Finding Their Son (4 page)

E
LI HEARD
C
HAR’S CRY
of alarm but he was too numb to react. A drum was thumping inside his brain. The words she’d written in a girlish combination of print and cursive seemed burned into his mind.

Guess who took care of him? Yep, me. And by
took care
I mean what you think. Why? Because I knew I’d never get another chance. Who wouldn’t make love to a god?

She’d spent two pages describing a night Eli could barely remember. His bachelor party had started out like any other party. His cousin—and then best friend—Robert had taken him out to Lake Sharpe to meet a bunch of friends and teammates. At some point in the night he and Robert had gotten into a fistfight. Eli couldn’t remember what they’d been fighting about. He vividly recalled everyone freaking out.

“Holy shit, Robert,” someone had shouted. “Bobbi’s gonna skin you alive if Eli shows up with two black eyes and a broken nose.”

He vaguely recalled Robert helping him stumble up to the back door of the dyke nurse’s house. Everyone knew
her sexual preferences—even if nobody in their right mind would have openly “come out of the closet” in such a conservative and close-minded atmosphere. The truth didn’t keep people in need from seeking her services. Got an itch that probably didn’t come from a toilet seat? Go see the elder Jones sister. Need stitches but can’t afford the E.R.? Pam Jones would help you out for a few bucks, a barter or for free, if it came right down to it.

People like Eli went to Nurse Jones when you didn’t want your business spread around town. He sorta remembered knocking on her door, but not much after that. He had no memory whatsoever of what Char had written. And he wasn’t sure he even believed any of it. Especially the part that showed up toward the end of the book.

I haven’t written for a long time because I didn’t want to take a chance on Mom or Aunt Pam finding this and reading that I was pregnant. I didn’t think it could happen from just one time, but it did. Too bad Eli’s happily married and living in San Diego.

Now that Pam’s found out, I’m not sure what’s going to happen. Mom threw her usual hissy fit. There’s talk of sending me to live with Aunt Marilyn in Montana. Like that’s going to happen. I’d run away and take my chances on the street before I’d put my baby within a mile of that creepy uncle of mine. All I know is it’s hard to be miserable when you’re carrying Eli Robideaux’s baby.

The door wrenched open. “Give me that. You had no right.”

He looked at the irate woman with the weird hair. She
was leaning in, her hand extended. It shook with barely concealed fury. Or fear. He didn’t know. He couldn’t think and that made him more pissed off than he’d been all day.

“You’re a liar. This didn’t happen,” he cried, crushing the notebook in his fist. It felt good to yell at someone.

She yanked the book from him and pressed it to her chest. Her voluminous chest. A tiny hint of something akin to a memory flitted through his brain.

No. It didn’t happen. She was a messed-up kid with a big-time crush. I wouldn’t. I didn’t.

“I don’t lie. Get out of my car.”

He looked from the notebook flattened against her pumpkin-colored sweater to her face. A stranger’s face. “I’d remember if that happened. I’m not the kind of guy who went around screwing innocent little girls.”

She dropped her chin in a challenging way. “Really? That number below your name in the yearbook—twenty-three, wasn’t it?—didn’t match the number on your basketball jersey. I always heard it stood for the number of girls you—”

“No.” He put his hand to his face and groaned. “That was a joke. Robert started that rumor. It wasn’t true. Not even close. I wasn’t a saint, but still…”

“You were passed out drunk when your cousin dropped you off at my aunt’s back door. He basically carried you to the gurney. She was on duty at the hospital. I was going to let you sleep it off, but you woke up. We talked.”

He tried to picture the scene. If he could recall what she looked like back then, maybe he could figure out what was true. But even studying her face didn’t bring back anything. “What did we talk about?”

“Your situation. The fact that Bobbi was pregnant and that was why you were marrying her.”

“I wouldn’t have—”

She interrupted. “Everyone knew it. You weren’t spilling some big secret. My friends believed she got pregnant on purpose to trap you into marrying her. I told them you were too smart for that.”

“Dumb, you mean. Blind, smug and dumb. That was my dad’s opinion. But the point is I was loyal. I wouldn’t have done what you wrote. Not on the night before my wedding.”

