Holly’s Island: The Complete Collection (4 page)

“Oh, okay,” Holly said.

“So you want the tour?”

“Sure.”

Sara led Holly through the massive house, most of which was
unused and closed off since there were only two people living there. It was in
need of repair, but not as bad as Sara made it out to be. There were rooms that
had been fixed up and she saw signs of repairs in other areas of the house as
well. 

“It looks like you guys are doing your best to fix it
up.”  Holly mentioned when they walked by a partially demolished bathroom.

“Yeah, Caleb was helping us out.  But without him, labor
is pretty hard to come by on the island and expensive, so we've had to put it
on hold.  We've been saving up though.  Ashley’s been working a bunch
of extra shifts and I chip in as much as I can.”

“So what does your mom … I mean Ashley ... do?  You said
she works at the resort?”

“Yeah, she's an assistant manager and also works some night
shifts as an activities director.  It's okay money, but not nearly enough
when you live in a money pit like this.”

“You said you help out too?  Do you have a job? I've
been helping out Caleb, you know being his assistant, but I don't really have
much to do, sometimes it seems like he sort of made up the job just to be able
to give me a paycheck, but there doesn't seem to be many other job
opportunities around here.”

“Ha, yeah that's certainly true. The island is sort of a
wasteland in terms of job opportunities. If you’re not working at the research
center or the resort, then you’re probably a fisherman. The resort is always
looking for good workers. Ashley got me a job there last year, but it didn't
work out … square peg into a round hole sort of situation. But you can always
make money. You just need to supply something that people demand.” Sara said
with a knowing grin. “Caleb taught me that, supply and demand, find something
that the people want and give it to them … for a price, of course. Speaking of
which, what did you think of my box of goodies I left for you to find?”

Holly wasn't sure what to say so she just looked down at her
feet and tried to keep her face from turning an even brighter shade of pink
than it already was.

“It's okay, you can tell me. I'm certainly not going to tell
anyone. You know how embarrassed I'd be if people found out about what's in
that box?”

“Yeah, I guess,” Holly said quietly.

“Well, then talk to me. What did you think?”

“So ... you left it for me to find?” Holly said with her eyes
still on her shoes.

“Well, yeah, I mean I'm not just going to leave something
like that out for just anyone.” Sara said with a big grin.

“But, why me, you barely know me … you didn't know me at all
back then.”

“I had been keeping my eye on you ever since you got here. At
first, I have to admit, I was pretty jealous of you, but then ...”

“Wait, why were you jealous of me?” Holly asked snapping her
head up to look Sara in the eye.

“Well, first off you stole Caleb away from Ashley just when
things were looking serious.  And, honestly I sort of have a little crush
on him too.” Sara said with a hint of secrecy. “Then, after I saw you that
first time reading out on the porch I became jealous of how pretty you are.”

“Whatever!” Holly responded louder than she intended before
quickly lowering her voice, “I'm NOT that pretty … certainly not as pretty as
you!”

Holly blushed hard as she realized what had just come out of
her mouth.

“Oh, but you are pretty.” Sara said confidently as she
brushed Holly's hair back over her ear with her fingers, letting her hand rest
against her cheek. “And that was the main reason I shared my box with
you.  I thought you were the most beautiful girl I had ever seen and I
wanted to show you how much fun we could have together. Did you like what you
saw in my box?”

Holly could only nod and hope that Sara would never remove
her hand from her cheek.

“So, do you think it would be okay if I kissed you now?”

Holly nodded again her pulse pounding as she watched Sara's
beautiful lips slowly move toward her.  Her lips were moist and hot
against her own and when Sara parted her mouth slightly Holly did the same.
Sara's tongue darted into her mouth, gently tracing the outline of her upper
lip and when Holly did the same and their tongues met she felt the wetness
between her legs began to soak into her cotton panties.

Sara pulled away and grabbed Holly by the hand.

“Come on.” Sara whispered and led her into a nearby room.

