Between Friends (Friends with Benefits) (9 page)

I gestured toward the couch. “Get in here, you two. I think tonight calls for drinks!” And because I was still desperately trying to get the image of a threesome out of my head, I added, under my breath, “Major drinks.”

*      *      *

“Cool,” Justin said as he took over Doodle play duty from Evan.

“Do we even want to know?” Justin smirked as he dropped onto the couch.

I frowned. “What do you mean?”

“This sudden urge you have to get shit-faced…” He chuckled. “What happened?”

Evan passed Justin a beer before taking a swig of his own. “Probably more drama at work.” He took a seat on the other end of the couch.

I laughed. That wasn’t the reason—not even close. Yet it sounded better than confessing my sudden fascination with threesomes. “Uh, yeah, something like that.”

Justin set his beer on the coffee table next to my laptop. He sat back and rested his hands behind his head. “What are you doing way over there?”

I stared at the two, visions of one of them at each of my doors dancing in my head.

Evan patted the spot on the couch between them. “Get over here.” He grabbed my laptop and put it on his lap. “I want to show you this property I’m going to look at next week. It’s my favorite so far.”

I swallowed the lump that had suddenly formed in my throat. I walked over and sat down between them as nonchalantly as I could. I was apparently pretty bad at faking nonchalance.

Evan made no move to open the laptop, instead turning to me. “You want to talk about it?” he asked.

I waved his concern away. “You know, basic job-stress stuff. Boring. I’ll be fine.” I gave him what I hoped was a bright smile that didn’t look strained around the edges. “I want to see this property you were talking about.”

Evan opened the laptop, poised his fingers over the keyboard, and froze. “Uh… Stace.” His hazel gaze slid from the screen to my rapidly heating face.

The porn site with the various pictures and videos of DP was there in its full glory.

Dear God, if only I could disappear right now, I would be ever so grateful. Love, Stacy.

Justin glanced over at the screen and did a double take. “What the fuck?” He dropped his hands from behind his head as he leaned over me to get a better look. “Dude,” he said to Evan, “you have to play one of the videos.”

“Don’t.” I sank down into the couch as far as I could, wishing with all my might that I could evaporate into thin air.

Evan looked at me with a smirk on his lips. “We’re embarrassing her.”

Justin glanced at me. “Is that true, baby?” he asked apologetically.

I nodded frantically.

He smiled. “Too bad.” He grabbed the laptop from Evan and scrolled through the selection of videos.

I groaned as my face grew even hotter.

“Ooh,” Justin said, “here’s a good one.”

Evan leaned back, putting an arm around me. “What is it?”

“This one has a black woman with two white guys.”

Evan chuckled, the sound close to my ear as he leaned into my side to get a better look at the screen. “Sounds good.”

“Let’s watch this, shall we?”

I buried my face in my hands as Justin pressed play and the sounds of hardcore sex filled the living room once more. I kept my face hidden throughout the entire clip which, thankfully, at five minutes long, was pretty damned short.

When it ended, I reluctantly lifted my head to find two men looking at me with blatant curiosity.

Evan, bless him, cleared his throat and tried to change the subject as he looked up from the screen. “Ready for that drink now?”

I could only offer a weak nod. I wanted to kiss him for being sweet enough to offer me an out during this time of my great humiliation. Justin, however, didn’t have the same reaction.

“Wrong question, dude. What you should be asking is why the hell she’d pulled this up in the first place.” Justin gave me a quick kiss on the neck. “Not that I’m judging you, baby.” He started laughing.

I pressed my lips together and shot him a dirty look. “Look, this is all Nina’s fault. I didn’t even know what a DP was until today, I swear!” They just looked at me, expressionless. “Really, I didn’t! And then Nina starts talking about two guys being at my doors and I was like, ‘Huh? How does that even work?’ and then she’s all, ‘Watch some porn; you’ll learn things.’ And then I did, but only out of curiosity. I mean”—I held up my hands—“I’m not saying I
want
to do this!”

Evan lifted his eyebrow while Justin narrowed his eyes at me.

“Okay, so I probably wouldn’t say no if a situation like, like”—I waved my hand in the direction of the laptop—“this ever presented itself, but it won’t, so can we be done with discussing this?” I took a much-needed breath and tried desperately to fan the heat from my face.