She took a step back. “Really? You’re sure about that? You can’t remember anything. You don’t remember me. But you’re sure.”

He hated having to swallow the lump that suddenly developed in his throat before he could answer. “Yes.”

“Then how do you explain what I wrote in my journal dated that night?”

“F-fantasy?”

“Why? Why would I make something like that up? On the off chance that you became president someday? Maybe I was a fifteen-year-old blackmailer? Maybe I’m crazy and this is a plot to screw with your head?”

He kicked the heel of his boot against the floorboard with such force the entire car shook. “How the hell should I know? You tell me.”

She gave the notebook a shake. “I did. You read it yourself. Firsthand observation trumps vague recollection every time.”

She had a point. If he weren’t so messed up and his head wasn’t pounding like he’d been on a three-day binge, he might have conceded round one to her, but he couldn’t.
That would lead to a can of worms he didn’t have the energy to think about, much less let loose.

He grabbed the hood of his sweatshirt and yanked it upward. Sinking in the seat, he did his best to disappear. “I can’t believe this is happening,” he muttered. “Talk about going from bad to worse. If I ever get my hands on that dumb-ass uncle of mine, he’s going to wish he’d never been born. ‘A part of you is missing, nephew,’” he said in a singsong voice. “‘The answer you seek is in
Paha Sapa
.’”

His disdain for the Black Hills couldn’t have been missed.

“Was that supposed to be your impression of Joseph or Yoda?” she asked sardonically.

Her tone was less angry than it had been, but he heard a tremor of bruised feelings. He’d done something—whether intentional or not—that affected her back in high school. She’d been a kid.

So was I.

But that argument didn’t hold water because he’d never really been a kid. His parents’ loud and turbulent love-hate relationship, their divorce, his mother’s remarriage and subsequent death from ovarian cancer when Eli was thirteen contributed to his very truncated childhood. He’d grown up too fast. People had depended on him from a very young age. His mother. His younger half siblings. His alcoholic father. Then Bobbi, who was by far a better mother than she was wife.

What did the county shrink call him? An enabler. He’d enabled the people he loved to take advantage of his need to be needed. A character flaw that probably contributed to his decision to go into law enforcement.

“Can you take me back to the main road? If not, I can
walk there.” Liar. He’d probably fall flat on his face if he made it a block.

She didn’t answer right away but a few seconds later he heard her sigh. “Okay. I said I’d take you to Sturgis and I will.”

As she walked past the front of the car, Eli caught a glimpse of her profile and a shiver of recognition traveled from the nucleus of his brain to the tips of his boots. “Boobs Jones makes my Johnson hard” someone had scribbled on the door of the boys’ can. He might have had a wet dream or two at her expense himself. He couldn’t say for sure, but there was always plenty of speculation over the exact size and shape of the breasts freshman Charlene Jones kept hidden under her bulky sweatshirts.

Which, he told himself, was the main argument against her story being true. If he’d had a chance to see and/or touch Char Jones’s nubile breasts, the image would have been seared into his brain—even if he was on a gurney in her aunt’s kitchen with a possible concussion.

“Why would I blank out something like that?” he asked as they backtracked through town. A few of the landmarks, like the stupid little dinosaur next to the Civic Center, looked familiar thanks to the television show he’d caught a couple of time with his daughters. But at the moment he didn’t gave a rat’s ass about seeing it.

“How would I know?”

“Were you on top? Or was I?”

The passenger-side tire dropped into a rut on the shoulder of the road. It took her a few heart-stopping seconds to recover. Enough to make Eli’s knuckles turn white from clenching his fists. “Forget I asked. Dumb question.”

“You’d been in a fight. For all I knew you were suffering from a concussion. I did my best to keep you calm and stable until my aunt came.”

“By jumping my bones?” he asked, reserving the right to use blunter terms later on.

“Not at first.” He looked at her and saw how pink her cheeks had become. A pretty color that made her look a good twenty years younger than he felt. “I was treating your cut when my aunt called to say there was an accident on the bridge and she wouldn’t be home for several hours. She wanted me to know my mother wasn’t involved.”

