nothing on Aubrey.”
“Except of course, Eleanor’s got the real thing. Aubrey’s is all new construction. A mere copy of the real thing.”
“Well, copy or no, I’m impressed.”
Andrew turned off the engine and stared at the house.
“It looks like she’s home. Assuming that’s her Mercedes over there.”
“The license plate is AGR. Aubrey some-middle-name-that-begins-with-G Randall.” Dorsey opened her door. “I don’t see another car, though, so maybe the senator hasn’t arrived yet. Which would be good, because I’d rather we have some time with Aubrey alone.”
“If they’ve concocted a story, for whatever reason, it’s already done. They know what they’re going to say.” Andrew got out of the car and took a good look around. “Nice gardens. Nice horses out back. Very nice.”
“I’d say Miz Aubrey does quite well for herself.”
“She’s a local star on her way to the big time, right?”
Dorsey looked around at the lush grounds and the beautiful house that stood before them.
“I’ll bet it would hurt like hell to give up all this. I’ll bet someone who had all this would fight tooth and nail if they thought they were in danger of losing it.”
“Your point?”
“Just that if this were mine, I’d feel really anxious if something threatened to take it from me, that’s all.”
“Something like a sister who’s supposed to be dead turning up with a record of numerous arrests for prostitution.”
“Yeah. Like that.”
“How do you think those network folks would feel about giving Aubrey a shot at the big time with a scandal like that just beginning to break?” Dorsey said.
“I’d say it would be pretty unfortunate timing.”
“Unfortunate enough that you’d do something really desperate?”
“You know what they say.” Andrew glanced around as they walked. “Desperate times call for desperate measures.”
The path they walked along was red brick to match the house, laid out in a herringbone pattern that led right to the front door. Breezy daylilies grew around the steps in clumps and vied with huge puffs of hydrangea for attention.
“Nice,” Dorsey said again. “Very nice. Tasteful, even, and—”
“Agents Shields and Collins?”
The woman who opened the door was tall and willowy, her features as finely chisled and delicate as her younger sister’s were sharp. Her blond hair curled around her face in a short and charming cut. She wore a pale pink T-shirt tucked into the waist of a slim denim skirt, lots of silver jewelry, and a welcoming smile.
“I’m Andrew Shields, this is Dorsey Collins.” Andrew smiled back as warmly. “Miss Randall?”
The woman barely glanced at Dorsey. Andrew had her total attention.
“Aubrey.”
“Aubrey,” he repeated with a smile meant to charm. “This is quite a place you have here.”
“Well, thank you.” Aubrey Randall beamed as she stepped out onto the small square that served as the front porch. “Would you like a quick tour while we wait for my sister?”
“We’d love it. Thanks.”
“Where would you like to start?” She folded her arms over her chest, her eyes never leaving Andrew’s face. “We have the stables, the pond, the gardens….”
“I noticed some horses out in the pasture there,” he said. “How about we start there?”
“Sure thing,” she drawled and stepped between Andrew and Dorsey. “Are you a horseman, Agent Shields?”
Aubrey sidled up to Andrew and touched his arm in a follow-me gesture. The two of them walked side by side down the walk, leaving Dorsey to roll her eyes and tag along, Aubrey chatting incessantly, Andrew occasionally nodding agreeably. Aubrey was playing the Southern belle, and Andrew was playing along.
“You, there, Sugar Plum. You come on over here and be sweet,” Aubrey called to the chestnut mare that pranced inside the fence. “Come say hello to our new friend, Andrew.”
The horse leaned over the fence just as a car sped up the drive. State Senator Natalie Randall-Scott parked her sedan next to Andrew’s and jumped out. She wasted no time in hurrying over to the fence.
“Natalie, honey, you’re just in time. This is Agent Shields—” Aubrey began the introductions and her sister cut her off.
“I know who he is. Agent Collins, Agent Shields.” Natalie offered her hand first to Dorsey, then to Andrew. “Natalie Scott.”