The two men regarded each other silently for a few moments.

Evan, his arm still around my shoulders, pulled me closer. “Do you want to do this, Stace?”

I sighed. I wasn’t in the mood for being made fun of anymore tonight. “No.” Oh, hell. Who was I kidding? The thought of both these men inside me at once made my pussy throb like never before. “Yes,” I said softly. I didn’t dare look at either of them.

In one of Justin’s rare gentle moments, he slid a finger along my jawline and placed a tender kiss beneath my ear. “You know we’d give you whatever you want.” He kissed me again, this time near my lips. “If you’re sure.”

I have no idea how I spoke, but I managed to eke out, “I’m sure.” Whoa, new Stacy was about to go to a level she’d never even knew existed. I was scared as hell, but my desire for these two wouldn’t allow me to put on the brakes.

Justin pulled my face toward him and slipped his tongue into my mouth. I was tense at first, kissing one of them in front of the other, but my bones were quickly turning into mush. I returned his kiss with fervor before Evan turned my face to him. I was kissed again; his tongue working its magic against mine. At the same time, I felt Justin’s tongue making a wet trail down the side of my neck. I moaned.

I could get used to this.

I wasn’t sure of the protocol for threesomes, having been so sheltered and all. I ushered them into my bedroom as I went to the bathroom and tried to sexy myself up as much as possible. I stared at my reflection in the mirror. Thank God my bra and panties not only matched, they were cute. I tousled my hair by bending over and letting it fall to the front and then flipping it back as I straightened. I ran my fingers through it and frowned at myself in the mirror. Was this sexy enough?

“What the fuck are you doing in there, woman?” Justin yelled.

I smiled. “I’m coming!”

“Not unless you get out here, you’re not,” Evan said.

He had a point there. I laughed and took a deep breath as I opened the bathroom door. My knees were shaking so bad, it had to be noticeable. I just wished myself luck and made my way into my bedroom.

“About time,” Justin said, letting his eyes roam over my body. He whistled. “Nice.”

“Very,” Evan said.

I licked my lips as I looked at them. They both stood in front of me wearing nothing but boxer-briefs that left little to the imagination. Their cocks were hard and ready for me. I couldn’t remember ever wanting anything else more. I’d never gone down on either of them before, but tonight was a night for firsts. This was probably my one and only time doing this whole threesome thing; I planned to make the most of it. Bold Stacy was in full effect.

I walked up to stand directly in front of them and reached my hands out to rub both their dicks through their underwear.

Evan moaned and leaned down to kiss me.

“Shit.” Justin covered my hand with his own as he took his other hand and slipped the straps of my lacy, red bra down.

Evan reached around me to unfasten the bra and it fell to the floor.

They each bent down, taking a breast in each of their mouths. The feeling of two mouths suckling, two tongues flicking against my hard nipples was more than enough to make my pussy wetter than ever. Could I handle sex with these two at once? I was about to find out.

I dropped to my knees as I looked up to see the surprise on both their faces. I pulled their boxers down and was faced with two beautiful, thick cocks. I ran my tongue over my lips again before darting my tongue out to lick the head of Justin’s shaft as I stroked Evan’s. He gasped as I took him fully into my mouth. I sucked Justin’s dick for a while, reveling in the taste of him, before turning my attention to Evan while my hand worked Justin’s cock.

After licking on the head of Evan’s dick, I slid my mouth down the full length of him. Well, as much as I could. They were pretty big boys. I closed my eyes as their moans washed over me. Evan tasted as good as Justin did; I never thought sucking dick could be something to be enjoyed by the giver. Nina had sworn it was true, but I’d remained doubtful. After having these men in my mouth, I was a believer.

I alternated my oral attention until they both were close to coming. Justin picked me up and threw me on the bed. He spread my legs wide as he began to eat my pussy. Evan stroked his cock as he leaned over to suck on my nipples. I dug the fingers of one hand into Evan’s back and buried the others in Justin’s dark blond hair. The dual sensations had me on the brink right from the start. There was no way in hell I could keep quiet. I gave my neighbors a mental apology for the restless night they were about to endure.