Holly recognized it as the setting for many of the photos and
her tummy did several more flips just thinking about what had gone on in this
room.  But she didn't have much time to think as Sara's lips were on her
again, but this time there was no doubt as to where it would lead and Holly
wanted nothing more in the entire world.  Sara started at Holly's mouth,
kissing and tenderly sucking at her bottom lip before moving slowly down her
neck leaving a trail of kisses in her wake.  Nibble fingers unbuttoned her
top as an avalanche of kisses followed her warm soft hands down her chest.
Before she knew it her shirt was on the floor and Sara's mouth was gingerly
sucking on her small pink nipples to great effect.  Holly felt on the edge
of orgasm even before Sara's hand began rubbing her pussy through the fabric of
her shorts so it only took a few strokes before Holly's knees went weak and she
collapsed onto the bed shuddering in a monster climax.

Sara didn't waste any time flinging her own clothes to the
floor and jumping on top of the still quivering Holly.  By the time Holly
had recovered, Sara had managed to pull off her shorts and was gently nibbling
on her inner thigh.  When Holly moaned Sara went to work, licking up the
length of her pussy again and again until Holly was poised to fall over the edge
once more.  But Sara held back, going back to the inter thigh and kissing
up to her stomach, over to her cute little bellybutton and down the other side
to the opposite thigh and then reversing course and doing it all in
reverse.  Soon Holly was moaning for release and just when she thought she
couldn't take it any more Sara's mouth latched onto her wet pussy and sucked
hard on her sensitive little clit.  Her orgasm was so intense, so
overwhelming, that Holly couldn't seem to breath, the feeling was so all-consuming. 
It was as if her body had to shut down in order to just concentrate on feeling
so phenomenally good.

Holly couldn't be sure if she actually passed out or if she
was just dazed, but when she came to she was met with the amazing sight of
Sara's bare cunt just inches from her face.  Holly knew that Sara shaved
her pussy from looking at all the pictures so often, but the sight of it up
close and personal was something out of a fantasy. Sara whispered something
like 'my turn', but Holly needed no encouragement and tried her best to
duplicate what she remembered from Sara's amazing example.  She had no
hesitation in tasting her first pussy, but she started slow like Sara had done
with her, kissing around her sex, licking the crease made where her thigh and
outer pussy lips met.  Soon, however, Sara had had enough and with her
position of power she sat her naked cunt right on top of Holly's mouth. 
Holly took the hint and went to town, sucking and tongue fucking her pussy with
gusto.  Sara's pussy juices ran down the sides of her cheeks and she
started to moan in earnest. Holly found her little nub of a clitoris and sucked
hard against it, flicking her tongue across it like she was trying to play her
like a musical instrument. Sara shook hard and Holly grabbed her small ass and
pressed her mouth firmly into her hot, wet, climaxing sex until Sara finally
collapsed onto the bed next to her, her left leg still draped over Holly's sex
soaked body.

“Wow, so I guess you really did like my box!”  Sara
sighed.

“Yeah, I guess I did.  But this was so much
better!  I didn't think it could feel so … so … good.”

“I know. I remember my first time with a girl, it blew my
mind.”

“So can I ask you a question?” Holly said turning to face the
still heavy breathing Sara, “what does it feel like to … you know, have sex.”

“Ha, I hate to break it to you but what we just did was sex
...”

“No, I mean with a boy. You look like you are enjoying
yourself in those pictures and, well, is it as good as this?”

“Oh, you're still a virgin?” Sara asked and Holly nodded
somewhat embarrassed at so easily revealing what was a deeply held secret.
“Well, it's pretty awesome, but it's certainly a different feeling than this.
I'm not sure I can explain it very well, you'll just have to experience it for
yourself.”

“Oh, I don't know … I mean I don't even know any guys here,
let alone one that I would want to have sex with.”  Holly said.