Before either of them could respond, she turned to her sister and said, “So much for keeping this whole mess under wraps.”
She pointed toward the end of the drive. “I’ve had two news vans following me since I left my office. I had to call the state police to send a few troopers over to block off the drive here and to limit access to my home.”
“So the story’s out,” Dorsey said.
“Apparently,” the senator responded dryly. “Out with a vengeance.”
“Then I suggest we warn Mother and Paula Rose,” Aubrey said.
“I’ve already called everyone. Chief Bowden is on his way over to Sylvan Road. He’ll do the best he can to keep things under control there. I’m wondering if we should move Mother and Father here until this blows over. I think we need to…” Natalie stopped herself, then turned to the agents and said, “I’m sure you can appreciate how difficult this has been for our family. I don’t want our parents unduly harassed by the media. This entire thing has been simply…” She sought the right word.
“A mess,” Aubrey said. “It’s just a damned mess.”
“Aubrey,” Natalie chided her.
“Well, it is. There’s just no other way to describe it. It’s a damn mess and it’s got Momma and Daddy just beside themselves.” Gone was the Southern lady who’d been trying to sweet-talk the hunky FBI agent into forgetting why he was there. “If she was alive, she never should have gone away, and she never should have stayed away all this time. She should have come home.”
“Aubrey, you and I both know Shannon wouldn’t have taken off on her own,” Natalie interjected. “You know she had to have been forced. Kidnapped, maybe by someone involved in white slavery. You hear about that all the time now, but it’s nothing new. Whoever it was who took her forced her onto a path she never would have followed willingly.”
Spoken like a true politician,
Dorsey thought.
“Well, of course she was forced, Natalie. Of course she wouldn’t have done those terrible things if she’d had a choice. But she could have come home before this. She could have escaped and come home
long
before now.” Aubrey crossed her arms over her chest. “I don’t blame her for leaving. I know she didn’t have a choice being abducted back then. But I do blame her for staying away as long as she did, making us all suffer all these years…making Momma so sad and Daddy so bitter.” Aubrey’s eyes welled with tears.
And coming back from the dead at a most inconvenient time,
Dorsey was tempted to add. Instead she said, “I’m sure this has been incredibly distressing for all of you.”
“You have no idea, Agent Collins,” Aubrey addressed Dorsey directly for the first time.
“Do either of you remember if Shannon had been upset or depressed in the days before she disappeared?” Andrew signaled Dorsey that the time for his interrogation had come.
“Not that I noticed, no.” Aubrey continued to dab at her eyes with the tissue she’d pulled from a pocket in her skirt. “If she was, she hid it well. And she was sort of private about things, you know? She wouldn’t have said anything. She was big on writing in her diary, but she wasn’t much for talking about things.”
“Any idea where that diary is now?” he asked.
“No. I don’t remember ever seeing it after…well, after Shannon was no longer with us,” Aubrey told them.
“Natalie, had Shannon confided in you about any problems she might have had?” Andrew turned his attention to the senator.
“I was away at college that year and didn’t get home much. I’m afraid I wasn’t there for her, if she needed me,” Natalie said solemnly. She turned to Andrew and asked, “There’s obviously something going on here that we’re not being told. You’ve been here what, three days, and yet you’re still here asking questions. Why?”
Before Andrew could answer, Aubrey asked, “What do you think happened back then, Agent Shields?”
“Our investigation has concluded that Shannon had not been kidnapped but ran away on her own accord.”
“What?” Aubrey gasped.
“That’s preposterous.” Natalie’s face went stony, much as her mother’s and grandmother’s had. “Why, even your own FBI man back then believed Eric had killed her.”
“For the past six years or so, Shannon was living with a roommate in Deptford,” Andrew told them. “She told the roommate she’d been traveling around the South on her own for years. There’s no question she hadn’t been kidnapped, she’d told her roommate she was a runaway. The question is, what was she running from?”
“Were either of you aware that your sister was a cutter?” Dorsey asked.