I cried out as Justin’s tongue slid back and forth over my clit just as Evan’s did the same to my nipples. Justin eased a finger into me, then two. They worked their magic along with his tongue until I screamed.

“Can I have some of that?” Evan asked, tapping Justin on the shoulder.

Justin moved to the side reluctantly, but held my stare as he slid his fingers into his mouth and sucked them clean.

Evan threw my legs over his shoulders as he had his turn eating my pussy. He wasted no time lavishing attention upon my now ultrasensitive clit.

“God, yes, yes,” I panted. I reached for Justin with one hand while my other pushed Evan’s head further in between my thighs.

Justin kneeled next to my head. I turned toward him, taking his cock in my mouth once more. I would have loved it anyway, but having a mouthful of him really helped to muffle the sounds I was making in response to Evan’s actions on a lower part of my body.

Soon, Evan’s fingers were inside me, working in a slow, hot rhythm as I moved my hips against both them and his tongue. Justin’s ragged breathing and dirty talk were completing this scenario nicely.

“Fuck, baby,” Justin said, squeezing my breasts, “that’s right, suck it. Suck my dick, you dirty girl.” He threw his head back and closed his eyes. “Ooh, shit,” he said roughly.

I was about to come from what Justin had started and Evan had finished. I clenched my thighs around Evan’s head and bucked against him, crying out, only the sound was muffled by Justin’s cock. The vibration of that must have really done something for him.

He moaned loudly before yelling, “Fuck!”

One orgasm was not nearly enough. I was insatiable. I took my mouth from Justin long enough to tell Evan, “Get up here. I want your cock in my mouth too.”

He wordlessly complied, coming to kneel on the other side of my head as Justin moved to kneel between my legs. Justin rubbed his thumb over my clit as Evan’s dick became the one to quiet my screams. Justin leaned over me to suck one of my nipples while Evan’s hand fondled my other breast.

“Mm,” Evan moaned as I sucked him, “shit.” He sucked in a breath. “Yes, yes, just like that.”

My pussy was soaking wet. I needed them inside me before I exploded. Though I’d never even been tempted to take a dick up the ass, I was now grateful that I’d always needed lube with Nathan. I’d never been an easy woman to get wet, but that had all changed now. Still, the lube would be much appreciated in light of what I was about to have done to me.

“Fuck me,” I pleaded. I squeezed and played with my own nipples with one hand while I slipped the other one down to rub my clit as I watched Justin and Evan jack off while watching
me
. I felt like the star of my own porno and I fucking loved it. I had never felt so powerful, so uninhibited before.

This
had been the point of my sexual revolution. All along, I’d been heading toward this realization; it finally dawned on me. Still… I wasn’t about to stop until I’d reached the ultimate climax.

They put on their condoms and both looked at me with their eyes narrowed and their heads tilted.

I was so horny; I couldn’t be bothered to feel self-conscious. I continued to masturbate right in front of them. I closed my eyes and moaned as I imagined my hands were theirs.

“Front or back?” I heard Justin ask.

“I’ll take the back this time.”

Silence. “
I
wanted to get in her ass.”

“Then why’d you ask?”

I smiled and opened my eyes. “Boys, boys, play nice. If Evan has my ass this time, it’s all yours next time around, baby,” I said, giving Justin a sly look.

“Damn right it is,” he said, throwing Evan a harsh look. “Fine.” He tossed the lube to him.

I watched with interest and desire as Evan spread some over his cock. I couldn’t help but continue to play with my pussy as I thought about where that big dick of his was about to go.

Evan tossed the lube aside after putting a bit more on his finger. “Turn her over.”

“Come here,” Justin said, roughly flipping me over.

“Put that sexy ass in the air,” Evan ordered.

I obeyed, all the while rubbing my clit. I felt Evan’s finger sliding around my asshole, spreading the lube around before he suddenly slipped it in. I gasped.

“Just warming you up a bit, baby,” he said.

I heard Justin chuckle.

Oh, I was plenty warm already. And that heat only intensified as I felt Evan’s cock pressing against my tight hole. I felt a stretching, a slight burning that bordered on absolute pain, but stayed just this side of uncomfortable as my body tried to adjust to such a foreign sensation. Evan began to move, slowly and gently, allowing me time to become accustomed.