“Well, give it some time.  And you don't necessarily
need to be in love with the guy to have sex with them.  If you both like
each other and want to make each other feel good, then what's the harm. The
island has ways of loosening you up. You'll meet my friends soon enough and
you'll see.”

Holly thought about that for a while and couldn't really see
the fault in Sara's logic.  Then she thought of something that made her
sad.

“But, we're different, right?”  Holly asked quietly.

“What do you mean?”

“I mean … like you didn't have sex with me just because you
wanted to feel good.”

Sara turned over on to her side and looked Holly in the eye.

“Well, that was part of the reason, but if you’re asking if
this … if what just happened between us, and hopefully will keep happening, is
a purely physical thing?  I would have to say no.  I've felt
something for you since the first time I saw you.  I feel connected with
you on a much deeper level than just sex. I just don't know exactly what that
means, but I know I want to find out.” Sara said sweetly and kissed Holly on
the cheek.

“I would like to find out too.” Holly said and then paused.

“What?”

“It's just that you've had sex with all those other girls and
guys … “

“And you want to know if what we have is special? Yes, it is
very special. All those other people are my friends and I love them all like friends
and we all enjoy having sex with each other, but that's it.  With you
there is something more.  You are different.”

Over the next few weeks Sara and Holly hung out
constantly.  When they weren't exploring each other’s bodies, they were
reading, biking, swimming in the ocean, or just lounging around talking. 
It was during one of these chats that Holly remembered something she had wanted
ask way back during her first visit to Sara's house.  They had just
finished another mind-blowing sexual rendezvous in which they had managed to
both orgasm simultaneously for the first time.  Now they were lounging in
the bed naked talking about boys.

“Hey, can I ask you a question?” Holly said in her typical
shy voice during a pause in the gossip.

“Sure, anything at all.”

“Well, remember when I first came over here?”

“Yeah, how could I forget?” Sara said with a lustful grin as
she casually rubbed her finger over one of Holly's pink nipples.

“You never really answered my question about how you make money. 
I mean you always have nice things, new clothes, new bike, an iPod, and you
also help with the costs of fixing up this old house ...”

“Well, it's like I said, I supply something that there is a
great demand for.” Sara said cagily.

“And?”

“Um, it's sort of a big secret.  If I tell you and you
let anyone else know, the whole thing would fall apart.”

“You can trust me, I swear!” Holly pushed herself up on her
elbow and looked down at Sara seriously.

Sara paused before shrugging her shoulders and spilling the
beans.

“Well, because you sort of know already, I guess it won't
really hurt to tell you the whole story.” Sara pulled herself up to a sitting
position and got comfortable. “It all started about a year ago, about a month
after my nineteenth birthday party.  I was having Katie, Sasha, Ben, and
Jacob over here to spend the night. Now up until this point we had been fooling
around, mostly it was just kissing and touching, although I know that Katie and
Sasha were actually having oral sex with each other and Jacob and I had just
had sex for the first time the week before. He's the cute, tall, island boy in
the photos. Ashley was working, of course, and Caleb was in the states picking
you up so we had the whole night all to ourselves.”

“So anyway we were fooling around, Jacob had heard his older
brother talking about blow jobs so Katie and Sasha were trying it out on Ben
and Jacob while I was between Sasha's legs eating her pussy for the first time
when all of a sudden there was old Sam standing in the doorway staring at us
with his mouth open.”

“Oh, my God!”

“Exactly, he had stopped by to pick up a bunch of books my
mom was getting rid of and heard us moaning and groaning. We all freaked out
and begged Sam not to tell anyone. I mean we were all over eighteen, so it
wasn't like we were doing anything illegal, but even on this island a bunch of
eighteen and nineteen year olds having an orgy would make for a pretty
embarrassing rumor.  But Sam was totally cool with everything, he just wanted
to watch.  It took some convincing before Katie and Ben gave in a let him
stay. I think everyone was eventually sort of turned on by Sam watching us, at
least I know I was because I let Ben fuck me that night for the first time.