“A what?” Aubrey frowned.
Dorsey explained.
“No, of course not.” Aubrey shook her head. “That’s the sickest thing I ever heard. Shannon was not crazy. She never would have done something like that.”
“Girls who cut aren’t crazy,” Dorsey said. “They’re in pain, and they’re trying to find a way to make the pain go away.”
“So they inflict more pain on themselves?” Aubrey snorted. “That makes a lot of sense.”
“It does to those who cut,” Dorsey said softly.
“The point,” Andrew said, breaking in, “is that girls who exhibit this behavior are suffering, most likely from some sort of abuse or trauma.”
“You’re suggesting that Shannon was being abused.” Aubrey’s emotion was gone in a snap, replaced with a cool composure. “That she ran away because she was being abused.”
“I’m suggesting that something happened to her that made her run away. That same something may have been the reason she turned to self-mutilation,” Andrew told her.
“How do you know that my sister engaged in this…cutting herself thing.” There was no trace of Aubrey’s earlier warmth.
“We saw the scars on her arms. And her shoulders, and her legs,” he told her. “They couldn’t have been caused by anything else. We’ve established the behavior. We’re trying to find out what trauma caused it.”
“The trauma of being kidnapped and forced into prostitution would have done it,” Aubrey snapped.
“Aubrey, I think Agent Shields has established that was not the case,” Natalie said calmly. “Shannon ran away—and stayed away—for a reason.”
The sisters exchanged a look that was difficult to read.
“Aubrey, Natalie, I have to ask,” Andrew addressed both sisters, causing them to look at him instead of each other. “What are the chances your father was abusing Shannon?”
“Ridiculous,” Aubrey snapped. “How dare you!”
“Most often the abuser is someone close to the victim,” Andrew explained. “Usually a family member, or a trusted family friend.”
“Daddy never would have laid a hand on any of us that way,” Natalie told them.
“Can you think of anyone close to the family who could have?”
“No,” Aubrey said curtly. “No.”
“I guess we’ll have to ask your father if he has any thoughts on that,” Andrew added.
“Please, don’t.” Natalie touched his arm. “He’s been through so much these past few years. I’m sure my mother told you that he’s never forgiven himself for what happened with Shannon, that he wasn’t able to find her, to save her. If you accuse him of something like this”—Natalie’s eyes filled—“if he thought for one minute that anyone would suspect him of doing such a thing, it would just about kill him.”
“But surely if he understands that someone was hurting her, he’ll want to help us to figure out who it was, don’t you think?” Andrew glanced from one sister to the other. He could not gauge what either of them was thinking.
“Of course he would,” Natalie said crisply. “We all would.”
“By the way, we believe that at some point over the years, Shannon might have tried to get in touch with someone in the family. Did either of you notice a lot of hang-ups coming to your parents’ home, for example? More than what might be considered normal.”
“Everyone gets hang-up calls,” Natalie replied. “I don’t think we had more than our share.”
“No,” Aubrey agreed. “No more than most people have, I suppose.”
“About the funeral services for your sister,” Dorsey said as if it had just occurred to her. “When will they be held?”
The sisters looked as if they each expected the other to answer.
Finally, Natalie said, “I believe Paula Rose is in charge of the funeral arrangements.”
Andrew gave them each a business card. “Call me if you remember anything you think might be important. We’ll be around for a few more days.”
“Ladies, thanks for your time.” Dorsey made brief eye contact with the women, then she and Andrew walked back across the drive to the car, leaving the two sisters standing still as statues next to the pasture fence.
“They know,” Dorsey said when they got back into the car. “They know who abused Shannon back then.”
“You still think it’s Dad?”
“I think he’s the most logical suspect. But neither hesitated for a second to deny it.”
“Let’s stop off at the Randalls’ on our way back to the motel. Let’s see how he reacts when we start giving him our version of what happened that night back in 1983.”
“I think this time, you should call. I don’t think Mrs. Randall is going to be happy to see us show up twice uninvited.”