He frowned, confused.

Char took her hand off the wheel and made a wobbly motion. “Aunt Pam had a police scanner, and on the nights my mom was late coming home, Pam knew I’d sit in the kitchen listening. Mom partied a lot.”

He understood. His father had lost his license twice that Eli knew of. “Did you tell your aunt I was there?”

She shook her head. “I’m not a doctor, but even I could tell that cut above your eye wasn’t life threatening. I managed to close it with two little sutures and a bandage. My only real concern was whether or not you had a concussion. I figured the best thing I could do was try to keep you awake.”

“And you figured the best way to do that was by having sex?”

His cynical tone made her scrunch up her face and sort of duck her head. The car wove slightly between the two lanes. “Maybe we should talk about this later.”

He searched his memory again, trying to pull some image to mind that might back up her story. What did the place look like? Nothing. Was the treatment room her
kitchen? He didn’t think so but he couldn’t say why. Was he on a gurney? He’d seen all kinds on the job. If the one he’d been on had wheels…he couldn’t picture making love on the move.

“Where’d we do it?”

She shook her head, as if she’d been expecting the question. “Pam saw patients in a small room off the kitchen. It was a screened porch when my grandparents lived there. She bought a used examination table from an old clinic. The back was raised about like this.” She held her hand horizontally between them then made the fingers tilt upward to a sixty-degree angle. “I thought it would be better to keep your head elevated.”

He could have said something coarse but he managed to bite his tongue. “You were on top?”

“Yeah. It seemed safer—concussionwise.”

He turned to look at her, but it took too much effort to keep his gaze off her chest so he slumped again and closed his eyes. “Do you really expect me to believe that a virgin would climb on top of an injured guy in her aunt’s makeshift E.R. where anybody could walk in?”

He heard her take in a deep breath, but he willed his eyes to remain closed.
No leering
.

“It didn’t take all that long, Eli. I put my hand down there and you were instantly hard. The smart thing would have been to give you a blow job, but I didn’t know how.”

His eyes popped open. “What do you mean you didn’t know how? That’s a no-brainer.”

The car made another unscheduled jog across the middle divider as she tossed up her hands on the steering wheel. “I’m sure I could have figured it out, but at the time, I didn’t want to look like a novice. Everyone said Bobbi
was the best in school when it came to giving bj’s, and since you were marrying her the next day…”

He groaned, wishing he’d never asked. His soon-to-be ex-wife was a topic he had no intention of discussing. “So you got naked and hopped on top of me?”

“You wish,” she sputtered, tapping the brakes to round a curve in the road. “Like you said, anybody could have walked in. As it happened, when Robert brought you in, it was past midnight. I’d already changed into my nightgown.”

Nightgown?
A tingle of something he didn’t want to acknowledge shot down his spine. He gulped loudly. “Pink flannel?”

Her shoulders lifted and fell. “I don’t know. Maybe. Yeah, actually, I think it was. We had a warm spring then suddenly in early June the weather turned cold. I remember someone saying if it snowed on her wedding, Bobbi was going to make the weatherman pay.”

He muttered a string of words he’d have busted his son’s chops for using. He’d had a dream for years that he secretly called his guilty pedophile dream. Only now he knew it wasn’t a dream, it was a memory.

Neither said anything for several miles. They were approaching the intersection of the main highway—he knew because he could see the cross-members of her teepee—when he worked up the nerve to ask, “So you had an abortion, huh?”

“What?”

Her shriek made the hair on the back of his neck stand on end. She stomped on the brakes so hard he had to brace his hands on the dash, despite the safety belt that cut into his chest. The rebound slammed him against the seat.

The car slid sideways to a stop in the gravel driveway they’d left an hour or so earlier. “Get out. You’re not the man I thought you were. Back then or now. Go. Take the money I gave you and leave. Now.”

She reached across him to open the passenger door. Her body touched him—that is, her wool jacket pressed against his grubby thermal sweatshirt, which covered a couple of other layers. There was nothing sexual in the touch. Nothing sexual between them. Only anger and hurt on her part, and confusion and desperation on his. No reason in the freaking world for him to kiss her.